I thought it would be interesting to have a group on this topic.
I think process of creating can be something abstract and complicated especially when expectations weight in it can hinder you from acting or can stimulate you to create, fear and anxiety of the blank sheet.
Without preparation, it happens you write something you don't think you would dismiss unlike what usually happens.
Would be interesting to hear some of your experiences in your creative process and how you work.
Do you always trust the process and go with the flow or you tend to chase the mental image no matter how long it takes you?
Hi [participant mention] [link withheld] -- I'm more a process-oriented person myself, but that doesn't mean I don't envision, plan, and work towards creative goals. For me, I know I've always done my best when I'm very prepared, but I also believe, philosophically, that events only occur once. The mental image can be a part of that preparation, but after it's all done the outcome is a new entity, or a new manifestation, and I don't usually compare that original mental image to the outcome product. Even listening to a recording is a unique experience every time, though in theory the recording has stayed the same, I know I have changed. I'm very meticulous with music and I do usually like to develop abstract ideas about what I should be doing at any given moment, but when other things occur I leave my mind open to working with them instead of trying to force the preconceived mental image. In the end I believe music is multifaceted, you can view it from many points of view and in many different contexts, indeed it may be impossible to take in the totality of all its potential in any one incarnation. With recording, we'd all like to believe that the final published work is the best, most accurately executed version of a particular musical composition -- but I think in the back of our minds we all know that other, equally interesting, versions can exist through remix and rearrangement. So now it is but one point of view, probably no better or worse than a large variety of other versions.
When inspiration strikes get it down.as much info as you can... So when you revisit it you can then work on structure and content..just getting the idea Down Participant 374 .. Is the best start then as you add to it even more magic happens..
Nice thread people. One has to be alert and ready both mentally and physically at all times so when the idea materializes you're ready to go wherever that may lead.
Do you have this issue when you're working towards a concept in your head the music you come up with you think doesn't fit or its not what you wanted, how do you react in this situation?
I've had two instances when i was working on a song, the concept image prompted me to really try to capture the notes or chords on how to write it according to the concept, situations like that for me have been frustrating but can be satisfying when achieved
I've also had experiences where im working towards a concept and the stuff i come up with initially i reject and later when i got back to it i realize somehow it fits with the themes i was exploring
like on a subconscious level i find that i expressed that idea without realizing it, usually hinted by the feel of the music, that mood i was thinking of
Hmm it makes me wonder, i suppose the goal of the composer is to reach a level where one can accurately produce internal abstraction into accurate music
So far when i write ive had to use ideas, or mental concepts in order to write i cant seem to write from an emotional response standpoint
I don't quite know if this is on topic or not, but when I work on original songs, I often get bored with them long before they are finished. As an example, i can have a song with keyboards, rhythm tracks, maybe a vocal. While trying to record a basic bass guitar part, before the time I have it near perfect, i don't even feel like working on the bass, or the song itself anymore. I'm talking basic bass part (quarter notes, 100 BPM tempo, nothing challenging at all).
I love those tabla breakbeat science tracks, I studied tabla myself. I also record a lot with Ableton and use some of the techniques you described in your "composing improvisationally" post, though most of the time I don't carry it to the extreme. It does happen a lot with my group tevellus [link withheld], since many of our songs aren't actually composed until a long way unto the process. It does seem like a logical extension of the "riff" or "motive" (if you're into that sort of thing) aspect of composition. I enjoyed reading your blog though and will watch for updates, and your music theory videos look great I'm really glad you're putting that component into this course.
You're not the first person to ask me for that, so I went ahead and implemented it. Look at the right-hand column below the search bar, you can put your email address in there: [external link withheld] [link withheld]
I DO feel strongly about them. I get tired of hearing them over and over while I record and re-record overdubs. It's basic stuff, open chords on guitar, easy keyboard an bass parts, nothing demanding on vocals. I'm not being a perfectionist either.
Mine is more the opposite, i get anxiety issues, but i get excited when i do anything that feeds it to complete picture, the thing is depending on how much i place a value on it dictates how fast i work on it. If its something casual im relaxed, if its a prized idea, i worry about taking the first step. Eventually i get it done, or sometimes there;s a big gap till i get back to it, always feeling like i;m not ready to touch it.
Hey thanks for the compliment, we're working on a new batch of songs now and will hopefully have a whole new album done sometime later this year. We've talked a lot about releasing our songs multi-track for remix possibilities, maybe we'll actually do it this time!
How do you wrestle with your doubting demon knowing that one false move sets the idea away to deviate from the original inspiration it's a another idiosyncrasies as a composer i deal with when im particularly drawn to an idea
i suppose the fear is rooted in knowing that music has so much some freedom that if you break the meat of the idea it just falls over and loses focus
I don't usually wrestle, and so far as I know demons are not involved. In my view, what you're describing as "original inspiration," "concept image," "prized idea" etc, is part of the unseen world. I mean that it may be a perfectly formed and very concrete and real in your mind, but its manifestations in the outside, perceivable (by others) world, will always be somewhat incomplete. The full picture is only really a set of boundaries, one that you consciously create. Working with that idea in the seen world, you can operate within that set of boundaries, but it's impossible to fill in the entire picture at any single time. So maybe you have a tonality, or a set of chord changes, a bass line, or a drum beat. These things can expose the bounds of your imagination of this idea, but you can perform them in many different ways, and still have it be "the song".
Say you've written a song, you play it well and it fits in with your imagined idea of what it should be. Maybe you do some slight variations, play an instrumental section slightly different, emphasize a word in the vocals, or maybe change the groove a little bit or even rearrange the form. But essentially, you play the song the way you think it goes, the way it fits with your imagined ideas of what it should be even though those particular manifestations of the idea are different from each other.
Now say your song starts to get a little popular, and other people start playing it. They are not operating under the boundaries of your imagined idea, they're using their own template, even purposely distancing themselves from your original idea. Is it still the same song? Will it fit with your imagined idea? Will they surprise you and open up a whole other area of interest that you never even imagined, but that fits perfectly with your original concept? Maybe they'll do something you don't like at all, take it in a whole other direction, etc. Is it still the same song? You can do this exploration without other people being involved as well, if you allow yourself the freedom to explore.
If you accept my line of thinking here, you can see that the individual manifestations of a particular idea, no matter how well defined that idea may be in your mind, can all be different. So why worry about trying to perfectly match the idea, when there are so many possibilities to explore that you may not even know about? Get as close as you can, think about it critically and work on the aspects you know you can control, fix the technical glitches, find something that comes relatively close and don't worry about the rest. Perfectionism has its place, but always keep in mind that no-body and no-thing is perfect in the real world. That's my chime-in for the day.
You were pretty much quite accurate in your description of some the things i've come across when i'm working on some ideas.I've been able to draw out the stuff that's in my mind but it took some time and persistence on my part to try to get it as close to the concepts that i get as impressions. You're right that after producing it that it's not best image of it but usually just close enough.
I learned to conquer my doubting demon by recognizing that pieces of music have a certain life of their own. They're memes that self-assemble in your head, or in the collective heads of your collaborators. You may have a certain amount of influence over their early gestation, but you can't control the way they come out any more than you can control the way your kids grow up. The best you can do is to be nurturing, to intervene when necessary, to stay out of the way when necessary, and to try to appreciate the final shape that the music takes on for itself. Imposing time limits on yourself is a big help. If you force yourself to stop working on something after a week, or a day, or an hour, you'll be pleasantly surprised by how beneficial the results are for your creations.
Somewhere this week conversations about the subconscious came up so i was wondering, how does one tap into the subconscious other than hard/soft drugs?