COMMUNITY ARCHIVE Selected reading edition · 2014–2020
Play With Your MusicCommunity archive
← Sounds and Space

Sounds and Space

2a - Project: Listen Like a Producer and Engineer

13 readable posts · Team contributions are labelled separately from community replies.

Image omitted from this public edition.


OVERVIEW

In this module, you’ll be introduced to techniques for identifying instruments, sound sources, and vocal timbres [link withheld] (e.g., guitar, bass, synths, lead vocal, background vocal, etc.) in recordings, how to isolate and place them in perceived space, and how to become more precise in the language you use to describe recorded sounds. We’re beginning this course with a project in recording analysis because critical listening is 90% of the day to day work of a music producer or audio engineer. Through isolating and describing timbres and positioning them in perceived space, you’ll better be able to work with these concepts in your own tracks, no matter what genres you work within and across.

We've divided this module into 4 sections:

  • A. Project: Listening for timbre and space in Peter Gabriel's Sledgehammer
  • B. Video: Alex Case: Listening for timbre and space in recorded music
  • C. Project: Analyze your favorite tune and share it with your Crew and the PWYM community
  • D. Further Resources

This module ends with you creating a PWYM Perceived Space Graph [link withheld] for a section of a musical recording you love. We encourage you to find other PWYM participants (your crew!) to share your graph, and to give feedback to others on their graphs.

Diving deeper into the musicians and sound sources

PWYM co-creator Ethan Hein [link withheld] will demonstrate the process of listening to and analyzing music recordings. In these videos, Ethan will walk you through our approach to listening critically for timbre and space within Peter Gabriel's song "Sledgehammer" starting first with listening for timbres, then graphing them in perceived space.

Graphing timbres in perceived space

To create a perceived space graph of your song, you need to figure out where all of the sound sources are located in the perceived space of the recording. Are they on the right, left or center? Are they in a specific location or spread across a range of the stereo image space? Do they sound like they are right in front of you, in the middle distance or very far away? And do any of the sounds change location over the course of the song?

Embedded media omitted from this public edition

Here is a completed perceived space graph [link withheld] for "Sledgehammer" that we created as a reference for you. You may hear things differently, which is why we call this a perceived space graph. We are using a Google Charts template to make it easy for you later in Project 2 of this module to share, edit and collaborate on your graphs with other PWYM course participants.

A quick recap of our analysis process:

  • Listen and identify each timbre/separate sound source that you can hear
  • Listen for where you hear each sound left to right
  • Listen for where you hear each sound front to back
  • Listen for whether each sound seems to surround you (wide) or come from a specific location (narrow)

Going deeper

Our approach is based on strategies for critical listening and analysis from William Moylan's Understanding and Crafting the Mix: The Art of Record Production [link withheld] if you are interested in learning directly from the source!

Exploring these ideas through other music

In PWYM 1.0, Bradford Swanson [link withheld] introduced these concepts through the music of Clara Berry and Wooldog [link withheld], a singer/songwriter duo out of Kennebunk, Maine. If you'd like to approach this through that music, see the following videos:

Embedded media omitted from this public edition

Embedded media omitted from this public edition

Embedded media omitted from this public edition

Cool I like how there is another music you can learn from.

Cool. Thanks for this! I'll get to work on some of this stuff tomorrow.

As a side note, an interesting fact - I don't know for certain if this is definitely the first use of gated snare, but it would be pretty close to being the first - Intruder, from Peter Gabriel's third album. You hear it right up front, first thing, on that record, and it's played by none other than Phil Collins Image omitted from this public edition

Yes... Intruder is the well-documented origination of the gated snare. Check out resident PWYM Audio FXpert Alex Case's post on Intruder here: [external link withheld] [link withheld]. Thanks for sharing that!

Putting every track in a space graph makes the whole thing so much easier to understand and appreciate!. It's a simple idea (linking a sound with a position in a space), but just brilliant.

The problem begins when You're trying to identify the instrument in pure electronic music.
At this point often You end with description full of jargon.

By the way: if You're into a rock music, You might find of Butch Vig discussing Nirvana songs:
In Bloom: [external link withheld] [link withheld]Smells Like Teen Spirit: [external link withheld] [link withheld]Drain You: [external link withheld] [link withheld]Polly: [external link withheld] [link withheld]

Also the adding spatial effects to the mix depends heavily on the genre - I wish to find some infos and - hopefully - a decent discussion on that subject.
For starters "Dub Lesson" by Mad Proffessor:
Embedded media omitted from this public edition

Hey everyone, I don't have any crew so far, hope it's ok to share the graph in this thread, and here it is: [external link withheld] [link withheld]I agree with Participant 028 synths are very hard to locate in the unified space simply because they are all sort of in their own space with different delays and reverb parameters. They all (effects in synths) sound different. Not sure if they bothered to make them sound as if they're in the same space.

I learn more from the older videos, being able to hear each instrument by separate makes things more easy because when I listen to the full song I was able to tell when each instrument was played. I think that the sledgehammer song It's very complex, I'm still not able to hear the female voice.

We're glad you find the older videos useful. The female voices in Sledgehammer don't come in until near the end of the song.

I really enjoyed those videos! It has been awhile since I've worked on any recordings and the ear training refresher was much appreciated.

Very resourceful…professionally I'd avoid describing sounds as warm or cold but rather refer to technical applications such as delay or reverb to explain how the result was achieved…the latter tends to make the analysis more precise to fellow musicians and engineers…nuff said

Participant 366

Im confused on exactly what this means

Is there any difference between a wide sound and a narrow one that has been doubled and put on the right and the left position, like the Sledgehammer vocals?