COMMUNITY ARCHIVE Selected reading edition · 2014–2020
Play With Your MusicCommunity archive
← Community & more

By Genre/Style

Acoustic recording & mixing group

68 readable posts · 6 retained privacy notices · Team contributions are labelled separately from community replies.

Acoustic recording & mixing goup

Hi every body I would like to create a group for people interested in recording and mixing of
acoustic material. I would like to learn and to improve how to record acoustic instruments most authentically, how to positioned in a room, and mix them that listeners feel like sitting among the musicians. So I hope there are people around the world interested in the same and
would like to join this working group. Looking forward to see people joining. So long Jan

Hi [participant mention] [link withheld], I play and record a lot of acoustic instruments and I'd like to join your group to discuss such things. I'm not too familiar with this site and design though, how do I join?

Hey guys, interested in this group as well - [participant mention] [link withheld] - I've just clicked the Regular/Watching/Tracking/Muted button underneath the comments and selected Watching - it seems this will probably let us keep track of conversations in here.

[participant mention] [link withheld] thanks, looks like that is the way.

Count me in! I'm a singer/songwriter/guitarist with a home project student using Logic X.

Thank you all for joining, Scot has a nice internet page with some of his material Glen and Patrick do you have material online to here? Looking forward to work and to have some fun with you. If you are interested this was my last recording project Vermillion Blue [link withheld]

Hi, I'm interested in joining. I'm playing acoustic piano.
Thank you for creating this group!
Nadia

I'm interested in recording and mixing my own acoustic stuff. I have no real experience but am very interested to learn!

Post #10 is omitted from the public reading edition to protect personal information.

Hi What I currently do is most closely related to this subject. I'm a singer with a working cover band; which, I also produce. I've never been behind the board for more than a dinner set. I am, though, a purist, it is just me and my mic. (Shure SM58's) I put up and tear down equipment all the time. I make decisions about set ups in venues (ballroom type) and outdoors. I do know some stuff about making adjustments for, say, desert high winds, etc. So far, I have no idea what's going on this class, except, I don't think doing the sonic frequency test with headphones on is a good idea:) Made my head hurt with bare ears and my laptop.

Hello,
I would like to join this group. I am a drummer and always very interested in acoustic recording. I have some experience with different DAWs, but Audacity is my tool of choice most of the time. I teach music at the University of Sao Carlos, Brazil and it is fundamental that we use open software. Hope to learn a lot here!

Super, now we have Drums, Bass, Piano , vocals, may be we are able to create a Song together and use the Song for the Mixing Tasks. So if some one has already a Song idea would be grate if you can share to make some music together.

Hello,
I'm Margarita. I'm interested in joining. I play guitar and cello. Image omitted from this public edition

Post #15 is omitted from the public reading edition to protect personal information.

Our group is growing. So now we have guitar, cello, piano, drums bass female and male vocals and songwriter. Yasemin, I like you music on soundcloud very much, nice melodies!

So my idea is to take a song and everyone who like to participate by playing an instrument or singing records her or his part and we end up with audio tracks we can use for mixing experiences and to learn from each other.

So all of you, who like to participate on creating music together and using this for the PWYM workshop please raise your hands. If someone in our group likes to share a song idea to work on this would be great.

looking forward to get some feedback

Also have years of experience with guitar, here's a link to something quick I recorded a few weeks back with the intention to write lyrics and sing (very basically) over the top later on - [external link withheld] [link withheld]

I'd love to contribute guitar tracks to any music we decide to collaborate together on - it's a pretty great opportunity to work with a bunch of talented people across the globe!

I've studied a few classes at uni on music production (mixing/recording etc.) so I have a fairly basic knowledge of the artform, and can certainly work my way around Logic without issue.

No experience mixing/playing with any Peter Gabriel songs however, I find remixing and 'touching up' old material (whether it's mine or someone else's) a difficult task because I find myself becoming attached to the original too much haha

Hi Jan, sounds good to me. I also play acoustic guitars and will be glad to contribute to something shared. Should be an interesting experience. Thanks.

Whatever everybody wants to do!

Thanks Jan! How shall we start this? We can...

A) choose an existing acoustic song that we really like and follow it's structure. Then the main instruments maybe starting with guitar can give us a few ideas/auditions we choose one and layer on top.
B) Pick some kind of theme like, unrequited love, snail farts...etc. here's a site that has all these different themes/ideas: [external link withheld] [link withheld]Then go through the same process with guitar laying down some tracks and other instruments and vocalists layering on top of it. We don't necessarily have to end up with one song.
3) somebody just throw something out there?

Hi Yasemin, all three ideas sound good.

I'm happy to join in writing new songs based on Yasemin's link posted above, otherwise I've had a quick search on the net for some classic, well-known songs that focus on acoustic guitars and vocals, but easy to implement instruments like Cello, Piano, Bass and Percussion:

Mr Big - To Be With You - [external link withheld] [link withheld]

CCR - Have You Ever Seen The Rain? - [external link withheld] [link withheld]

Fleetwood Mac - Landslide - [external link withheld] [link withheld]

Phil Collins - Another Day In Paradise - [external link withheld] [link withheld]

Or perhaps we can even transform a much more different song into something a little more laid-back and acoustic:

Michael Jackson - Rock With You - [external link withheld] [link withheld]

Obviously there's thousands more choices, these were just a few that popped up in my mind.

Feel free to shoot through any other ideas, and we can have a quick vote on it soon.

//EDIT - Well this is strange, the website won't allow me to post more than three times in a single topic because I'm a 'new user'? Which means I have to edit an old post.

Anyway, hey [participant mention] [link withheld], I couldn't find your email address on your profile to be added to the shared Dropbox, so I'll just dump it here in hopes you'll see it and add me as well:

[email withheld]

I agree with the non-copyrighted music idea, it'd be much more beneficial for all of us to collaborate in creating something new.

Post #23 is omitted from the public reading edition to protect personal information.

The chapman stick? I think, they have a chapman stick orchestra in Santa Cruz, California, I believe, I lived there briefly. Interesting instrument. I should say, I don't have a home studio yet. I only have a laptop, Zoom H4n, and guitars. I don't have external mic's or anything yet. The Zoom's pretty nifty though.

I would like to join this group too. I'm a songwriter and play piano and work in Pro Tools. Here's my latest: [external link withheld] [link withheld]

I'm interested in joining this crew. I'm in Northern California. I'm learning low-G tenor ukulele (G2 to D4), guitar and UBass (bass ukulele but the same scale as a bass guitar). I've written a couple of songs and tunes using Finale and Tabledit. I've spent a fair amount of time with Audacity to record vocals and instruments and songs so I can create loops for practice or to discover tone centers and notes or chords. I am just beginning to learn DAW with Ableton Live Kontakt 5. I have recently joined a vocal group that entertains folks in hospitals and retirement communities. I know just enough to be dangerous .

I'd be happy to follow Participant 550's lead on songwriting. We could do a brainstorming session to identify some concepts that strike a chord (pun intended) with the group. Writing a new song adds a layer of complexity, so I would have no problem with the crew choosing an existing song to use as a base. Just to start juices flowing, Elephants that Fly might be an interesting song to work up. ([external link withheld] What other candidates are interesting?

Hi Lara, I think you have a home studio (may be a verys small one) I think your can use your Zoom H4n [link withheld] as sound card for your laptob via USB port. So you should be able to use the Participant 291 or the line input from the ZOOM to directely record on your Laptop. You need to have a DAW software like Reaper [link withheld], Cubase (LE) [link withheld], Ableton [link withheld], Garage Band [link withheld] installed on your Laoptob. I think ZOOM sales your device with Cubase LE bundle. To complete you home studio, you need good head phones and connectivity to a stereo speakers Participant 001. I hope this helps

The DropBox folder is created and online. Participant 514 already has access. Send me your e-mail address if you want to get access as well. Looking forward to see you mail coming in! Jan

Nice Song, nice play

Thank you very much! That song was done long-distance, with me in
California and the singer, Bridget Davis, in New York, sending music and
vocal files via email and Dropbox.

OK, I am overwhelmed by the talent in this group. I hope to be able to contribute and add some small part. Very nice work, David.
As to suggesting songs that are not under copyright, my limited view would be to cover very old classics or write something original. Not my strong suit.
How can I help move the project forward?
Thanks.

I've added one draft song to the dropbox. I wrote it as an exercise using Pablo Neruda's poem "The Condor" as a lyric. No lyric in the dropbox file, just melody. I'm not proposing this song as much as offering insight to my limited experience. The song was written in Finale and the output is Finale instruments. I'm not yet able to play this song .

[email withheld] Thanks for organizing it.

Thanks adding. I thing its a nice idea, that could be developped further. Should be recorded from real musician, because its obviously a machine playing. It the same with the song I added. The drum are from midi patterns. So hope we get some more ideas from other member of our group.

Your voice is beautiful! Enjoyed listening to the first song on Soundcloud.
Nadia

David, wow @ Fly fly, from the music to the vocals...really beautiful.

Hi Jan my email is [email withheld],

Thank you Nadia:) Years of singing in the shower Image omitted from this public edition

Well thank you very much! We just finished it so I'm so glad people like it, thank you for your comment!

I like your song. It's very renaissance or Scarborough Fair. What does just the rhythm track sound like? It's a very strong melody and since we don't everybody's specific range vocally and level of playing and reading, starting from a strong rhythm track, I think, is going to necessary. You know, Scarborough Fair is public domain, for sure, I have a weird Pete Seeger songbook from the used book store in San Francisco and I think everything in it is public domain. It's in my storage space, oops. But, what about a mix of something like "Clementine". It actually has like 6 verses. Or, Kumbaya, accommodates the rhythmic needs for this project. From the other list on here, I like, "Rock with You" best. But, the arrangement has to be re-done; because, the male falsetto as in its recorded arrangement, is not going to lend itself well to a multi-instrumentalist and vocal group project. There is a mix of it, I think, with Alicia Keys and Mya(?) from 10 years ago.

I've just uploaded one more possibility to the Dropbox, a half-baked song that's been languishing in a folder for awhile that I called "Almost Home," it's all midi and has no lyrics at this point.

That is a nice Idea. Perhaps Lara and Yasemin can say if they think they can do vocals to this.

Lara, thanks. Rhythm seems to be my major weakness. I struggle to find a good strum to go with songs. I can play many rhythms, just have a hard time feeling the one that is best. What you heard is what I have. If there is interest, I can provide the Finale file or a pdf copy. I'm open to what works best for the group and will likely do a lot of following....

I'll sing or play guitar, it doesn't matter, I'm along for the ride, to investigate the process:). My gig is all mid-tempo and uptempo, I do ballads, they just require more patience to work up lol. I don't do torch songs, etc, at the convention gigs for obvious reasons. If this is a song that is going to remain in the realm of acoustic, I guess, the meter is fine. If we plan to do a mix of it. I think we will have a better time with something that starts out syncopated. I lack recording technique; but, I do know, as a singer and dancer, that mixes on, like, Adele (who I like) are awful. So, it needs to be at least one, TWO, three, FOUR, or to really be able to mix it up, one AND two AND three AND four AND. The latter is how I count everything. The AND would be where you, as they say, lean, in hip hop. So, it would be one LEAN two LEAN three LEAN four LEAN.

What does "lean" mean? Would you give me an example?
Is it just a different name for an up beat?

I also hear sixteenth beats as, One eh and ah Two eh and ah Three eh and ah Four eh and ah, with emphasis where needed.

Thanks.

Basically, all jazz, R&B, hip hop, some pop and rock "leans". It's a way to count music so that you can find the nuances of the beat. I just used lean as an example to translate cause there's songs say lean in them and stuff. So, just stand up and count 1&2&3&4& and on the & lean slightly to one side (or bend one knee slightly) and repeat it. Then apply it to a piece of music in 4/4 time. I think it's necessary for a song to mix up for the dance floor lol. Let me know if that makes sense to you or not:)

oh, it's a down beat.

Post #50 is omitted from the public reading edition to protect personal information.

Truth is, I joined 3 groups, the girls, hip hop and acoustic, so, I think this song fits almost all of them, kind of, besides, I kept thinking of it when I watched the Clara Berry videos, and, well, I admit it, I wanted to start with something easy and female:)

Mod2 Space Graph Mazzy Star Fade Into You.pdf [link withheld] (88.4 KB)

Fade Into You Video: [external link withheld] [link withheld]

Here is my Mod 2 Perceived Space Graph of Sweet Baby James by James Taylor:
Sweet Baby James #PWYM Perceived Space Graph.pdf [link withheld] (91.7 KB)

I struggled a bit with the placement and size for the bass, guitar and vocal, but felt they were all up front with different emphasis in different parts of the song. I felt the slide guitar was over his right shoulder.

I looked at the music. I am not familiar w/Finale. I am a little familiar w/Guitar Pro's permanent trial. I read the Wikipedia for Finale as their trial version doesn't give you the sounds, only writing and printing capabilities. So, the Wiki said you can choose the playing style or feel. Does it have 1/8 rock or 1/16 rock or shuffle (blues or country), maybe even swing? Nobody's told me if this is studio mix or something we are going to bust up with some beats. But, I think the tempo needs to come up above 80.And, the feel needs to be on a downbeat.

Post #54 is omitted from the public reading edition to protect personal information.

Ok, whatever everybody wants to do. I thought this class was about doing a mix of the chosen artists songs in the fashion a DJ would do for a club. Or, on ambient end, a new age yoga class piece. But, then I wasn't sure that's what everybody had in mind for this project.
A shuffle is a feel written in 4/4 and counted as 12/8. There are slight variations on it, as in, Kansas City Shuffle, Blues shuffle, Country Honky Tonk, etc. 1/8 rock and 1/16 rock are also common feels. The guys that play with me, they will just say, blues shuffle in E or something and take off playing. I thought that is what Wikipedia meant when it said it gave you choices in playing style; because, that's what I know that to mean. I was just trying to move us into something that had a downbeat. It will be more friendly to work with, as contemporary musicians with different approaches to theory. Since the piano players probably read really well and the guitar players may or may not at all. We a rhythm track to build on.

Post #56 is omitted from the public reading edition to protect personal information.

[external link withheld] [link withheld]

Here's mine. I tried to pick something that would be easy for me, but, it took a really long time. This suddenly got all complicated:)

Little Richard #PWYM Musical Structure Graph b.xlsx [link withheld] (27.5 KB)
Here is mine. This was a bigger challenge than I expected. I tried several songs before settling on this one. I discovered I did not know many of the instruments in the other songs. I had to use Audacity to slow the song down to count measures. Too easy to get lost.

Welcome, Yuliya. It looks like all the crews have slowed activity on the forums. Join in!

Hey, well, I listened to it and looked at it. Wow, it's complex. Live music is a hard choice for this. You got close. I just don't think that tempo is that fast. You must live in Hawaii or go there all the time. I used try to pick up a local record when I went there. I don't get over there much anymore. I started flying for work and now I'm, like, 1500 miles on a plane for a 4 day special. lol Did you listen to mine?:) You don't have too.

Hi Lara, thanks for the review. I did look at yours, and that is what lit the fire under me to get mine done. I wanted to finish mine, and learn, before commenting. I'll take a more educated look this afternoon and reply. I'm struggling with tempo a bit, and used a metronome with a tap function to follow strum strokes to get the tempo. That may not be the best way. I've learned that following the bass line may not be a good method. The solos seem slower to me, but they are more complex and intentionally different. How do you count tempo? Thanks.

PS: just back from a short drive to UCLA, about 1,000 miles. . Flying low.

Tempo is the rate you tap your foot at. So, I actually, sort of stomp my heel:) I just do that and adjust the metronome until its the same. UCLA? You work in the university Participant 001? I know far too many people that teach/work at UCLA for someone that's never taken a class there. Metronomeonline.com is a dial like the one I have packed in my storage space. And, simple.bestmetronome.com has the little swing arm, that one's easy cause you can snap your fingers to the beat and swing your arm too until they swing at the same time.

I know that there is a tempo detection tool on this #PWYM site, but I've lost track of it. I did a Google search and found a free tool called, "BPM Counter" and installed it. It reads music and reports the bpm. It tells me that Little Richard is at 154 bpm. Tapping on my KORG KDM-2 metronome gave me the bpm's reported in my analysis above as 141-144 bpm. Am I doing something wrong? I got a report that my tempo was too fast. I used strumming frequency as bpm in 4/4 time, with one beat per strum stroke. Thanks.

Hi Lara, I looked at your musical structure again. I thought you did a good job with it when I first looked at it, and have the same opinion after doing mine. I checked bpm with my Korg KDM-2 tap metronome and then with the BPM Counter software. I got 77-78 bpm at the beginning, middle and end, and the BPM Counter gave 77.95. That comes very close to your 82. I also agreed with your number of measures.

I had trouble recognizing the pedal steel guitar. It helped me to go through your analysis. Thanks.

I also have a DigiMan Solo XT looper that has a foot tempo button. I was not so consistent in bpm measurements with it. .

I listened to yours again. I don't think its quite that fast. I think it does speed up and slow down somewhat throughout; but, it's live, and the bar for that is do they stay together when they do. And, they do stay together. I guess maybe your gadget is latching onto something maybe because it can't find a kick drum or bass. Why it measures mine in the 70's I don't know, it can't be. I'd say ditch the gadgets and tap your foot but I don't know if Tiesto (who I did like back when he was a DJ that did a mystic mix) could do that and he's got hit records now as a producer. Go figure:) I'm gonna look for the gadget on this site.

I looked at yourvideo again and the lead guy if tapping his heels right and left in the section before the harp solo. Match the metronome to his feet:)

Lara, thanks. The lead guy is Lil' Rev. The two foot tap still seems like 144 or so to me, and it matches the strum pattern. However, if I look at other players feet, such as the other Uke solo player (James Hill) standing near the uke-less vocalist, I see half of Lil' Rev's foot falls and count 71 bpm. That seems to match the other players on the stage, where I can see constant foot falls or movements.

That makes it seem to me that Lil' Rev is strumming in sixteenth notes, with 8 down strokes per measure. That would mean that I have twice as many measures as I should.

Looks like I should have only counted one foot fall from Lil' Rev.

Thanks for your help. I've learned something. Much appreciated.

Listening to it I thought it would come in about 110. I marked it and got 112. That one's hard there's not anything really to actually mark time on. I'm a dancer too so I'm used to finding rhythm in all kinds of ways and have a lot of this memorized in my muscle memory:) They're good though. Thanks for turning me on to them. When I 1st saw Rev I thought it was going to be some Avenged Sevenfold something:) I like hard rock not them so much. Synister's ok w/me though lol

I used an app on my mobile called 'mobile metronome' and that came up with a 140-144 tempo varying through the song. I just tapped what felt like the beat but it seamed to vary a lot.

Thanks for contributing, Participant 450. Much appreciated.

That's not right. Watch his feet in the section before he starts playing the harmonica. He's goes left right left right on and on that's the tempo. Count to that and then turn on your metronome. It's a hard one:)

Lara, I'm not certain I understand your method of matching beats (foot movements) to the metronome. Your suggestion was to count to the footfalls and then turn on your metronome. How are you matching your count to the metronome? Are you finding the tempo, turning on the metronome, and then adjusting the metronome to your foot beat?

I'm still getting about 142 bpm in the section just prior to the final harmonica solo.

I'm pretty sure I don't yet understand but I found a video that may be showing one bit of useful education on tempo:
Hearing the beat in Tango music [link withheld] I'm finding a higher tempo than the spoken tempo, and the video helps me understand my error for that song.
I'm measuring about 130-132 bpm on my own, and then after hearing the spoken beats I'm understanding 62 bpm.
Back to my research.....

Yes just count 1 2 3 4 and match footfalls w/him and then catch up the metronome. Generally, in these type things its easier to bring something up than down to hear it best. Maybe start at 90 and go up. I just had another interest in collaboration fall apart. Oh my:)

[external link withheld] [link withheld] . enjoy Image omitted from this public edition

Nice. Thanks for sharing. Love the Floyd-ish part- David Gilmore-esque guitars (you missed a couple of minor notes in that scale:) It's really lovely. Maybe for one of the needle drop websites for selling it in indie films or something.