COMMUNITY ARCHIVE Selected reading edition · 2014–2020
Play With Your MusicCommunity archive
← Musical Structure

Musical Structure

3b - Video: Phil Galdston - On Songwriting

8 readable posts · Team contributions are labelled separately from community replies.

Songwriter/Producer [link withheld] and NYU Professor Phil Galdston [link withheld] shares techniques for how to listen to the song within a recording, and how songwriters use musical structure, repetition and variation expressively. Given that his songs have appeared on almost 80 Million records, you don’t want to miss this!

Check out another interview with Phil by ArtistHouseMusic.com:

That's a lot of Ds Image omitted from this public edition

I'm curious how Phil would critique early Genesis songs with Gabriel. Clearly, they diverted from the songwriting norm of verse, chorus and melody. Supper's Ready anyone?!

[participant mention] [link withheld] I'll ask Phil and see if he'll respond here. In my interactions with Phil, I've taken away that good songwriting is about that creative balance between expectation and surprise. Chord progressions and melodic shapes can be manipulated to reinforce expectation or induce surprise.... and, so can lyrics, and that extends to meter and even song forms. One of my favorite examples is the Beatles' Yesterday, which has 7 bar phrases ... one less than you'd normally expect. But, it sure does a good job of setting up the first lyric of the second verse - "suddenly." That, coupled with the entrance of the string parts really makes an impact, I think. To me that's a good example where the recording/production techniques reinforce the song.

[participant mention] [link withheld] Agreed my friend…To clarify my earlier point, Genesis had a linear approach to songwriting…no one part is ever repeated…whereas traditional songwriting has intro, verse, chorus, verse, bridge, extended chorus, etc.

On another note, I'd like to express my gratitude for your team's hard work and tenacity. This is very resourceful. Keep up the great work!

Participant 366

Good point [participant mention] [link withheld]. That narrative structure is one of the defining features of progressive rock. Thanks for the feedback!

I´m located in Germany and I´m unable to watch the first video because "it could contain music from UMG, for which we could not agree on conditions of use with GEMA." >:-( Any ideas? Thanks!
Participant 002

Thanks for letting us know [participant mention] [link withheld]. This is unfortunate because of international licensing differences between Germany and the US. Phil plays short excerpts of recordings in his video, which were internally tagged by YouTube. I will see about providing an alternate link for you.