COMMUNITY ARCHIVE Selected reading edition · 2014–2020
Play With Your MusicCommunity archive
← Musical Structure

Musical Structure

Module 3 Project Share: Musical Structure Graphs

37 readable posts · 1 retained privacy notices · Team contributions are labelled separately from community replies.

Please share your Module 3 finished Musical Structure Graphs here for comment and discussion.

Here is my attempt at sharing project 3:

new link should work!
[external link withheld] [link withheld]

As I mentioned, it is difficult to fit in everything. Maybe I am being too picky about where something starts and ends. But they use instrumentation to play the same notes in different sections, have drums and bass drop in and out, etc. which keeps the song interesting and surprising.

[participant mention] [link withheld] I couldn't access your file. Could you update your sharing settings to "anyone with the link" so that PWYMers can view your graph? Thanks!

OK -- hopefully this will work

Success! I can view it.

This is more difficult than I thought.

I picked New Orders 'True Faith' as it is a song I cannot stop dancing too. I used the version off the singles CD and copied it into Cubase so I could analyse it in detail, probably too much. Also I added the bar positions as I found it easier than using the time position. Its a little longer than the video version but it still makes sense.

[external link withheld] [link withheld]

.Here's mine! I tried to pick something that would be easy for me. Turns out it was hard and took a long time anyway:)
[external link withheld] [link withheld]

Module 3 Project Share: Musical Structure Graphs for Tiësto - Red Lights

Tiësto - Red Lights Graph [link withheld]


Image omitted from this public edition.

Here's my attempt, an uplifting trance tune by Dash Berlin. It surprised me to discover the structure of this song (basically verse/chorus/chorus, with only one verse).

Dash Berlin - Steal You Away [link withheld]
Video [link withheld]

Image omitted from this public edition.

I tried to work on Chasing Pavements by Adele. I do not believe I succeeded very much, but I'm happy I worked on it,because I got better filling on how the instruments play in harmony.
All comments, corrections, criticism are appreciated.
[external link withheld] [link withheld]

Embedded media omitted from this public edition

I liked the synth names on the 'Dash Berlin' as this is a difficulty with modern electronic music, how to separate the different timbres.

Never listened to country music before so Lara Whitten's insight very interesting.

I couldn't access the Lina Rose file. Could you update your sharing settings to "anyone with the link" so we can view your thoughts.

Thanks everyone.

This is my analysis of alt-J's Breezeblocks. I thought the analysis would be simple but I found that it's quite complicated to detail every change of the structure in the same section.
Youtube link here [link withheld]

Full musical structure graph here [link withheld]

Image omitted from this public edition.

One thing I learned from doing this was that my critical listening for this excercise is way more intensive than for the perceived space graph exercise. As a result...my perceived space graph changed, hah.

Again, I concentrated on Feist's "1234".

Embedded media omitted from this public edition

Image omitted from this public edition.

The doc includes a lot of my own comments, so follow the link if you want to read them. Otherwise, you can glance at the chart below:

[external link withheld] [link withheld]

Image omitted from this public edition.

This was more challenging than I expected. I learned that I don't recognize many sounds or what instrument made them. I needed to use Audacity to slow the song and count measures. Good exercise for learning.

Link: Youtube link 1 [link withheld] There are differing opinions as to the tempo of this song, and your view would be appreciated. Thanks.

Image omitted from this public edition.
Little Richard Musical Structure.JPG999x677 171 KB
[link withheld]

Participant 450,
Here is the link to my Graph template, Adele, Chasing Pavements:
[external link withheld] [link withheld]

I'm really sorry, I have no idea how to place the link any other way. If you still can't access it I'll try again in a few days.
Thank you,
Participant 653.

Tried the link, but doc permissions do not allow me to see it.

I'm also surprised how much is happening in this simple sounding song. Maybe the light sound comes from the dry production. For instance, on banjo and acoustic guitar each note is a pluck and the sound ends instead of the ringing or reverb you might have with electric guitar.

The extra bar at the end of Chorus 3 is interesting. It adds some tension in a different way than the buildup and drop in a dance song.

RE: File sharing permissions in Google Docs

In order for others to see your graph, you need to change the file sharing options. It is easy in Google Docs.

Click File
Click Share...
Click Change...
Select Anyone with the link
Click Save
Click Done

Sorry about that. Didn't even think about permissions. You should be able to access the link now. Thanks for the feedback!

"Alive" - as recorded by "Empire Of The Sun"

Embedded media omitted from this public edition

The structure of "Alive" breaks from the rule for section lengths in multiples of 4. Most sections are 8 measures plus 2. The first three sections of verse and chorus also add a 1 measure breakdown, for a total of 11 measures in the section.
The song uses different voices for verse, chorus and break. Everything drops out for verse 3 except for some closed hi hat and synth. Some instruments join for the second half of verse 3. All the sounds return for the final chorus.

[external link withheld] [link withheld]

Image omitted from this public edition.

Ok here's the song for this assignment. I had some trouble using Echonest, it didn't quite let me install it due to security related reasons, either because of my antivirus or my browser but i'm placing my chart here for now. I have placed a BPM read on this my chart but i'm not sure how accurate it is. For this week, i chose a song by Pink Floyd from a really important album.

Embedded media omitted from this public edition

PWYM Musical Structure Graph Template - Sheet1 (1).pdf [link withheld] (117.8 KB)

This song has an unusual structure when taken a closer look. It's outro/intro sounds like a reprise of Breath track, which is the second song in the album from Dark Side of the Moon.This makes the song sound like two different songs in one track which is quite engaging. The third chorus of Time although changes the mood from the original chorus does still manage to give the impression of familiarity of the original chorus but still sounding slightly out of place. Conceptually and musically the track is very well written and deals with how fast time passes us by, thereby making it a somewhat timeless theme that translates well across generations of music fans. I also really like how the organ is used a lot during the chorus, gives quite the feeling of peeking like opening up.

Thank you for the help my link is now public.

I picked 'Frame by Frame' by King Crimson. We had the Crimson ProjeKCt play here in Sydney last weekend, and I went and saw them. I've basically had this track spinning in my head since then, so this is kind of an excercise in trying to get it out of my head more than anything Image omitted from this public edition

Embedded media omitted from this public edition

Image omitted from this public edition.
Screen Shot 2014-07-02 at 4.07.34 pm.png1318x661 146 KB
[link withheld]

Link to the Google Doc is here [link withheld]. For an ostensibly 'progressive' song, the basic structure of Frame by Frame is actually quite regular, and bears some resemblance to a lot of jazz music in having a predictable, consisting of the statement of a theme, followed by developments of that theme, then moving into another theme(s), before returning to recapitulate that theme later on and moving through the structure again. Most of the complexity lies in the individual parts, modulation and varying tonality, polyrhythm, and the general use of complex meter.

This has been very difficult for me as well [participant mention] [link withheld] Image omitted from this public edition

I picked up "Lucy In The Sky with Diamond - by The Beatles".
You can view my graph on "Lucy In The Sky With Diamond" - as recorded by "The Beatles" [link withheld]

I wasn' t able to recognize each single instrument and tempo. So I googled and I took info on:
Notes on "Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds" [link withheld]
Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds [link withheld]
LUCY IN THE SKY WITH DIAMONDS LYRICS [link withheld]

By the way I choose to dissect that song following the lyrics more than the music, because they are really interesting and have their own musical tune dictated by poetry metric.

I' d like to receive your feedback espacially about measures and meter.
I used bpm counter to determine the BPM.
BPM Counter [link withheld]

Thank you.

Did 'More' by The Sisters of Mercy. Used the version on YouTube, here [link withheld]. My breakdown here [link withheld]. Great exercise!

Interesting that the song works on rolling 4 bar blocks until the end as well as the 4/4 time. I wonder if this was a concept the writers were playing with?
As you say, it's more complex that an initial listening suggests.

Hi Participant 450,

could you please post a link to the CD single version that you used?
Listening the song on Youtube New Order - True Faith [link withheld], some instruments start around the 10 second:

00:10 bright keyboard
synth bass (bass rhythm beat?)

00:17:00/00:18:00 bass

but I' m not able to find them on your graph.

I' m not a musical expert and I do not feel very confident with the '80 electronic music and
with any kind of synths

"..."True Faith" was created using a wide range of electronic musical equipment. According to an interview in 'Sound On Sound' by Richard Buskin, Hague notes that New Order provided a Yamaha QX 1, an Ocatave Voyetra 8 Polyphonic synthesizer, a Yamaha DX 5 and an Akai S900 sampler, while he provided an E-mu Emulator II and an E-mu SP12.,

but I 'd like to check a New Order' song.

Thank you.

I like that with this being a very early stereo recording you can hear the bass on the right quite separate and pick out what Paul is playing. Their is also a lot of early phase or flange effects which I presume were done on tape machines.

Sorry I cannot find how to link to a CD version of 'True Faith'. I know they say they used many synths but I cannot separate them on the recording and I presume they are all in the mix at the end where it's difficult to pick then apart.

I have found this true with other peoples samples that sometimes the mix is so full it's hard to unravel them.

Hi Participant 450,

do not worry. It' s ok. It has been quite a long time since I did listen the New Order.
Yes, it' s very hard to identify each synth and pick them apart one by one.
But you can start with the bass (it starts around 00:17/00:18) and find info on the net about what instruments and who play them and when.

Thank you for your quickly answers.

Post #30 is omitted from the public reading edition to protect personal information.

Hi [participant mention] [link withheld], thank you for your reply.
You are definitly right. I detected the use of multiple meters,
but I wasn' t able to point out the different BPM
between the verses and the chrous.
Using some on-line tool Tap for Beats Per Minute [link withheld] and tapping on the keyboard
it' s easy to have an idea on "what' s happen to Lucy":

Verse 1 - Verse 2 - Bridge 1 (tempo=3/4):
Average BPM 131.9
Nearest Whole 132
Timing Taps 97

Chorus (tempo=4/4):
Average BPM 94.04
Nearest Whole 94
Timing Taps 29

I guess BPM Counter makes an arithmetic average of the BPM of the song.
It could be right according to the BPM value found inside some BPM database.

[external link withheld] [link withheld]
THE BEATLES - FULL TRACK LIST - ROCK - PAGE 17 [link withheld]

Thank you again for share your opinion.

Well, finally, here it is!

My analysis of Kanye West's Black Skinhead.

It's a remarkable work of songwriting and production.

Click on the link below to hear the song.

Black Skinhead by Kanye West [link withheld]

Image omitted from this public edition.
Black Skinhead Musical Graph 2014-07-07 at 4.53.18 PM.png1635x835 164 KB
[link withheld]

[participant mention] [link withheld] Could you share and link to the Google Doc of your analysis, too? I'd love to be able see how you annotated specific cells using the comment feature.

Sorry Alex

Here it is:

Black Skinhead Musical Structure Graph [link withheld]

Thanks for the "Heads Up"!

Here's a link to my graph for Reptilia by The Strokes. I did not know the tempo so I looked that up on my own and I was not sure of the Meter:
[external link withheld] [link withheld]

Oh yeah and I had to mess up the formatting to add more sections Image omitted from this public edition

Embedded media omitted from this public edition

So here's my analysis of "Smoke" by "A Thousand Horses". This is one of my favorite country songs so hope you all enjoy!

I did the song "Born to be Wild" by Steppenwolf...the measures may be off? Also the drums may be present in the chorus, I struggled a little but here it is!

Image omitted from this public edition.
Musical Structure chart-lizzy Roehl.PNG1127x587 72.2 KB
[link withheld]

Here is my Structure Graph for Thinking Out Loud by Ed Sheeran. I am new to studying music but I really enjoyed doing this project.
Embedded media omitted from this public edition