COMMUNITY ARCHIVE Selected reading edition · 2014–2020
Play With Your MusicCommunity archive
← Music Multitracks

Music Multitracks

Module 4 Project Share: Convergent and Creative Mixes

39 readable posts · Team contributions are labelled separately from community replies.

Please share your Module 4 finished Musical Structure Graphs here for comment and discussion.

Be sure to share both a link to your mixes (copy the URLs) and post a screenshot of your mix so that we can see your convergent and creative mix settings at a glance.

Hi there,

this is my reference mix for Sledgehammer
sledgehammer/#2flsq [link withheld]

and its screenshot

Preserved course illustration or music-analysis diagram
SH - reference mix.jpg1438x567 219 KB
[link withheld]

I was very surprised listening the bass and guitars solos (Tony Levin is one of the best bassist and the guitar parts are really funny and interesting also if they are in background of the original mix).
I used the original mix as reference to set the level of my mix, comparing the different pans and volumes and checking time by time the different sound impact in some sections of the song.

I do not think I' m too far from the original mix, but I guess my mix could be too loud (the horns and the shak?) and it' s not balanced and harmonious with the same amalgam sound of the original version.

Hoping to read your opinion.

Thank you.

I' ll come back with the creative mix in the next few days Image omitted from this public edition!

Here is the link for my Sledgehammer mix [external link withheld] [link withheld]
Here is my screenshot

Image omitted from this public edition
Screen Shot 2014-07-12 at 17.16.44.png1435x782 238 KB
[link withheld]

I was rather cautious when it came to the levels - I tended to think lower levels were safer therefore better

Here is my attempt at a reference mix. I feel like I did a decent job of matching the original mix but I also feel like it could always be better (at some point I just had to stop messing with it and call it good). I really enjoyed listening to the components, especially the interesting bass line and guitar licks. When comparing the sounds I wished I could mute both tracks of the original mix with one button, as it's hard to remember volume differences that are over a second apart. A bit more fine control on jumping to specific points in the song would help speed the process too (not that I'm complaining as it is already a great tool).

I should also mention that when listening I didn't notice the need to pan any of the tracks. I see that other students are using panning so I probably missed something there. Here are my settings:

Reference Mix: sledgehammer/#1wgzi [link withheld]

Image omitted from this public edition
Sledgehammer - My Reference Mix.jpg2308x970 240 KB
[link withheld]

After enjoying that bass line so much, I decided to make my creative mix more bass-and-drum focused, so I turned up the bass/drums/guitars and panned the bass a bit to the left and the guitars a bit to the right for a bit of left-to-right call/response. I also added a bit more piano because I felt it was originally difficult to hear that instrument.

Then I de-emphasized the Shak and reduced the vocals slightly, panning the background vocals slightly left and the lead vocals ever-so-slightly right, once again to emphasize the call-and-response effect.

Creative Mix: sledgehammer/#43k7i [link withheld]

Image omitted from this public edition
Sledgehammer - My Creative Mix.jpg2304x966 242 KB
[link withheld]

To me, it sounds pretty nice this way, but I'm sure everyone will have their own favorites (which is what makes it creative). Thanks for the assignment!

This was really difficult, as I have no internet I did this in the Library with headphones with very sweaty ears. Some tracks were very hard to locate and pan for and I could barely hear any piano in the mix. It seamed to lose a lot of stereo when I mixed it but here it is at : [external link withheld] [link withheld]

and here is the screenshot

Image omitted from this public edition
Pasted image1024x768 226 KB
[link withheld]

I will have to do the creative mix on another day after I give my ears a rest but liking this very much!

Here is my Convergent Mix for Sledgehammer: [external link withheld] [link withheld]

Image omitted from this public edition
Pasted image936x500 36.2 KB
[link withheld]

It looks close to what others have come up with. Except for the horns, I used Alex Case's suggestion of going center, hard left, or hard right with the pan. I was surprised that the result did not sound heavy handed. As others have mentioned, trying to figure out what the piano should be was hard because of the difficulty of hearing it in the reference mix. That became my inspiration for a creative mix.

My creative mix started with the idea of trying to mix things so the piano part could be clearly heard. I extended that a bit to become, how could we have recorded and mixed Sledgehammer if we had a limited budget. The big savings in the budget was to 86 the horn section. I also left out the Shakuhachi because I thought it might be a bit esoteric for this rootsier type of mix. So here is the result: [external link withheld] [link withheld]

Image omitted from this public edition
Pasted image934x500 35.5 KB
[link withheld]

Right on:) Listening to yours I starting visualizing how to do choreography for this. I think that way. Too may dance classes. I didn't hear the lead vox and just having to bg vox and the drum machine at the end, really, allowed me to think of it more in the here and now. Like, before I could feel the Participant 374 4 for the dance floor, but, I kept imagining too many 80's pas de burre's and Bob Fosse cliches. I've heard these songs so much.It was hard for me to hear them any other way. I remember the 1st time I saw this video when I was little vacationing in Panama City Beach, Florida. Then I was listening to some of PG's stuff on Spotify I was less familiar with and it had a hype of, "Hey, hey, hey, hey..." like we hear all the time in top 40 hip hop now. Trip. Good job.

Here's Sledgehammer followed by In Your Eyes- my laptop speakers sound thin, so, I don't know, what does convergent mean?

Image omitted from this public edition
Pasted image1920x1080 434 KB
[link withheld]

[external link withheld] [link withheld]

Image omitted from this public edition
Pasted image1920x1080 422 KB
[link withheld]

[external link withheld] [link withheld]

Here is my creative mix which basically reduces the horns and brings the bass & guitars forward as I like their really funky sound.

[external link withheld] [link withheld]

Image omitted from this public edition
Pasted image1024x768 192 KB
[link withheld]

I would really like to mix it varying the levels throughout the track to get a better balance in the different parts.

Only got time for the first half of Module 4 so far:
[external link withheld] [link withheld]

Image omitted from this public edition
In Your Eyes 4-1.PNG1042x490 129 KB
[link withheld]

Like Participant 217 “Participant 039” said, the pads are pretty hard to pinpoint. Even after trying several combinations between the piano and the pads, I never quite reached the same musicality as in the reference song.
Following the advice to take frequent breaks led to changing my mind after each break. It wasn’t big radical changes, but significant enough to conclude that my ears can barely be trusted. Goniometers are going to be my best friends.

[participant mention] Ruthmann & Ethan Hein: when you share the reference settings for Sledgehammer and In Your Eyes, please also include those for Air Traffic, which are hard to trace back amidst the multitude of Google+ posts. It’d be helpful to retry Air Traffic and see if there’s any improvement from the totally rushed attempt done a few months ago. Thanks a lot for this challenging exercise.

Here is the link for my version of "Sledgehammer":
Sledgehammer Studio Session Mix [link withheld]

start - 00: 21:00
end - 4:41:00

Image omitted from this public edition
SH - Studio Session Mix.jpg1440x568 122 KB
[link withheld]

I' m not an '80 fun so I decide to remove (to mute off) the shak and the drums tracks completely.
The bass and the guitars (a bit on the R pan) are the body and the rhythm of the song.
The other instruments made the arrangement of the song, shaping the colour of the sound and emphasizing the different sections of the song with different pans, lowering the horns and balancig the piano and the prophet.
I put down the PG BG Vox and put up the female BG Vox to enhance "the studio session sound".

I tried to keep the "master volume" to low level to avoid the prophet to create annoying sounds.
I 'd like to add some cymbals, percussion or clapping to give more groove and sweat to the crescendo (3:13) at the end of the song.

Let me know your opinion.

I like the idea behind the creative mix and the sound too.
Perhaps you can ear the absence of the horns at the start of the Verse 3
(2:12:00 your mix time - as per Ethan Hein' s musical structur graph)
Project 1: Learning to Listen for Musical Structure
and a bit in the final crescendo,
but I like the balance you found between the piano 100% on the R pan and PG bg vox 100% on the L pan,
the strings (bass and guitars) and the synths.

I enjoy to listen your mix version.
Great job.

You’re onto something interesting. At first, it felt like a letdown to remove what makes this song a unique headbanging experience, but I think you uncovered something great by letting the guitars, the piano and the Prophet emerge after 3:12. The three of them now sound like cool 70’s music, as far as I can tell, a bit like the soundtrack of a blacksploitation movie. Anyway, 60’s, 70’s or 80’s, I love it. You could use the 3:12 break as a new melody and build a progression from here. It’s crazy how prolific this song is.

In Your Eyes creative mix:
[external link withheld] [link withheld]

Image omitted from this public edition
creative mix.PNG1040x480 127 KB
[link withheld]

Main goal: find out how much more tribal this song could sound. Apart from not managing to push the percs as much as desired, I enjoyed myself like a kindergarten kid playing Tarzan in the jungle. And then, looking at it a little more seriously, it can also be interpreted as a religious love song (“the doorway to a thousand churches”), or a dance to the God leading to trance.

Apologies in advance to people who like clean and tidy mixes. Mine always sound messy because the intention is to make you want to move on your chair with your ears feeling excited from all sides. It’s hard to achieve this and still sound thoughtfully polished, but I’ll keep trying...

Another thing you’ll notice is that the piano, pads and guitar had to be sacrificed to make room for the tribal rhythm. That's a shame, but I’ll come back to them for the remix attempt in Module 6.

My own playing is primarily roots blues. I think a lot of the "sound" of places like the Chess, Sun, and Muscle Shoals studios comes from the limited resources they had to work with. I visited the Chess studios and it was very humbling to realize how much great music came out of such a modest place. It was interesting to see how "Sledgehammer" seemed to evoke that kind of sound as it was stripped down.

I also found it interesting to think about the background that Ethan provided as to who was doing what in the recording. I felt I could hear more of what each track was contributing with Ethan's insights in mind. Based on that, I was making mixing decisions to bring out particular contributions.

Well here it is...my reverse mix of Sledgehammer:

[external link withheld] [link withheld]

Image omitted from this public edition
PG Sledgehammer Reverse Mix 2014-07-19 at 4.00.35 PM.png1207x808 236 KB
[link withheld]

Participant 366

My creative mix below...pulled out the guitar and piano completely...still felt well balanced but less dense...I've attached my mixer settings as well...vocal dead center...backing vocals at 3 & 9 o'clock respectively...the same with the prophet and horns...drums and bass, as always, dead center...

Participant 366

[external link withheld] [link withheld]

Image omitted from this public edition
PG Sledgehammer Creative Mix 2014-07-23 at 9.09.08 PM.png1229x818 233 KB
[link withheld]

Is there a lesson in the fact that "Sledgehammer" and "In Your Eyes" can be mixed so many ways and still be good songs in all of them? It seems that creating a bad mix of these songs would be the challenge.

I'm a purist myself in that I don't have much equipment. I think those studios/labels you mentioned had sweeter vocals because of the climate they are situated in. I myself am from about 40 miles from Muscle Shoals and worked as a singer for longer than I wanted too in Las Vegas. I figured that out working there. I want to start recording now and I have no intention of recording anywhere near the desert, not L.A., Vegas, Joshua Tree, San Jacinto jk, none of it. Aretha's vocals were never better than when she was in Muscle Shoals.

If singing is your main priority, I’d recommend you try one of Khaliq Glover’s Mixing Hangouts. Among many other useful things, he’s been giving good advice to singers and discussing microphone techniques that will help you collaborate better with engineers.
[external link withheld] [link withheld]

Image omitted from this public editionParticipant 331 said:

My own playing is primarily roots blues. I think a lot of the "sound" of places like the Chess, Sun, and Muscle Shoals studios comes from the limited resources they had to work with. I visited the Chess studios and it was very humbling to realize how much great music came out of such a modest place. It was interesting to see how "Sledgehammer" seemed to evoke that kind of sound as it was stripped down.

I also found it interesting to think about the background that Ethan provided as to who was doing what in the recording. I felt I could hear more of what each track was contributing with Ethan's insights in mind. Based on that, I was making mixing decisions to bring out particular contributions.

The way you stripped it down is less radical than Participant 288's version because you kept the drums, but you both achieve a groovy finale. I’m very impressed with the soundscape you managed to craft, it feels like there’s years of experience behind it.
Have you found a DAW that helps you get close to that studio sound or are you mixing out of the box? Have you tried console emulations like SSL Soundscape or Harrison Mixbus?

Image omitted from this public editionParticipant 366 said:

My creative mix below...pulled out the guitar and piano completely...still felt well balanced but less dense...I've attached my mixer settings as well...vocal dead center...backing vocals at 3 & 9 o'clock respectively...the same with the prophet and horns...drums and bass, as always, dead center...

Well done, another successful stripped-down version. Yours is less a departure from the original and retains more power, which isn’t surprising given your musical taste. I like how the Prophet and the horns respond clearly to each other. It certainly helped that you decided to have a less busy mix, but at the same time, it’s hard to forget how fantastic the 3:12 Break can be with the piano and guitars. Maybe you could have the best of both worlds by automating their volume when doing the FX mix inside Soundation.

Thanx. I'll check that out at some point. I was just making the point that those studios may consist mostly of vocal booths; because, the humidity and amount of constant flows of water around, are major contributing factors to the classic records that came out of these locations and this jelled for me when I working in the desert. And, hey, that would effect the sound of those guitars, too, back then. I just took the edX course on vocal recording technology. I have to take it again though, I couldn't follow all the pro tools demos that well visually. But, I do understand microphones well:)

Have you tried modding your microphones so that they suit your voice even more? If you only have a few minutes available, please try watching this hangout starting from around 1:46:00: [external link withheld] [link withheld]

Looking forward to reading what you think of it, because I’ve been wondering why most singers don’t carry their own modded mics around.
Maybe it’s not the appropriate thread though. We could use Participant 257’s DIY group instead: [external link withheld]

Image omitted from this public editionParticipant 584 said:

I’ve been wondering why most singers don’t carry their own modded mics around.

The question of singers carrying their own mics is interesting. The microphone clearly is a major component in how a singer will sound when recorded. Instrumentalists who use amplification are usually pretty picky about the amps and speakers they use with their instruments. Harmonica players generally carry a microphone that they like to use with their harmonicas. Seems like singers are missing the boat on exercising greater control of the sound they put down in a recording. That seems especially odd given that their sound is arguably the most important of the entire recording.

Image omitted from this public editionParticipant 501 said:

I was just making the point that those studios may consist mostly of vocal booths; because, the humidity and amount of constant flows of water around, are major contributing factors to the classic records that came out of these locations and this jelled for me when I working in the desert. And, hey, that would effect the sound of those guitars, too, back then.

The effect of humidity is an interesting observation that I don't think I have heard being brought up before. It certainly can be a significant factor.

I do some work maintaining pipe organs, which are incredibly fickle instruments. I'm in Southern California and when we are having dry weather we know the pipe organs will act up. If there is a concert under such conditions we often flood the blower room with water to raise the humidity of the air being blown through the organ. I've heard of people pouring water directly into the air intake of the blower but I'm not that brave or desperate.

Image omitted from this public editionParticipant 584 said:

The way you stripped it down is less radical than Participant 288's version because you kept the drums, but you both achieve a groovy finale. I’m very impressed with the soundscape you managed to craft, it feels like there’s years of experience behind it.Have you found a DAW that helps you get close to that studio sound or are you mixing out of the box? Have you tried console emulations like SSL Soundscape or Harrison Mixbus?

Thanks for the kind words. This is my first experience with mixing. I haven't used any other DAWs. I think my good results are mostly the result of having Peter Gabriel's good source material to work with.

Since I've had that revelation regarding humidity and fresh water sources and vocals I have learned that many legit singers live in Dallas for the same reason (and the big airport, I imagine). When I was working all the time in Vegas I would buy vaporizers by the 1/2 dozen on sale.'cause I burned them up all the time. I put sea salt by the tablespoon to make more steam but then decided later the salt was bad. Maybe swamp coolers for the pipe organ? My storage space has those they work well in dry, low humidity; but, I'm still keeping my fingers crossed for my Martin and my albums:) Also, the Shoals, Memphis and Chi aren't very high up in the air, like, who records in Colorado except John Denver.

What is modding? Modifying? I mostly carry Schure SM58's cause I work live. On a good day, I don't need much else. I used to throw an extra in my carry on; but, I can hardly get my make-up bag thru the airport now. I quit doing that and now I don't carry any electronics. Just hope what's on the truck is still there and in working order. OMGosh. For home, I'm looking a stereo pair of Neumann 184's or 185's, followed, by the U87, later. I'm a singer's singer, not a tech, I don't kid myself, I know what I do, so, the mic's will be my big purchase. What mic's do you use? I'll watch the vid, too, promise, and get back to you:)

I watched part of Khaliq's thing. I got hung up in the cloud one. Here's the link for the one mentioned: [external link withheld] [link withheld]
I have like 6 clouds all ready. Those stocks are all ready so sky high who knows what is going to happen with that; but, it's a cheap way to get straight to streaming then you can just print 2000 business cards with the video download on it for $25.00.

Glad you found something useful for your current needs. If you aren't much into tech, there are other options than modifying the mics yourself: you could just check Bradford Swanson's database [link withheld] to narrow your choice, then ask someone like Langston Masingale [link withheld] to help you reach the best solution for your voice. Like Jim said, it's an opportunity for singers to contribute more and improve the quality of indie productions, live or recorded.

[participant mention]: sorry for the great big digression Image omitted from this public edition

Image omitted from this public editionParticipant 331 said:

This is my first experience with mixing. I haven't used any other DAWs. I think my good results are mostly the result of having Peter Gabriel's good source material to work with.

Sorry to hurt your modesty, but that's even more impressive. Yes, you were lucky to work with all the effects already applied on the tracks and probably Csound as an audio engine, but not everybody comes up with this as his first mix...

here is my attempt to recreate, or may be a little bit to improvise on Sledgehammer.
I leveled up all stems, listened to original mix, and tried to adjust sound for each instrument and vocals while listening to original in different tab.
[external link withheld] [link withheld]
Your comments are greatly appreciated.

Image omitted from this public edition
Pasted image1069x622 172 KB
[link withheld]

It is interesting to notice that there is no even 2 identical interpretations so far. People are very creative!

Here's my reverse engineered mix of Sledgehammer:
[external link withheld] [link withheld]

Image omitted from this public edition
sledge_orig.png1153x449 140 KB
[link withheld]

I think it is pretty close to the reference mix which is published in the mixing tool, however still pretty far from the album version.

Here's my creative mix:
[external link withheld] [link withheld]

Image omitted from this public edition
sledge_creative.png1155x454 142 KB
[link withheld]

What I did is basically rising up the volume of guitar and piano. I have completly cut out Shak and left only minimal volume of Prophet. I have also added more importance to the female background voices.

Reverse Engineering - In Your Eyes
[external link withheld] [link withheld]

Image omitted from this public edition
In Your Eyes.Convergent.png1280x704 188 KB
[link withheld]

The process - Listened to the given tracks while sketching a perceived space graph on paper. Next, I chose to work with the percussion first because the triangle really stood out as left and forward. I moved drums and bass in relation to percussion based on how they were placed on the space graph. Then, I work with the lead vocal by listening to the given track, then muting the the given and soloing the lead vocal. Next, I work on the piano and pads by panning them in relation to the original graph sketch. I mute and solo back and forth between the given track and the track to reverse engineer until they seem to match. I do the same procedure for the guitar and backing vocals. Finally, I mute and solo back and forth between my reverse engineered tracks and the given tracks to listen for a match. I moved some volume and pan on some of the tracks to tweak.

Creative Mix - I found the triangle to be too strong in the given version, so I wanted to softened it up. I wanted the voice and piano to sit near each other in space and the guitar and pads to play with each other on opposite sides.

[external link withheld] [link withheld]

Image omitted from this public edition
Screen Shot 2014-08-12 at 9.12.17 AM.png1202x609 147 KB
[link withheld]

This is my recreation of sledgehammer:

[external link withheld] [link withheld] (edit: I think my settings were not saved. Please check the screenshot)

Image omitted from this public edition
Auswahl_005.png1260x617 127 KB
[link withheld]

I created it by soloing the reference tracks and individual instruments in turns and comparing levels and panning.
First, I had to reduce the levels of the reference track because I found it easier to compare the individual channels that way (so I had more room at the top), so my levels are a bit lower than yours.

Then I in turn adjusted the levels for Shak, Drums, Bass etc. and at the end the panning. The easiest way for me was to mute all the idividual channels, leave the reference track running and then quickly soloing / unsoloing individual instruments at characteristic points.
My result is fairly similar to the ones already posted. In my opinion, PG voice does actually have the highest levels, the BG voices are actually set higher (but PG voice is still louder).

What I could not exactly set is the panning for the individual tracks, it's very difficult to hear differences between different settings when the instruments are already far to the left or right.

Here is my creative mix:

Image omitted from this public edition
Auswahl_006.png1249x632 123 KB
[link withheld]

I increased the loudness of Guitar, Piano, Prophet and Horns in relation to the other sounds, I really like their sounds. I also changed some of the pannings. I think the drums and bass are too loud in the reference mix.

When is module 5 coming?????

Task 1:
The first thing I did when creating my mix was to isolate the Shak because that has a solo in the beginning and I found it easy to place the fader. After that, I worked on each component as it came into the piece, often referencing the original musical structure graph to help listen for the next part. I found it easy to place the strongest components of the piece, for example the lead vocals, Shak, and horns. I did find it challenging to place the beat holders, like the bass and drums, as they were in the ‘back’ of the sound. It was also difficult to find the accurate placement of the fade as the song became more and more layered with timbres.
First off, I learned how hard it can be to reengineer a piece of music. But, I truly learned how to train my ears to listen for each part of the music and how it comes into the ears. This exercise was much different from the perceived space graph and the musical structure graph. Although those projects helped me hear when a song part was or came in, this project made me create what I heard. This made my analyzation of songs more fine-tuned. I do believe I came very close to the reference mix. But, I don’t have the very best headphones so some of my placement in left versus right may be off.
[external link withheld] [link withheld]

Image omitted from this public edition.
Sledgehammer reverse engineer.jpg1366x768 139 KB
[link withheld]

Task 2:
Before beginning my mix, I listened to the original piece and detected my favorite parts and gave them more emphasis. As a fan of rock music, I wanted to emphasis the vocals, guitar, and bass as an attempt to change the genre to a more rock sound. While increasing the fade of the guitar, I reduced the horn portion. Another dynamic I changed was the prophet versus the horns. By increasing the synthesized sound of the prophet and reducing the horns, the sound become more modern.
A challenge I faced was how to change the sound of a song I had already heard. When I listen to a song, I never think about the components I would have liked to hear more or less of to match my musical taste, instead I would just decide if I liked the song or not. So to change the song entirely to tailor it to my ear was difficult at first. In addition, I found it hard to figure out what parts of the song changed the ‘vibe’ or genre sound. I learned that by turning up the guitar and vocals, the song became something that I would choose to listen to. Ultimately, I learned which parts of songs appeal to me, which now makes sense why I favor certain genres over others.
[external link withheld] [link withheld]

Image omitted from this public edition.
Sledgehammer remix.jpg1366x768 135 KB
[link withheld]

[external link withheld] [link withheld]

Preserved course illustration or music-analysis diagram
Screen Shot 2016-06-29 at 12.30.43 PM.png2434x1102 333 KB
[link withheld]

Task 1: So when I did this project my tactic was to mute one side of the standard mix and have that playing and to shift all the singular instruments to the other side. I would then go through one by one and try and get it so that the instruments sounded balanced in my headphones. This worked well for me except with piano and prophet as they were only heard in the left ear in the original mix so I had to kind of guess where to set them. Overall this was pretty fun and it forced me to really pay attention to the song and listen critically.

Task 2: [external link withheld] [link withheld]
For my creative mix I decided to emphasize the sounds that I think define the song: The lead vocals, drums and bass. I took the horns out as I think they are a little irritating and brought the guitar down as I like it more as a background noise and replaced it with the piano and prophet as I think they both provide a really cool sound with the song. the only things I didn't change was the shak and background vocals.

Preserved course illustration or music-analysis diagram
Screen Shot 2016-06-29 at 12.49.46 PM.png2512x1036 323 KB
[link withheld]