COMMUNITY ARCHIVE Selected reading edition · 2014–2020
Play With Your MusicCommunity archive
← Community & more

By Skill/Experience Level

Mix Engineers or Aspiring Mix Engineers

33 readable posts · 1 retained privacy notices · Team contributions are labelled separately from community replies.

I'm a full time mixing engineer (NYC), and honestly I'm a part of this to constantly expand my education, hear some new perspectives, try some new things, listen to some great music and be inspired by many. I figure it's reasonable enough to make a 'group' of people that are either currently mixing primarily, or have the goal to do so.

Post #2 is omitted from the public reading edition to protect personal information.

Hello! Image omitted from this public edition

Kevin here. Anxious to learn new things and / or review previously learned things.

Hi, I'll join up here too. I do recording, mixing, and mastering on a small scale -- mostly my own projects and those of my friends. I'm starting to expand a bit and take on more projects though and it may become more primary for me in the future. I took this course last time and even though I've been doing this for decades, I still found it interesting and enlightening. Expecting it to be even more so this time around.

This sounds like a good place to join up. I've been mixing my own music now for about 15 years (starting with Goldwave), and have only been multi-track mixing for about 6 years. I'm still a noob when it comes to some of the more complicated processes and techniques, and I'd love to learn more.

Production is definitely where my interest is now. Got a home studio… spent a lot of time with ProTools, but i've settled on Ableton… It just works better for my needs. My main focus right now is mixing, producing my own albums, and then performing them. My performance needs really do require Ableton and Max for live. This is an amazing opportunity to learn from the more experienced guys out there about the art of mixing.

Looks like my kind of group. Hi everyone. I'm Jim. I'm new to mixing and music production in general. Saying that, I've been fascinated by how recordings sound for a long, long time and always have wondered how it is done. I've had many false starts trying to learn on my own. I get frustrated or turning in circles and just quit for awhile but I keep coming back to it. It's what I want to do. I'm really looking forward to learning as much as I can from this course.

The first world problem. I'm currently into mixing, experiencing lack of skill, but still there's so much other stuff I'd like to learn… What to do? Sign in to all the groups of interest? I'll take a try, and keep an eye on You guys. Image omitted from this public edition

Michael from Dunedin, Florida here. Looking to be a mix/recording engineer and am currently training on an SSL over in Clearwater. Glad to be here with all of you!

Hi, I'm Paul from the UK. I'm definitely interested in learning more about mixing. The drummer in our band used to do the mixing and mastering of our tracks, but he's gone now so it's an opportunity for me to learn.

I've been dabbling in Pro Tools for a while, but only basic stuff, so anything I can learn (concepts, procedures, etc.) will be welcome.

Hey There,

Im Jesse and I am also from NYC. I have a strong background in the flute and drums, as well as, some interest and experience in messing around with mixing. i am hungry to learn and look forward to what you can teach me. I consider myself a novice

Hi guys, I'm Kevin L. and I'm an amateur audio engineer and producer. I've been recording a long time though. I first got the bug back in about '81 or so when a roommate brought over two cassette recorders; one that could play only and the other that could play and record simultaneously. "Wow! I can overdub".. That was quite a revelation back then..

I've been constantly trying to improve since then, and so, that's why I'm here at #PWYM.

In the spirit of sharing and learning, I posted an introduction to ducking audio using compressor sidechaining in the Logic X meet. It's nothing new to you pros and experienced guys, but maybe some folks will get something out of it.. and maybe the more experienced folks here will correct or add to it.


Ducking Audio With Compressors

Ducking is reducing the volume of one or more audio tracks based on the volume of another. One example would be to reduce the volume of a music track in a commercial while a voice-over is being spoken, then allowing the music to increase after the voice-over completes.

This is also useful in audio mixing. For example, having the bass guitar's volume lowered or ducked whenever the bass drum plays. This could be done manually using the bass guitar's fader or drawing volume reduction automation, however, this may not be practical because it might require lots of volume automation throughout a song depending on how many times the bass drum plays.

One solution would be to use a compressor on the bass guitar track sidechained to the bass drum track. The idea is that the bass guitar audio will be attenuated whenever the bass drum plays. The bass drum controls the compressor on the bass guitar track through the sidechain.

Here's the video I made using both a bass synth and synth pad with compressors sidechained to the bass drum track. Bass synth compressor is on the left and synth pad compressor is on the right. Listen especially to the synth pad. Every time the bass drum plays, the synth pad volume is immediately reduced, then the compressor releases and volume increases until the bass drum plays again and the process repeats.

This is a pretty aggressive use of sidechained compressors sometimes used in dance/techno type music for a "pumping" effect, but it can be used more subtly and in different ways on other types of music.

Embedded media omitted from this public edition

Hi everybody, I'm a drummer and I like recording my acoustic drum kit (and other instruments).
It's a very complicated (but wonderful) matter... I record 10 track at home, one for each piece. I'm very interested in all recording and mixing techniques.

I don't work with recording and mixing but my specialization and work is about Room Acoustics, transmission loss and sound absorption of building elements. I work in a University laboratory as a researcher... but my dream is to play, record and mixing! Image omitted from this public edition

If you have some Room acoustics questions, I'm here

Hey, that's a great video. I'd been wondering how sidechaining and compression worked like that for a while. You gave me a good excuse to figure out how Reaper does it. Thanks.

You're welcome. It's been a while since I've used Reaper, but iirc, it has a compressor and gate with sidechain capability.

hi, I'm Rashaune Dalbany. I finally to join here.

Hi, Im Glenn Better Known as Mikro! young Rapper And Mix Engineer! Follow me on Soundcloud [participant mention]

Hi, i'd like to join you too! I'm musician with 15 years of experience, many bands, recorded two albuns and looking forward to lern from mixing tecniques!

Participant 366 here…recorded music for nearly 30 years…always looking to improve my mixing skills…look forward to hearing new ideas!

Hello! I've been a recording engineer for over 30 years part time, have done several albums using analog and digital media. Actually prepared tape masters with splices and leader tape!

I have a studio at home and do mixing and mastering at a small studio with a friend who is a music teacher and a great musician. I'm mentoring him and continuing to sharpen my skills. I always want to continue learning and sharing. I feel like I'm JUST NOW starting to be decent at mixing.

Well better late than never...

Image omitted from this public edition.

This graph addresses the intro of the song only. The bass is heavily distorted and compressed. The toms which follow are distorted and compressed as well. The cymbals are gated and panned hard left and right.

Next, the background vocals are delayed, stuttered and gated. They're panned real wide too.

The drum kit has a narrow pan and are rather dry with hand claps just off to the right.

The toms come in again but are panned to the left with a guitar effect countering to the right.

A distant background vocal, delayed, stuttered and gated, enters ping-ponging left to right. Thereafter, the bass reenters but doubled with a male vocal.

Listen to the song here: [external link withheld] [link withheld]

This song is unique in its arrangement and disparate use of parts. Very disruptive and disconcerting but works when put together. Quite innovative.

Participant 366

Thanks Marc for choosing a challenging song. The guitar effect is hardly recognizable, at first it feels like the tribal cry of an African voice. The other thing I’m disconcerted about is the position of the cymbals and hand claps. To my ears, it seems that the hand claps are panned hard left and right. The reverb on the cymbals is definitely wider than usual, but I’d still put them a little more central, closer to the drum kit and behind BG Vox 1. Apparently, the reverb is progressively widening in order to prepare for the ultra-wide vocals.

Now, that’s coming from a listener who isn’t a mix engineer. The only pro status I’ve got in post-prod is subtitle editor, which requires a different type of listening skills. A few months ago, it took a lot of fumbling around to do this space graph exercise. BTW, hi Glen from PWYM#1 and thanks for what you wrote about editing the vocal breath in Air Traffic. It encouraged me to keep trying even though it can be quite tricky and time-consuming.

Hello, nice to see you again as well, looking forward to learning lots more interesting stuff!

Well, finally, here it is!

My analysis of Kanye West's Black Skinhead.

It's a remarkable work of songwriting and production.

Click on the link below to hear the song.

Black Skinhead by Kanye West [link withheld]

Image omitted from this public edition.
Black Skinhead Musical Graph 2014-07-07 at 4.53.18 PM.png1635x835 164 KB
[link withheld]

Hi Evelyne
Thanks for your critique!
I wasn't entirely happy with this chart because so many elements in this song are up front and in your face. Though this makes perfect sense for the poetic's in this song, the graph at hand made it difficult to demonstrate accurately. Hence, I decided to lay it out as I heard it in the stereo field. Basically, a two dimensional analysis.

Regarding the hand claps, they're definitely panned to the right but you can hear their reverb effect on the left. But I do agree that the cymbals should have been more centered.

Thanks again for your input,
Marc

You’re welcome, there was a lot to learn from your space graph. The way you positioned almost all instruments in the lower half conveyed accurately the in-your-face soundscape. Also, you were damn right about the hand claps. Listening to them again, it’s very clear that there’s only reverb on the left, and it’s pretty scary how I got fooled the first time. West & the Dafts did a great job at creating disorienting wilderness.

Looking forward to having access to your yellow comments in Google Docs. Could you please make your structure graph public?

Hi Evelyne

Sorry for the delayed response!

My Google Docs are now public.

Thanks,
Marc

Well here it is...my reverse mix of Sledgehammer:

[external link withheld] [link withheld]

Image omitted from this public edition
PG Sledgehammer Reverse Mix 2014-07-19 at 4.00.35 PM.png1207x808 236 KB
[link withheld]

Comments, good or bad and from friend or foe, are welcome!

Participant 366

My creative mix below...pulled out the guitar and piano completely...still felt well balanced but less dense...I've attached my mixer settings as well...vocal dead center...backing vocals at 3 & 9 o'clock respectively...the same with the prophet and horns...drums and bass, as always, dead center...

Participant 366

[external link withheld] [link withheld]

Image omitted from this public edition
PG Sledgehammer Creative Mix 2014-07-23 at 9.09.08 PM.png1229x818 233 KB
[link withheld]

Image omitted from this public editionParticipant 366 said:

My Google Docs are now public.

Thanks, Mark, you have good ears for identifying instruments. It helped me decipher a lot of what’s going on in Black Skinhead. For some reason, the yellow comments disappeared from your graph, but I’ll try searching the web to get more info about the effects that were used. Let’s focus on the structure thing that raises the most questions: does a rap chorus obey different rules than usual?

I agree with your Intro Beat, Intro Vox, Re-Intro, Vox Break and Outro, but your Bridges 2, 3 and 4 correspond to what is usually described as a chorus. Or if you prefer, the leitmotiv and loudest part of the song:

Image omitted from this public edition
structure A.PNG1250x459 51.7 KB
[link withheld]

Granted, it’s risky to rely on one’s eyes too much. But that’s one of the few occasions when looking at the waveform seems to help. And each time, the chorus corresponds to the recurring lyrics “Four in the morning (...) And you know it”.

The same Black Skinhead waveform with the structure you chose shows things that feel weird to me, like a bridge which would be louder than the chorus:

Image omitted from this public edition
structure B.PNG1248x458 53.2 KB
[link withheld]

Now, this song is very special, so maybe they broke the rules here too. And I can see how the recurring scratch guitar led you to decide that it felt like a chorus. What bothers me though is that the lyrics are significantly different between each of your choruses. But hey, the Dafts don’t care much about lyrics. When doing the structure graph for Kavinsky’s Nightcall (produced by Guy-Man), I realized that verse 1 and 2 had exactly the same lyrics, in addition to the chorus lyrics remaining the same. Not to mention “Around the world... Around the world... Around the world...”

Image omitted from this public editionParticipant 584 said:

I agree with your Intro Beat, Intro Vox, Re-Intro, Vox Break and Outro, but your Bridges 2, 3 and 4 correspond to what is usually described as a chorus. Or if you prefer, the leitmotiv and loudest part of the song:

Hi Evelyne

Thanks again for taking the time to assess my work. Honestly, I failed to pay enough attention to the naming of each section for I was hyper-focusing on the instrumentation and arrangement. Hence, your analysis is probably more accurate than mine.

Image omitted from this public editionParticipant 584 said:

Granted, it’s risky to rely on one’s eyes too much. But that’s one of the few occasions when looking at the waveform seems to help.

Totally agree!

Image omitted from this public editionParticipant 584 said:

Now, this song is very special, so maybe they broke the rules here too.

Girl, they broke all the rules here! Awesome work...I think there were 10 writers on this song.

Image omitted from this public editionParticipant 584 said:

What bothers me though is that the lyrics are significantly different between each of your choruses.

Again, I was focusing mostly on the music. If the sections were arranged similarly, I would give them the same name.

Btw, where are you based...NYC?

Your input is greatly appreciated!

Best Regards,
Marc

Image omitted from this public editionParticipant 584 said:

Looking forward to having access to your yellow comments in Google Docs. Could you please make your structure graph public?

Here it is:

[external link withheld] [link withheld]

The yellow comments should appear.

Marc

Hi Marc,
After trying with a different browser and computer, the conclusion is that Google sharing options have room for improvement. If you log out of your Gmail account (so that you aren’t the doc owner anymore) and try viewing your graph as a 3rd party user, the comments won’t appear.
Google won’t let other people view your comments unless you choose the option “Anyone who has the link can comment”. The only thing reassuring is that people can’t mistakenly delete your notes.

Image omitted from this public editionParticipant 366 said:

Btw, where are you based...NYC?

ATM, near Paris, France, but I’m used to working remotely. If you have a music video project at hand, I’ll definitely look at it. My video skills are more advanced than the audio ones.

Image omitted from this public editionParticipant 584 said:

Google won’t let other people view your comments unless you choose the option “Anyone who has the link can comment”.

Hi Evelyne

I have that option selected. Frustrating but thanks for the insight!

Image omitted from this public editionParticipant 584 said:

If you have a music video project at hand, I’ll definitely look at it. My video skills are more advanced than the audio ones.

I'll keep that in mind.

Thanks again,
Marc