COMMUNITY ARCHIVE Selected reading edition · 2014–2020
Play With Your MusicCommunity archive
← Sounds and Space

Sounds and Space

2b - Video: Alex Case - On Listening for Timbre and Space in Recorded Music

11 readable posts · Team contributions are labelled separately from community replies.

Embedded media omitted from this public edition

PWYM resident Audio FXpert Alex Case [link withheld], faculty member in Sound Recording Technology at UMass Lowell [link withheld], publisher of the blog Recordingology [link withheld], and instructor of audio courses at Lynda.com [link withheld], shares his insights into how to listen for timbre (instruments, voices, synths, etc.) and space in recorded music. This video interview was conducted back in November 2013 during the first version of PWYM that focused on the music of Clara Berry and Wooldog [link withheld]. Although Alex references that music, you can apply his advice to your projects.

[participant mention] [link withheld] is the resident audio FXpert here at PWYM. Post your questions to him as replies to this thread. He will be available to reply to your questions throughout the course.

A couple of questions for Alex:

Is it pretty standard to pan instruments depending on their pitch? For instance, would it be usual to pan the lower registers on a grand piano to the left, and higher registers to the right, and then having a sharper pan in the middle registers to leave space for vox? I've noticed this on some recordings (and tom fills on drums. Phil Collins for example, seems to have a lot of his fills move across the listening space), and just wanted to be sure that's what I'm actually hearing.

Secondly, if yes, is this done mostly to have a sense of the physical tactile space of the instrument, or are there other reasons for not just replicating all the tones both left and right?

Thirdly, again if more or less yes to the above, is this process done at the mixing level or recording level, and how is it done? Seems to me it would be difficult to manually pan individual piano tones ( or tom hits for that matter) when engineering clips.

Thanks!

I will ask [participant mention] [link withheld] to respond to this, as he's much more experienced to answer this question. My take on this is that panning by frequency (low frequencies on left; high freqencies on right - ala, an acoustic piano, for example) is just ONE possible approach. That might make sense if you were trying replicate how a pianist hears their part when they play. Similar debates occur in the mic-ing of drums, for example. Do you pan the drum set from the audience or drummer perspective? There is no right answer. It's a creative decision by the engineer/producer of the recording.

To answer your Third question, many times these decisions are made from the very pre-planning stages and impact how the microphones may be initially set up, including details of physical placement of mics, whether or not to use stereo microphones, and microphone distance and instrument placement within the recording space. These decisions on the perfomer's "side of the glass" impact what the engineer does and can do on his/her side of the glass.

I encourage others to chime in here with their experiences, too.

Here is a frequency chart

[external link withheld] [link withheld]

Image omitted from this public edition. [link withheld]

As a producer how much consideration is put into "fixing" and "arranging" during the creative process. I can imagine you can spend a lot of time getting this right but I would hope to find a balance with the creative process so that things move forward steadily.

Thanks and great interview!

Kevin

The Humble Pan Pot: A Critical Tool

Early in a mix, you work to find fader and pan positions that best reveal the mix. We call this balancing a mix, and it is not easy. I’ll mention quickly that the mute button is part of this process. If the tracks don’t fit together in a way that makes musical sense to you, at any fader or pan pot position, then mute one of the cluttering tracks.

But, back to the pan pot. What are the strategies for this simple control? Several priorities must be considered, and balanced:

  1. Realism

You might pan things simply to create a realistic image of the instrument in the stereo field.

Drum overheads can be spread out to create the illusion of the drummer playing right in front of you. This is called ‘Audience Perspective’ because this view of the kit is from the front, like an audience member looking at a drummer on stage. Your biggest clue here is the location of the hi-hats and the motion of any tom fills. Right handed drummers put the hi-hats to their left, and the toms off to the right, with the lower toms further to the right. For an audience member, that means the hi-hats are localized to the right, and descending tom fills move to the left.

‘Drummer’s Perspective’ is another choice. This stereo image of the kit puts the listener on the drum throne (that’s what they call their stool, and who are we to argue), with the hi-hats off to the left, and tom fills panning further right as lower toms are struck. If you play air drums while mixing, this will be satisfying way to work.

While Audience Perspective and Drummer’s Perspective are, in fact, opposite panning solutions, they are borne from the same core concept: pan to create a realistic illusion of the instrument. Choose your view of the instrument.

Similar approaches can be taken with any stereo tracks: string sections, horn sections, a chorus, etc. Piano presents an interesting challenge. Is it low to high, left to right, as if you are sitting at the piano keyboard? Or is it high to low, left to right, as if you are looking at the open lid of a grand piano from the side, as would happen in any concert where piano is a featured instrument? You choose. For a bit more on pianos, here’s an article I wrote for Recording Magazine a few years back [external link withheld] [link withheld]

  1. Left/Right Balance and Mix Center of Gravity

Another part of the decision process for panning has to do with giving a mix an overall, centered feeling. If, on average, your mix is louder on the left, the whole mix will feel lopsided. A left-heavy mix tells you that you likely need to find a balancing track to slide over to the right. The goal is to give the mix an overall center of gravity that is dead center.

Yes, you can be left- or right-heavy briefly. It becomes a form of musical expression, leaning one way, then another, and then resolving it when the mix is restored to a centrally strong image. But an entire mix that is lopsided, for its entire duration, will almost always be a mistake. At the very least, it says you aren’t taking good advantage of both speakers (or both ear buds). You have precious few ways to reach the listener – left and right. Use ‘em both!

  1. Spatial Counterpoint

Panning priorities also depend on the interaction among tracks. Similar tracks (doubled electric guitars, for example) can be panned to the same location, but they sound even more interesting panned opposite each other. Double tracks become wide walls of sound when panned to opposing sides.

Listen to other performances for interaction as well. Call and response tracks might work better when separated from each other – not necessarily hard panned to extremes, just separate enough to give their interaction spatial distinction. Guitars and keyboards often interact in interesting ways, playing together and then breaking into separate but complementary parts. This is nicely revealed and enjoyed when they are panned to unique locations in the stereo field.

Then there are some counterintuitive pairs you’ll pick up over time: Rhythm acoustic guitar is often played with percussive muted strums in between ringing chords that interact nicely with hi-hats. Yup: Acoustic guitar and hi-hats are common tracks to separate with panning for interesting spatial counterpoint. As you audition all of your tracks at the beginning of every mix, note which tracks sound best offset from others.

  1. Audibility and Intelligibility

Tracks fighting to be heard benefit from being panned away from their competition. When guitars and keys blur together, making it hard to enjoy either performance, separate them with pan pots to reveal both tracks. A vocal and a saxophone might step on each other unless panned to different locations.

  1. Best Use of 2 Channels

Lastly, and this one might annoy you at first, but one guiding principle is for the most important tracks to be dead center, or close to it. Vocal, kick, snare and bass are core elements of many styles of music. Put ‘em in the center so that you get the benefit of both speakers/ear buds for these important instruments. And for listeners who don’t happen to be sitting dead center, between the monitors, they’ll always hear these instruments, because you ‘ve panned them to both speakers.

Pan the other tracks around this central core, guided by the suggestions above, and your pan pot decisions will lead to a strong musical mix.

Moments of inspired creativity should proceed unchecked. Keep the magic happening. If you are the creator, try to stay 'in the zone' and get as much done as you can.

But if you are producing/engineering someone else, it is your job to have an ear out for Fixes and Arrangement issues at all times. Don't interrupt the flow of a session because of this, but keep track of it and try to find solutions seamlessly.

With experience, you develop an intuitive sense of how to manage these things while staying creative.

What a fantastic, helpful, and detailed answer. Well worth the wait. Thank you, [participant mention] [link withheld] !

Can I ask one follow up question - how does one go about setting up optimal conditions for a fertile pan pot? For instance, on drums, I assume it would be standard fare to mic each individual drum, and use seperate tracks to make this a little easier. But would you do this with a grand piano, for example, and have multiple mics set up to record different registers? Would it even be possible to get 'clean' recordings that way without making the instrumentalist divide their complete part into smaller recordable parts by register? Do you even want a 'clean' piano sound, with each register neatly parceled up and panned away?

So basically, the question is the how of your answer - how does one best make creative use of the pan pot- is it pretty reliant on how you record, or can you use software to achieve that end? Is there such a thing as pan automation in modern DAWs, for example? Would you have to go through manually to position everything just so, or can you automatically pan parts of a track automatically by frequency, like with an EQ or something?

[participant mention] [link withheld] thanks for that great post, I enjoyed the article on recording piano too. I've played the piano for 30 years but I don't really like playing synths or keyboards much, or at least I'd say it's a very different experience. I recently carried a spinet up two flights of stairs and through three doors to get it into my studio. It's no grand piano but it beats any electronic keyboard.

[participant mention] [link withheld] I'll chime in with some of my experiences. I tend to try different things, and I record drummers pretty frequently. Sometimes, I put two microphones on every drum, plus overheads and room mics -- I do that when the drummer is doing lots of interesting things using all the drums, and I know I want to capture all those details. The inputs of each microphone get recorded as mono signals, individually -- so I'll effectively save any permanent decisions on panning for later. But in the meantime, I want to make a nice sound too, so I'll also record a mix of those mics, which will include the panning I do in real time on the console. If I do a good enough job there, it can be the official track and I don't have to even look at the individual mic channels, but maybe I need more kick drum later or the snare needs some work, then another mix may be necessary. If the drummer is coming in to lay down some pretty straightforward stuff, nothing fancy, then I'll usually only pan overheads and count on them plus a room mic to make a good stereo image. Then whatever spot mics I use on drums are just to enhance that sound so they'll usually be center.

I think about recording the piano the same way, if the pianist is playing a left hand part that is distinct from the right hand part, having them panned stereo is a pretty good idea. But, the lower frequencies will then be off to one side, and that can aggravate people. But a bass player or kick drum in the center could help to offset that. You can get into an endless tub of weirdness by panning out different frequencies, but yes you should be able to do most of that after you've recorded it into the DAW. There's plugins that do this sort of thing, but you could always just duplicate a mono track, pan the original left and the duplicate right, and then put EQ on them individually.

LCR panning appears to be the dominant method used by engineers. It definitely creates a wide stereo image and clears up the center for the vox, kick, snare and bass. The main limitation in my experience is when you have really wide stereo keyboards and efx. You kill their essence when you impose LCR panning.

Participant 366

(Sorry, late to the party, but I'm playing catch-up this week and next, so it'll be fun!)

First - This stuff is practical, yes, but absolutely NOT boring!!! This stuff is some serious brain candy, so please never hesitate to unpack all the nuts & bolts! Image omitted from this public edition

Second - I'm only about halfway through the interview so far, but the bit about being strategic about when/where to bring in or remove different timbral (sp?) elements, specifically referring to bringing in more low end later in the song, made me immediately think of the first song where I'd ever consciously noticed this happening (back in the days when I was first learning how to critically hear my music)... I was listening to Depeche Mode's "I Feel You" for maybe the 500th time, and it occurred to me to wonder how the intro managed to so effectively kick up its intensity not once but twice on it's way into the main body of the song... and on a closer listen I realized that it was exactly this idea. The song starts off with just a guitar, minimal percussion (a mix of acoustic and electronic), and the lead vocal... then at 0:43 (which is usually when most intros wrap up and go into full-band mode) it bursts into a very full sound, lots of drums, lots of melodic elements from the synth, very dramatic... and then, as the entire musical phrase that opens the song is being fully resolved for the first time, it bursts AGAIN (at 1:04) with fresh energy when the low end is finally brought in. I get two waves of goosebumps every time I listen to that intro (and it makes me sorely miss Participant 450 Wilder's contribution to the engineering of that band's music, because I'm pretty sure that was his idea).

Here's a link to the vid if anyone wants to check out this example - Depeche Mode "I Feel You" [link withheld]