COMMUNITY ARCHIVE Selected reading edition · 2014–2020
Play With Your MusicCommunity archive
← Community & more

By Genre/Style

Lyrically frustrated songwriters

26 readable posts · Team contributions are labelled separately from community replies.

I know lyric writing is not the point of this course, but I was wondering if there are any other lyrically frustrated people in this class.

I'm sure there are tons. You could count me among them.

Likewise. I've been focusing lately on songwriting, so I'm coming up against this more often. I think the trick is just to KEEP GOING. Keep writing, don't let your inner critic stop you. If it's crap, let it be crap, but just get it on the page. Eventually the good stuff will flow.

[participant mention] [link withheld] I'm trying to cultivate this attitude, and remind myself that the working title of "Yesterday" was "Scrambled Eggs." I need to loosen up.

I wouldn't say I'm "frustrated", I feel pretty decent about my writing, but I do wish it was easier for me. I think songwriting changes from genre to genre a bit, typically at least, I'm not going to say absolutely. Regardless, I'll share some things that work for me or what I kinda live by.

  • I'll start off with what [participant mention] [link withheld] said. Keep Going. I think its especially important to keep in mind when youre writing and you feel really good about the bast few bars but you feel stonewalled. At that point, grab another sheet of paper, Forget any expectations you have for yourself and just flow, just go, get it out, all while having a vague direction being the idea of feeling you're trying to invoke.

-If you ever feel discouraged and feel like youre just not creative enough or any of that crap, try something thats just more fun. Put your main focus aside, find something fun to write about. You can do this by checking out "writing prompts" you can use this in song form, prose, or write a short story. For example, one of my favorites is "Imagine you're in a field, or forest, or mountains or what have you, and imagine you see a door that has no business being there. What's it look like, what's on the other side?" Thats a fun one to reuse and get you feeling creative again, get that confidence then go back to your focus when you feel good about your abilities again.

  • If I'm writing in rhyme (usually I am, I like rap) but feel stuck like my flow is starting to get weak and I'm forcing rhymes, I'll start just writing in prose, I forget about the rhyme or the flow, I just write in prose trying to grasp the emotion or feeling that I'm working towards. Usually through that I find another way to say what I'm trying to say, then I get to draw connections and thats a really fun thing to do, also I think it shows more mindfulness.

-Know when to go into "open" or "closed" mode. I get this notion from this excellent lecture: by John Cleese of Monty Python [link withheld]. When your open, your receptive to influence, your mind is loose, just gathering ideas, letting it come to you, dont force anything, sometimes you gotta stick with it longer, then when you get ahold of something inspiring, go into closed mode. thats when your focused, tunnel vision, frantically write down that capture that inspiration. when you get roadblocked again, go back into open mode and fish for some inspiration.

  • carry a notebook always. I hope you do this already. any type of writer will tell you that this is a must. I'm always writing down words or phrases or ideas or just a few bars. Just last night I was watching looney tunes (yes I still watch looney tunes) and in the episode "Baseball Bugs" the "bad guy team" was named "Gas-House Gorillas". Thats an awesome word and would be really fun to drop that reference in a song so I wrote it down haha. It's a goofy example but trust me, having a word/phrase bank is super helpful.

  • Final note, if you're feeling like you head is spinning and cant get a grip with your writing, go back and copy someone else. One think I really like doing is finding a song, or poem, or hook or whatever that I love, copy it into word, add extra space between each line, then write a parallel story using the completed material as the skeleton and write your lines underneath the original. I feel like this really helps your sense of direction.

So if you're frustrated, keep trying different things! find what works. Dont limit yourself to just "songwriting" get comfortable with all sorts of creative writing and use all those elements together when it comes to writing that song youve been trying to get out.

Footnote: this probably only partly relates but I'm such an advocate I'm gonna plug it anyway. try Freestyling! Im awful at it and I don't care its really fun and once in a while I surprise myself with a really cool simile or metaphor and then I write that shit down. It really boosts your creativity skills.

If you're looking for feedback dont hesitate to ask.

EDIT: dont know how my post ended up with sub bullets. interpret them all there own thought

2nd EDIT: I just remembered another tip I keep in mind. Build confidence, it means a lot. There's a reason why Tiger Woods sinks 50+ 10 foot puts before a tournament or why basketball players begin warmups with simple layups. If you're struggling to write a song, go back and sink some putts for confidence, just write 2 juicy lines, or a hook. Then you feel good and come back to your main focus while also building that handy word/phrase bank

Great advice [participant mention] [link withheld] thanks for this!

Yep. I don't have to many problems pumping out tunes that are decent, but lyrics are trickier. I also tend to find that to get good lyrics I need to be on a 'roll' - once I get going, I get better results if I keep going for as long as possible in one hit. I find with composition, I'm much more able to get the basic stuff in one hit, and then come back and add new things incrementally in a way that still feels creative.

The thing I've found most useful lyric writing is simply to complete. No matter how good or bad you think your lyric is, you simply have to finish the whole song, and then you can decide if it's crap or not. Sometimes what makes a song lyric is not so much a given line, but how everything works as a unity. And, if nothing else, completion at least forces you to keep making, and to at least have SOMETHING finished. Somtimes, I find I can also recycle lines from lyrics I've written previously but wasn't entirely happy with, or didn't have a good tune to attach to

I like what [participant mention] [link withheld] said as well. Having something completed feels good, just make sure you let it simmer for a while (I've let things simmer for months before and have heard of famous poets letting things sit for over a year) and come back with a clear mind ready to rip that shit apart and chew off the fat so that only what belongs there remains and then beef it back up again and repeat until you have something Participant 374.

Lots of good ideas here... personally, I would like to expand on the "copy someone else" thing: I do that a lot, not in the form of "copying" but in the form of : "write lyrics taken from something already existing/make lyrics out of something that wasn't intended as such". It helps a lot in trying to figure out what works and what doesn't, and besides you don't have to worry about self-confidence that much...

Another thing along those lines is to practice writing lyrics to pre existing songs. Songs with regular time signatures, pop structures and melody notes of a fairly regular and consistent length are good ways to start with this.

You don't get the same kick out of creating from scratch, but the up side is that you have all the rhyming points, breaths, etc already in place, so you can just practice writing lyrics. If it turns out well, you can always transplant those lyrics onto a similar structure, but adjust the melody, musical progression and tempo later on.

Hey guys, sorry I'm a little late to this party, I just realized there are all sorts of forums here. I really like a lot of the points [participant mention] [link withheld] made, I'm definitely going to have to try employing some of those techniques. I feel that, from a creative standpoint, I am constipated. Like, my opportunities to create are not as regular as I would like (life, right?), so when I do have that time to sit down and try to make something, I strain and force to try to create something of a certain quality that would make the dry spell worthwhile. Once in a while, something comes out that I'm really proud of, but more often than not, all that straining and pushing just results in little rabbit poops, and I feel like there's still so much more that needs to come out, but I don't know how to coax it. I'm sorry for the potty metaphor, but it's the best way I could think of to describe it lol. If only there were an Activia for the mind...

Reading that post I'm reminded of something Slug from Atmosphere once talked about. In an interview he said that he used to just write prolifically on anything about anything. Serious or goofy didn't matter, he was just getting the gears going and hone his skill. He used to write four bars on napkins. It didn't matter, he would just write. If your feeling like your creative juices just arent flowin then you've probably just got too much pressure on yourself. Just create a little four bar kick or hook and write it anywhere and leave it, dont even think about it. write a hook on your napkin, make it about your meal, its stupid and goofy but you just created something, leave it on the table and let the server read it, maybe he/she will laugh. but even if they dont, so what? you're just a creative dude having some fun.

Also, a good quote to have taped up wherever you work, or maybe in your notebook:

"Half of what I say is meaningless; but I say it so that the other half may reach you." -Kahlil Gibran from Sand and Foam

I'm not sure if I would call myself frustrated, just new at it. Wanting to learn tips and tricks that lyricist use to write good material.

I'm a singer actually have a degree in vocal performance in Jazz and Classical and I have been surrounded with many DJ's that would love to work with me but they always ask me that question "can you song write"? It's quite embarrassing to say No, I've tried writing a few poems but I'm my worst critic, I get discouraged and leave projects halfway, to those savvy songwriters how can I prepare myself to write a song? how do overcome the feeling of being stuck?

Hi Ana. You'll definitely find some good tips in this thread already. Again, for me, the most important thing is to turn the 'feeling' of wanting to write into a process, and then the process into a habit. Start writing lyrics with minimal regard for quality. Set yourself a deadline (doesn't really matter how long, just stick to it!) and have a complete lyric done in that time - doesn't matter if you think it's good or not, it must just be complete in terms of having a distinct beginning, middle and end.

You may find that you do this a number of times before you start developing material that you think is any good. You may also go back later and reuse things from earlier attempts. What matters most is that you turn feeling into process, and process into habit. This requires persistence and self-discipline.

Perhaps you might also want to find other like-minded people, and keep each other accountable in terms of those deadlines, and maybe do a lyric swap each time, to look over each other's work, critique, and maybe even contribute your own ideas.

And, far from stunting your creativity, I find it actually helps defeat all the things that get in the way (self-doubt, laziness, lack of commitment, lack of focus), and ultimately gives your creativity the most opportunity to flourish.

Thanks for the tips so far everybody! I like to write songs too but since I'm not super good at any one instrument so I tend to get stuck after a point cuz I'm not sure where to go with the energy of th song. Like I write the first couple verses and the chorus and then I hit a wall. I find it a lot easier to write a complete song if someone provides me with the background music and maybe a theme, and then I can test out different ideas on it. Now I've started going with the "just finish it" tip that some of you mentioned. I find it helping a lot!

This is amazing advice Participant 217, thank you so much. Will put into work all those tips Image omitted from this public edition

It sounds like the only one really holding you back is you (which is absolutely common). You asked about preparation, and I'd back up [participant mention] [link withheld] and say that you should attack the smaller things that are bogging you down like laziness and lack of focus. I think doing things like cleaning up your work station or just your kitchen or maybe organize your desk. Anything that gives you a feeling of small personal progress can help. Also, go for a walk! aimless walks are kind of dying but it was a big part of the lives of great minds. I remember reading something strongly advocating leisurely walks to boost creativity and cited guys like Einstein and Freud and the like who all took walks regularly. It sounds like the biggest obstacle for you is yourself so just relax, there's no shortcuts to it, you got to be the one to get through it.

Also, if you're a really great singer which it sounds like you are, then draw confidence in that. There's this rapper that I love named Brother Participant 362. He has such a great voice and delivery, I could honestly listen to him read an instruction manual and could groove to it.

If you haven't yet, you might want to try to write the chorus first. It helps solidify the overall feeling or emotion that your focusing on and helps you to make sure that you're always bringing the other parts of your song back to that one main idea.Often times it can be easy to get lost in direction by trying to go in just a linear way, which is totally understandable because thats how we do most things in life. Sometime's I even write the end first and then I figure out how I want to get there.

Also, anyone thats reading this topic is more than welcome to ask me for feedback on a written piece. That's one thing I miss about school, peer review is fun. Feel free to send me a message.

(sorry for 3 posts in a row. oh well)

Participant 374 advice from [participant mention] [link withheld]. On that note, I often go for walks around my local suburb, and often end up spending some of the time singing (quietly, because otherwise people in the houses think I'm nuts! Image omitted from this public edition). I often will sing when driving to work or whatever, as well.

Also, I have a tape recording app on my phone. If I'm at home with my keyboard and I'm playing around and come up with a passage or melody I like, I'll record it. Sometimes on walks or whatever, I'll sing something or think of something and then say it into my phone. Sometimes these things come in useful later when doing more structured composing, and you'd otherwise lose them if you don't note take or record. Most smartphones these days have this kind of capability, and most can record straight to MP3, so you never need to worry about disc space. Really easy to use, and using it as essentially a dictapohone, sound quality doesn't matter too much,

While I think having structured composing time and actually limiting yourself time-wise is important as it forces you to get creative, I also think, as Patrick says, that having time that you dedicate to creatively UNFOCUS is also needed. Most of my private thinking time is on walks, and it allows your brain to stretch out of the box a little, and gather in things that you can then focus on in your more intensive composing time. Both elements are useful for a productive creative cycle.

Hello frustrated song writers. This is a really interesting as I have never been able to write lyrics and hoped to find someone to work with who can, but you have inspired me to try myself.

The main thread seems to be the eternal battle of the conscious
and subconscious to be creative and controlled at the same time. I can see techniques here such as notebooks and recorders to capture inspired moments on walks but I wonder if anyone knows more systematic methods.  I always wondered if David Bowies strips of paper with words on and randomly rearranging them was real. Has anyone ever used those poetry fridge magnets to create phrases or lines that have produced a song or at least an idea for a song?

Listening to the Kevin Killen interviews it was amazing to think the likes of Peter Gabriel and Bono still writing lyrics when the music
has been recorded. How do they stay creative under that pressure? I have just read an interesting book called ‘trying not to try’ which talks about the history of trying to ‘go with the flow’ without forcing it. As mentioned above by others the idea of just letting go and not caring about if it’s good or bad seems to be the basic conclusion. The saying ‘sing like no one’s listening’ seams very apt.

Also found on another thread is a website with literally
1000 things to write a song about that might help;  [external link withheld] [link withheld]

Yea i've been having problems here too..I'm no stranger to writing .There are some stuff i've been working on, i wrote bits of lines for a chorus, and then i'm stuck. It's strange but somehow i felt in my early 20s writing came easy. I worked on poems and some prose back then.

The problem back then was that i couldn't compose the stuff in my head, although some the lyrics back then ended sounding like poetry.I also realize that when it comes to writing lyrics i can't seem to express myself by writing about myself, it's like some how i always need to use a concept to write from.

I think i have a lot to say, but somehow i can't seem to write as myself

There are times i wonder if the creative stagnant has a lot to do internal movement. What i mean by that, i remember one time i was travelling, and the whole transition of going to somewhere new or doing something sort of triggered some ideas in my head.

So i wonder was life experience part of the inspiration deal? So maybe if you're just living on routine it's hard to experience internal consciousness unless you're moved by external experience of experiencing your life. I don't know but i feel a lot like a stuck sink.

[participant mention] [link withheld] Hey, I didn't know that was Kalil Gibran... I knew it from John Lennon "Half of what I say is meaningless But I say it just to reach you, Julia."

I find myself with a lot of lyrics that I really like, and sometimes with the musical ideas and melodies to go with them. But I tend to get stuck trying to finalize the song structure and settle on the best place for a chorus or bridge.

Also, I agree with [participant mention] [link withheld] and others, that it is best to write as much as possible in one sitting to capture the creative moment and explore all of the lyrical possibilities. But then I tend to want to keep all of it in the song. Editing for length is difficult for me. I often borrow leftover lyrics from one song for another, but then I sometimes end up with a confusing overlap between the songs.

Maybe I should rely more on the process of recording and playback to discern which lyrics and ideas are really worth keeping.

I have just done the song analysis of New Orders 'True Faith' and I noticed that again the lyrics, as with Peter Gabriels 'Sledghammer, are not exactly what I presumed them to be about. Maybe we are being to picky with the lyrics trying to get them to make sense when what is really needed is to convey the feel of the song.

So as noted by Participant 196 B maybe the process of recording and playback is a good tool to discern which lyrics work and which don't. Maybe it's also useful to get another persons opinion as we may be too close to decide.

I picked New Orders 'True Faith' as it is a song I cannot stop dancing too. I used the version off the singles CD and copied it into Cubase so I could analyse it in detail, probably too much. Also I added the bar positions as I found it easier than using the time position. Its a little longer than the video version but it still makes sense.

[external link withheld] [link withheld]