COMMUNITY ARCHIVE Selected reading edition · 2014–2020
Play With Your MusicCommunity archive
← Getting Started

Getting Started

1a - How to Listen to Music in this Course

60 readable posts · 4 retained privacy notices · Team contributions are labelled separately from community replies.

Image omitted from this public edition.

Find A Quiet Space to Listen

As you prepare for Play With Your Music, we suggest that you find a consistent, quiet spot to engage with the course materials and recordings from week to week. In the first few weeks of the course, you'll be spending a lot of time listening to your own music and the music of others. Listening in the same physical space with the same equipment will help maintain consistency from week to week.

We also encourage you to listen using the best equipment you have available to you. That might mean a set of stereo speakers, or high quality headphones. Listening back to the audio files in this course using earbuds or laptop speakers is not advised because they often cannot reproduce the full spectrum of frequencies used in recordings. We're starting this course by sharing with you a process of listening deeply and critically to recorded sound. You'll want to hear all of the tiny details in your own recordings and the recordings of others!

Evaluate Your Listening Participant 001 Frequency Range

Image omitted from this public edition. [link withheld]

To evaluate the range of frequencies that you can hear through your listening Participant 001, click here (or on the above image) [link withheld]to load a test video. This video contains a test audio signal that sweeps from very low frequencies ( < 10 Hertz [link withheld]) to very high frequencies ( > 20,000 Hertz). To get started, we suggest that you turn your volume down to about 30% and skip to the middle of the video timeline. Once you hear the test tone, raise the volume until you hear it at a comfortable level. Then, restart the video from the beginning and take note of the approximate frequency when you first hear the tone on your Participant 001, and listen for the last frequency when you no longer can hear the tone. Use the frequency labels on the horizontal axis of the graph as your guide.

This range of frequencies that your Participant 001 can reproduce is not quite the same thing as the frequency response [link withheld]of your audio playback Participant 001. Not all speakers and headphones reproduce each frequency along the range evenly or equally. If you are interested in the more detailed ins and outs of speaker frequency response, read this article [link withheld]. For this course, the general rule of thumb is that listening in a quiet, consistent environment with better equipment (i.e., wide frequency range, and "flatter" frequency response), you will hear more details and come closer to experiencing the recordings as intended by the artists, engineers, and producers.

To get a better understanding of the frequency range differences among various speakers and headphones that you might have, try the above activity across multiple listening systems available to you (e.g., headphones, your laptop speakers, your home stereo, etc.). Share your experiences with your learning ensemble.

[participant mention] [link withheld] suggested using the following video to test both your hearing and your headphones because it gives you the exact frequencies on the video. We agree!

Learn More about the Science and Math behind How We Hear Sound

Mathemagician Vi Hart [link withheld] has prepared an amazing video illustrating the scientific and mathematical basis of sound and how humans hear and perceive sound. Check it out by clicking here (or on the image below [link withheld]) [link withheld]:

Image omitted from this public edition. [link withheld]

Rock On!

- The #PWYM Team

I found this helpful, and have bookmarked it for future pondering.

Wow. I thought I knew things... But that video explaining the overtones... blew my mind.

I have no idea what is meant by "pin", "pinned" " unpinned" and etc. It would be adviseable to all ... students, instructors, moderators ... all ... to avoid using colloquialisms and instead use words found in the common English language

Thanks for your feedback, Conrad. "Pinning" - as exemplified by this icon: Preserved course illustration or music-analysis diagram - is the way our forum designer - Discourse.org [link withheld] - refers to making a post stay at the top of a forum. We're sorry for the confusion.

nice stuff really enjoyed it

We'll I'm glad after the listening test I haven't lost my hearing after all these years! Looking forward to further participation.

Conrad, this is harsh reply. Pin, pinned and unpinned are all found in my dictionary. I say we leave the advising to the instructors, and all have a good time, yes?

The video was fascinating and informative. I had no idea all of that was going on inside our ear. Good stuff!

Sound test was good -- it turns out my headphones have really even response (Sony MDR-V6) but cutoff at around 1:34, so maybe not as good as some others (1:37? wow). I found the 12 minute video on hearing and tones not new information, but brilliantly presented and well integrated -- something which would appeal to a wide age range.

After i had done the test, youtube suggested me a few similar videos.
I wanted a more accurate answer. Dont know how accurate are they though. Do you recommend any other in particular? For this video i can say i stopped hearing at 1:36 but how does it translate to Hz?
Also a suggestion for the other classmates. Dont expose too much to hearing very high frequencies, you might end with a headache even if you are not hearing anything!

50hz - 20khz was about the range of my hearing ability through my Participant 001. I found the science and math video very interesting. An example: for reasons unknown a string of smaller size gives off smaller, higher vibrations than a longer string which gives off long, slower vibrations. Also the part about how our brains make up frequencies that aren't there, that really fascinates me.. (It's good enough for the brain, so why not perceive it? We hallucinate certain missing frequencies.) Fascinating stuff!

My studio monitors appeared to vary in volume quite more than my Grado Labs headphones. I'm not sure if that's because of the quality of the monitor of perhaps the acoustics in the room. Regardless, identifying this aspect of the sound from each should prove useful when mixing.

The video on how we hear sound explained the principles in a clear manner considering the amount of information provided in a short period of time. It gave some realism to timbres, fundamental frequencies, and quite a number of other topics that we're sure to dive deeper in before long.

Good start. Have a nice weekend...

Hi Jeff.
Yes! I agree wholeheartedly that we should all have a good time and enjoy the "course". While your reply was harsh it was not unkind. However, I think my comment was in keeping with that objective. Let me apologize for appearing argumentative; but, if we "students" waste time and become frustrated over interpretation of vernacular, the joy we otherwise hope to embrace vanishes rapidly. Use of "Pin", "Pinned" and "Unpinned" are simply emblematic of a larger issue. My dictionary includes the terms as well; but, those definitions have nothing to do with placing a post or comment at the top of a page until it is removed by someone. You'll note that we are also asked to "pin" our location on a map that has been provided. That usage of the word "pin" has nothing to do with a comment being "posted" does it?

My advise was more of a reaction to how our language is being destroyed by people taking little care to preserve it. I'm sure you've seen any number of colloquialisms bantered about in Social Networks that are, IMHO, meaningless unless one takes the time to ask or otherwise research what it is the author is trying to convey. Especially in a MOOC where people from all over the world are likely to be involved in the learning process, reverting to use of common words used in the America lexicon makes life and learning a heck of a lot less difficult.

Perhaps it is not a bad idea too that we take the effort to find out the meaning of words that we do not understand either by asking or checking around ie by googling. Isn't that what learning is about?

I know you guys said not to use earbuds, but on a whim I tried mine out and I was able to hear the entire range of frequencies in the video from start to finish. I guess these will do until I get some spare cash for a fancy set of cans:)

Can someone tell me if an old 70s vintage Koss K/2+2 Head-Phone set is worth driving 30 miles to purchase it for $30? I found them on Craing's List [external link withheld] [link withheld] I am currently using a very cheap set that roughly covers 17 Hz through 8.5 KHz with a varying loudness level across the band. I am simply a hobbyist on a self imposed limited budget. Alternatively, what is recommended as a mid priced, quality headset? e.g., is the following a good value [external link withheld] [link withheld]

You can get a decent pair of Sony headphones new at Walmart for like $20 that have a really good frequency range and are very comfortable. I have used them over the years for mixing and they are a great value for the money. Only reason I've had several pair is that cats like to chew them up Image omitted from this public edition But save yourself some money and they're good, reliable headphones. Over the ear, not earbuds. Here's a link to them: [external link withheld] [link withheld]

Thanks Alex. I need a little practice and tinkering time to post properly. Image omitted from this public edition

No worries... Just helping out to get your questions answered!

Conrad, I'm having some trouble reading your profile. It may be a problem with my browser configuration, but I'm getting very little contrast between the text and the background - I find that I have to select text to be able to read it. How does it look for you?

Listening to the frequencies test on my Panasonic HTX7s (I know, they're not real monitor headphones), I could hear up to 1:34, but I'm guessing that may be an age-related deficit, as opposed to any limits on my equipment.

But I could always get a decent pair of studio headphones anyway, just need to figure out what I should get...

I had to watch Vi's video a few times because I haven't had to do that much math in about a decade. I feel that watching it again gave me a better understanding of the material. Now off to do more research on overtones and frequencies. Image omitted from this public edition

I tried this out on my apple earbuds and could hear from 90Hz to 20kHz. Also tried this out on my KRK Rokit 8 monitors in a quieter space and could hear the entire frequency range.

I too noticed that the font appears to be strange ... as though it is trying to be a "relief" or an "embossed" sort of font. The FaceBook source from which it was copied was clearly replicated. I think something weird happened in the Copy and Paste process. I'll see if I can fix it.

I am having issues trying to navigate this site. My problem probably lies in the fact that I seldom read instructions but frankly I've never come across a site that was quite like this one. A little awkward ... at least for me!

Anyway I managed to post my profile a couple of times and still can't fugure out where one is versus the other. I just found one of the posts at the following URL. [1]: [external link withheld] [link withheld]

This one appears to be normal. If I can find out how to delete the other I will do so forthwith!

Your background image is mainly white. Try a darker background image.

To post a link, just copy the URL from the address bar and paste in the editor, like so: [external link withheld]

This method also works very well with videos:
Embedded media omitted from this public edition

If you want to add a description, use the hyperlink (%) in the editor and paste the link url and description when prompted Connie Sings "My Way" [link withheld]

I hope that helps.

Hello Conrad,
Are you sure everyone knows what IMHO and MOOC mean? :o )

BNGO!! Thas my point! IMO b/c peeps waste Tm tryn t dsyf'r wrds wn thy cud use it to lrn gud msik tknqes.

Hearing test was interesting because of 2 aspects:

  1. to under understand, where my ability to here high frequencies stops. Unfortunately more
    early then I expected.
  2. to here where the resonance frequencies of my speaker Participant 001 are.

One improvement for thetest would be, to display the exact frequency, so that you can stop the play back and get the exact frequency. The hear test at this link is doing so: Hear test with frequency display [link withheld]

What does this mean?

The frequency scale is logarithmic so the faint lines on the chart between 10kHz and 100kHz occur every 10kHz. Stopping at 1:36 equates to about 14kHz.

I used this video. The Hz value is displayed throughout, then just pause the video at the exact point where you either hear or don't. Much easier to note down the results that way.

Embedded media omitted from this public edition

Edit: Just for reference; my results:

Monitors:
Yamaha HS7: 115 Hz – 12000 Hz

Speakers:
Swans M10: 44 Hz – 12000 Hz

Headphones:
Audio-Technica ATH-M50: 20 Hz – 11000 Hz
Audio-Technica ATH-M50x: 20 Hz – 13200 Hz
Nocs NS200: 20 Hz – 12500 Hz

Tested the Nocs just for fun since they are my 'throw in a bag' iPhone cans. I was surprised by the result and it shows doing your research even before buying cheaper gadgets/equipment pays off in the end.

It represents how one might create a text message to avoid having to use so many, otherwise "wasted", key strokes. Uncle Al, maybe you are being facetious; but, just in case you are serious, the message attempts to convey the following:

Bingo ... In my opinion ... because people waste time time trying to decipher words. They could use it to learn good music techniques

It is my way of bringing on a little levity to the matter.

wow...great video...way too much to take in with just one viewing, but extremely interesting!!

Listening today through a pair of HK-NC headphones I heard 20Hz - around 8K. Looking at other people's numbers I'm afraid the missing piece of higher frequencies is my own hearing loss. Bummer.

Nice informative video. I did not hear much on the low end until maybe 40 hz but high end went up well past 10khz

I like the video [participant mention] [link withheld] posted, it's not too helpful if you can't see the frequency numbers clearly and ending at 100khz is just ridiculous. I ripped the audio and loaded it into Sonic Visualiser [link withheld] and it seems like the audio cuts off at about 18khz anyway. I only heard up to about 13.5khz, but I've been doing live sound for a while now and I'm sure I've lost some hearing (and intellectual) capacity as a result.

Hello all

50 hz to 12 Khz.. is that good?

Wow! That Vi Hart can talk. That was very thorough too! Will definitely be viewing that again. I wonder if she has a transcript? The articles on speaker response were great too.

I saw some comments on the video mention the same thing. I didn't have time to rip the audio to test that.

Post #45 is omitted from the public reading edition to protect personal information.

Thanks for sharing this!

So my Audio Technica monitor headphones allow me to hear from about 15hz to just under 10kHz.

I love Vi Hart. She's fantastic.

Post #48 is omitted from the public reading edition to protect personal information.

I tested several speakers, headphones and earbuds. I didn't notice difference on the range, could hear from 20~24 Hz until around 17500 Hz, when the sound completely fades for me.

I say this in a vein of jest; but just for the heck of it, try to Google "Pinned" and let me know what you come up with! I don't know about you but I am here to learn about music production techniques not to learn obscure interpretations of common and not so common words that are tosses out by a website techy.

IMO, H o N, tryn to fgur vrnculr is a w8s u tym.

thanks! i tried the other videos and probably they are more useful!

Great wee video, some nice stuff explained and very helpful to know the rest too!

Post #54 is omitted from the public reading edition to protect personal information.

Amazing I loved all of these videos. Blew my mind!

Post #56 is omitted from the public reading edition to protect personal information.

Very interesting you learn something new everyday

This video loses less in the upper frequencies at HD resolutions:
Embedded media omitted from this public edition

YouTube still compresses audio noticeably at 480p, which is what the video in the OP maxes out at.

These videos recently let me discover that I've lost a noticeable amount of high end in my left ear in the last year Image omitted from this public editionMy left drops off completely at 13.7kHz, while my right still gets up to 15.5ish.

My desktop speakers (Trust Tytans) appear to have a range of 65Hz to just over 14kHz, while my headphones (Sony MDR ZX600) go from 36Hz to just over 14kHz. Headphones will be necessary for low-end mixing then Image omitted from this public edition

With my Radio Shack Extreme headphones I can hear from 40Hz to 20kHz.

The Vi Hart video, as all of her videos, was fun and educational.

so jealous of your 8's i have Rokit 5"s ....for now Image omitted from this public edition

Heard from 34 Hz to approx. 13,000 kHz on the second video on my Altec Lansing desktop computer speakers.

Don't forget about the little push pin icon.Not sure if this is the universal icon for pushpin though.

That is way too fast too even begin to follow

Yay! So interesting. I really learned alot.

The frequencies got annoying around 4000 my ears started to die but this was very intresting how the ears cannot pick up on lower an higher frequencies an sometimes when it got to a certain point only 1 of my ears could hear it then it went back to both i found this intresting

this is really informative and new to me

This is one of the best videos I've watched on the science behind sound. Likening it to a swing is brilliant. Training for production in radio, they used the waves in the ocean as an example.
EG: When one collides with the back of another, if the timing is off, the wave doesn't push it forward harder and faster, it tends to collapse in on itself, much the same way as the swing example. A brilliant start!