COMMUNITY ARCHIVE Selected reading edition · 2014–2020
Play With Your MusicCommunity archive
← Music Multitracks

Music Multitracks

4c - Project: Reverse Engineer a Mix and Share it with the PWYM Community

11 readable posts · Team contributions are labelled separately from community replies.

Project 2: Reverse engineer our reference mix of Sledgehammer and/or In Your Eyes

Task 1: Reverse engineer and match our reference mixes

Now the real fun begins! Launch Google Chrome and load up our Sledgehammer [link withheld] or In Your Eyes [link withheld] online mix tools. Depending on your internet bandwidth and geographic location, it may take upwards of a couple minutes to load the audio files on the above web tool. Please be patient and wait until the audio files are completely downloaded and loaded. You're downloading the equivalent of 10 song-length MP3s - one for each fader channel in the interface.

Note: Our tool is NOT optimized for mobile devices like iPads and tablets. Please complete this project using a laptop or desktop computer.

If you are listening on a good Participant 001, and if you have been listening to the YouTube versions of Sledgehammer and In Your Eyes, you'll likely notice that the online mix has many signatures of MP3 compression - dullness and transient blurring in particular [link withheld]. Just know that this is not a short coming of your production skills but is a necessary side-effect of our online workflow. Recording studios always try to operate at higher resolution than the release format, using MP3s only at the last stage: when the mix is released for download. In order for us to hear the contributing multitrack stems, we've had to compress all of them to MP3s, with a slight sonic penalty. If you are hearing this, CONGRATS. It means your critical listening chops have risen to the challenge!

Reverse engineering our mix

  1. To get started, consider creating a perceived space graph for the reference mixes for either In Your Eyes [link withheld] or Sledgehammer [link withheld]. Here's the template if you need the link again [link withheld].
  2. Start by choosing a stem that you feel most confident in in terms of it's placement left to right and balance level in the mix. Click play and advance the track to a point in the song where that track is playing.
  3. Mute the two leftmost tracks (Mix L & Mix R), and slowly bring up the fader on the track you are starting with. Place the fader where you think it should be and adjust the panning setting for that track to place the sound approximately where you hear the sound.
  4. While that track is up, unmute the Mix L and Mix R tracks, and mute the track you were working on to compare if your balance and panning settings are close to what you heard in the reference mix. If it's close, move on to another track and repeat the process. If not, go back and listen to the reference and try a different set of settings.

Repeat the above process (or improvise your own preferred process!) and try to reverse engineer the exact panning and balance settings that we used to create the reference mix in either Sledgehammer or In Your Eyes.

This is a challenging project. Feel free to take frequent breaks to clear your ears and mind. Also, when you think you have the mix matched, take a break and come back again a few minutes later to check your work. We'll share the actual settings for our our reference mixes at the beginning of the next module.

Once you’ve finished your mix:

  1. Write up a couple paragraphs detailing your personal process of recreating our mixes. What challenges did you face? What did you learn? How close do you think you came to recreating the reference mix?
  2. Copy the URL of your recreated mix.
  3. Share the URL of your mix and what you’ve learned to your PWYM crew, and then to our Module 4 Project Share space. Feel free to also add a screenshot of your mix settings so that we can see your solutions at a glance.

Task 2: Create your own creative mix of Sledgehammer or In Your Eyes

Now that you’ve synthesized your critical listening skills working hard to match our mixes, use the same tool to create your own creative static mix with balance and pan settings that YOU like. As you do so, keep track of your personal process and the creative, musical decisions you make in the mix process.

As with Task 1:

  1. Write up a couple paragraphs detailing the process and decision making behind your creative mix. What challenges did you face? What did you learn?
  2. Copy the URL of your creativemix.
  3. Share the URL of your mix and what you’ve learned to your PWYM crew, and then to our Module 4 Project Share space. Feel free to also add a screenshot of your mix settings so that we can see your solutions at a glance.
  4. Lastly, be sure to make some time to listen to and provide feedback on the mixes of your fellow classmates!

Wow. Thanks to Peter for letting us work with these stems and to Paul for the instrument intro and the musicians. Having listened to these songs in depth for years there is still undiscovered nuance for me in listening to the stems. There are guitar parts that I had never really heard, and who knew there was a piano in Sledgehammer!

So far I've just tried to match the reference mix of Sledgehammer [external link withheld] [link withheld] which to my ears is pretty close to the reference, but farther from the original than I thought. The baked-in reverb on both the horns and snare sound compressed or something that doesn't seem as open as the original recordings, but as close as I can get with these stems. I wonder how my settings will compare with the reference settings! Other things I've noticed:
- the drums sound best just slightly panned, perhaps I have some phase cancellation in my speaker setup?
- I didn't think it possible to be more amazed by Tony's bass playing and tone, but now that I can solo it, I can listen to that all day long. Thanks for the info about the bass octave doubler - that explains some of its richness.

I could go on, but back to finding my own mix. Some automation maybe...?
Best, Dave The K

One feature that'd be great for the first part of this assignment. Group mute, or essentially a button that lets me flip between the reference tracks and the others, so we can quickly a/b our mix to the reference!

ok, last post until you guys catch up Image omitted from this public edition I'm going to go out on a limb here and say that the reference tracks are phase-reversed from the stems. Listening to them on their own is ok, and mixing the stems sounds ok (barring that mp3 compression stuff ick) but if you play all the tracks there seems to my ears to be some cancellation...

We agree and have added this to our roadmap for improving the interface.

Good ears. Yes, there is some cancellation, but that's because the reference mix is NOT phase reversed. We are not intending users to listen to the reference mix at the same time as the stems.

The "less than ideal" artifacts you are hearing are in some ways by design to raise these issues experientially for those that hear them. In the next two modules, we'll be working in a Soundation.com environment with 44.1kHz, 16 bit WAV stems.

Image omitted from this public editionParticipant 150 said:

One feature that'd be great for the first part of this assignment. Group mute, or essentially a button that lets me flip between the reference tracks and the others, so we can quickly a/b our mix to the reference!

I just opened two tabs in my browser, one for reference, and the other for my mix. Then I just flick between tabs. It's not as efficient or effective as flip between the two mixes as I play through the song, but

For me, I'd actually rather have a timeline way to scan through the track, rather than just a back and forth scan button with a number readout. I find having a sense of where I am in space in the song helps a lot, as well as having that kind of granularity when trying to get to an exact point in the timeline.

EDIT: And here's my attempt [link withheld] to match the reference mix of In Your Eyes. I think I'm reasonably close, though I wasn't entirely certain of the position of the piano, and the level on some instruments (REALLY hard to discern the pads amongst all the other instruments, particularly the spacey piano sounds). I at least have a sense of the relative positions of the different instruments, and how that is being used, so I guess that's something Image omitted from this public edition

Image omitted from this public editionParticipant 003 said:

While that track is up, unmute the Mix L and Mix R tracks, and mute the track you were working on to compare if your balance and panning settings are close to what you heard in the reference mix.

Once you have more than two or more stems that you want to A/B, this uses fewer clicks:

... solo the Mix L and Mix R tracks, which will mute the tracks you were working on to compare if your balance and panning settings are close to what you heard in the reference mix.

If you want to A/B one stem against the reference mix, solo or mute the stem.

I wasn't smart enough to come up with this all on my own. I realized that this was the efficient way to use Solo and Mute when I saw Participant 539's convergent mix, which only has the reference tracks muted.

Here is my creative mix. I wanted to emphasize the guitar texture and pattern [external link withheld] [link withheld]. I tried various ridiculous permutations such as drums barely audible just to have a play around.

Image omitted from this public edition
Screen Shot 2014-07-17 at 18.49.54.png1343x675 189 KB
[link withheld]

My creative mix below...pulled out the guitar and piano completely...still felt well balanced but less dense...I've attached my mixer settings as well...vocal dead center...backing vocals at 3 & 9 o'clock respectively...the same with the prophet and horns...drums and bass, as always, dead center...

Participant 366

[external link withheld] [link withheld]

Image omitted from this public edition
PG Sledgehammer Creative Mix 2014-07-23 at 9.09.08 PM.png1229x818 233 KB
[link withheld]

After listening to all of the different instruments separately, I thought that the guitar part was very crisp so I increased the level of it to just about match the level of the lead vocals to make a duet kind of sound. Also, I noticed the horns and shakuhachi bamboo flute parts were very intermittent so I thought why not raise their level and make them really bold when they do come in! I also did some panning of the guitar vs. bass guitar, and tried to fit the other instruments in in a way that wasn't too choppy.

Here is my Sledgehammer remix:

[external link withheld] [link withheld]