COMMUNITY ARCHIVE Selected reading edition · 2014–2020
Play With Your MusicCommunity archive
← Mix Balancing

Mix Balancing

Module 5 Project Share: In Your Eyes Mixes

18 readable posts · 1 retained privacy notices · Team contributions are labelled separately from community replies.

Share Your Work!

Now that you've taken the time to balance and refine a mix of In Your Eyes, export it and share it to SoundCloud.

  • Step 1: Make sure you are logged in to Soundation by checking that your email address/username show up in the upper right corner of the Soundation.com window.

Image omitted from this public edition

  • Step 2: Export your mix as a .wav file in Soundation by clicking "Export .wav File." Saving as a WAV file preserves the quality of your mix by exporting it at 44.1 kHz and 16-bit resolution. By default, your file will be named "mixdown.wav." Feel free to give your track a more descriptive file name.

Image omitted from this public edition

  • Step 3: Open SoundCloud.com [link withheld] and Sign in to your account.

  • Step 4: Click on the Upload button in the upper right corner of SoundCloud.com (just to the right of the search bar) and upload your .wav file mix from Soundation.

Image omitted from this public edition
Screen Shot 2014-09-15 at 11.52.44 AM.png1242x487 39.6 KB
[link withheld]

  • Step 5: Fill out descriptive information about your track. Add the #pwym [link withheld] and #petergabriel [link withheld] hash tags so that our community can easily find each other's mixes. Be sure to set the privacy setting to "public" so that other can hear your mix. Click Image omitted from this public edition to save your track on Soundcloud.com.

Image omitted from this public edition
Screen Shot 2014-09-15 at 11.57.55 AM.png818x568 117 KB
[link withheld]

  • Step 6: View and listen to your track on Soundcloud.com.

Image omitted from this public edition
Screen Shot 2014-09-15 at 12.00.33 PM.png1265x650 179 KB
[link withheld]

  • Step 7: Copy the URL to your track, and share your work with the PWYM Community by replying to this topic and copying the URL on it's own line in your reply. It will show up like this:
Embedded media omitted from this public edition

Rock on!

  • The PWYM Team.

It's interesting that Alex seemed to have Sledgehammer in mind when he wrote the title for his modern rock version of In Your Eyes: the drums level is high enough for them to bounce around the head like in Sledgehammer's music video. They create a great 3D space with lots of movement.
After going overboard with them in my previous mix, I tried to do the opposite: focus on the piano and build a sweet ballade to accompany the 50's stock footage you see in the video.

Embedded media omitted from this public edition

Lowering the drums brought home how much craft goes into singing lyrics: PG stressed his syllables in order to match the groove. So when you try to pull the drums level down, it soon feels like you also need to tame the rhythm of the lyrics, either with automation or compression.
There's a particular line that sounds weird now: “When I want to run away”
Since we were supposed to play with the track faders only, I left it as is for now.

Thanks a lot for this new exercise. In addition to learning how to balance levels in a little less amateurish way, it helps find a suitable listening volume when starting to mix.

Here is my result. When compared to the reference mix, my version has stronger drum / bass components and less prominent lead vocals. Doing these assignments as an amateur, in some ways I feel like I have no idea what I'm doing. But at the same time, my results sound good to my ears. It's definitely an interesting exercise and a learning experience.

Embedded media omitted from this public edition

Cheers!

Embedded media omitted from this public edition

I thought the vocals were a little too far in the back on the "mix" track. And, I was like, "Why is it like that?". I knew that mine were a touch louder, more like I hear on the radio; but, after the mixdown, and putting it on Souncloud, I don't know, they might be a touch too out front.

Your mix definitely grabs my attention even though there's less groove than in the original. It seems you've got the solution to the 'less drums challenge': let the vocals carry the song fully instead of trying to compensate with other instruments. And it does sound balanced to my newbie ears. Some folks might argue about a few words at the end that could be a little too loud now:
“I want to touch the light, the heat”
But they are intentionally stressed, and if you had chosen to lower the whole track, the vocals would have lost in presence elsewhere. Personally, I prefer people who take the risk to flirt with the extremes rather than staying on the conservative side of things. So kudos to you because you dared to go for it.

Also, you asked a crucial question about the place of the vocals in the reference mix. It reminded me of what Jerry Marotta said about Peter Gabriel being a drummer himself. Sometimes, he sounds like a self-effacing singer who's drumming with his voice.
On the radio, we hear a lot of performers who have been educated with imperatives like “own the stage” and “steal the show” even though it might not serve the song. For them, In Your Eyes could be about a man who sings “I am complete”.
If the real subject is the relationship he's trying to save, then why should he occupy the forefront? The heat he's talking about is probably better personified by the percussions. But yes, as humans we relate to vocals first, so it makes mixing even harder if we don't focus on them.

Thanks for reviewing it. I would like the hand drums separate from the kit; but, I'm probably not ready for that anyway. I'm not reviewing others, because, I only have my laptop speakers to listen thru. I do have Bose headphones they are with the rest of my stuff in a storage, hopefully for not much longer, so next class, I'll listen carefully to everyone's.

You're almost getting a mono sound with your tiny laptop speakers close to one another. It could be a good opportunity to try mixing in mono:
[external link withheld] [link withheld]
You're lucky, you won't have to resist the temptation to use headphones that make everything sound great Image omitted from this public edition

Interesting idea. I drive thru remote, mountainous areas of the desert all the time listening to the radio and it changes noticeably I guess this mono thing is why. I looked in Soundation but didn't see how to switch to mono. I looked under settings but didn't find it. I'm at the same level of ignorance in Soundation, Cubase LE and Audacity (and as you can tell from my profile photo my Canon software too) Oh, dear, I have a lot of software to learn.

If your sound card doesn't have a mono output option, there are two other solutions:
1/ Use a virtual audio cable (for instance, V-B cable) and configure it with only one channel. It's something I only discovered recently because, like you, I couldn't find any other way to deal with Soundation. We'll see in module 6 if it's practical enough to be used for an entire mix.
2/ Put a plug-in like HOFA 4U Meter on the master fader of Cubase LE. Apparently, we aren't allowed to export the individual stems for In Your Eyes, but you can experiment with Air Traffic's stems from PWYM#1. Personally, it helped me hear better the masking effects, so my mix sucks far less than it used to, there's more separation between each instrument.

Oh, it's a sound card thing. I have a gaming laptop with large sound and graphics card. It came with no instructions, just, like a pamphlet, seriously. Participant 526 the cable to what? I only have a Zoom H4n. No other outboard gear.

Post #11 is omitted from the public reading edition to protect personal information.

Thanks for that info. Idk tho the SiSo freeware looks iffy to me. Not that I don't use cnet sometimes, it is just google, but not for that...Idk

OK, let's forget about software and use In Your Eyes' convergent mix to reach a similar result: if you place your head above your laptop speakers, can you actually hear all the instruments panned across the stereo field? Following Bradford Swanson's advice, it's likely to happen when your head and speakers form an equilateral triangle: [external link withheld] [link withheld]
I hope your laptop tastes good Image omitted from this public edition
Now that it kind of gives you an idea of the original stereo panning, you can try to move away from your speakers until it feels like all the instruments are dead center. It won't be perfect mono, but maybe close enough...

ok I did that. Actually, I all ready did kind of do that. Stereo panning is easy to detect on gaming laptops, they blast it. They are kind of fun. The graphics, etc.

If they reflect accurately the settings for In Your Eyes, then you're probably better off than most of us using headphones. It's cool that these laptops aren't snubbing old school stereo in spite of the virtual 3D - whoa 360° panning thing.

Here is the balancing practice for Peter Gabriel's, "In Your Eyes". I still tend to want to toggle back and forth between the provided mix and my mix as I worked on the project. I enjoyed the process working with tracks in a well thought out sequence of challenges that increased gradually in difficulty. Looking forward to the next module!

Embedded media omitted from this public edition

[external link withheld] [link withheld]

I think in the original mix bass is too overlapped and the vocal was so low that it sounded remote. In my mix, I enhanced vocal to ensure that all instruments surrounding the leading vocal and bass can be heard clearly. I placed kit on right and kitbass on left. Since in the module we were taught that don't get distracted by one sound, I think in this mix I did balance the whole thing.
here is my remixzishuai zou's remix [link withheld]
[external link withheld] [link withheld]

Hey lisa
I checked almost all the remix here and yours got my attention. Your remix accentuated leading vocal and created a good balance. I especially loved your adjustment on bass. I actually emphasized bass to get a stronger sense of rhythm. you probably wanna check mine(Participant 773's post)!