COMMUNITY ARCHIVE Selected reading edition · 2014–2020
Play With Your MusicCommunity archive
← Musical Structure

Musical Structure

3a - Project: Listening for Musical Structures

8 readable posts · Team contributions are labelled separately from community replies.

Overview

In this module, you'll be introduced to techniques for how to listen for musical structure over time in a recording. We'll build on the perceived space graph from Module 2, where you identified sound sources and placed them in perceived space, by having you listen for the big picture musical structure (song sections and form), the musical texture (when sounds enter and leave the mix/arrangement and the arrangement's musical density). We'll also lead you through counting bars and beats, determining meter and tempo, and place chord changes if you so desire.

We've divided this module into 4 sections:

This module ends with you creating a PWYM Musical Structure Graph [link withheld] for a musical recording you love. We encourage you to find other PWYM participants (your crew!) to share your graph, and to give feedback to others on their graphs.

Project 1: Learning to Listen for Musical Structure

We've invited our colleague Ethan Hein [link withheld] to share with you a process of listening for musical structures within music recordings. For this video, Ethan will walk you through our approach to listening critically within Peter Gabriel [link withheld]’s song Sledgehammer [link withheld].

Getting Started

LISTENING FOR MUSICAL STRUCTURE

Preserved course illustration or music-analysis diagram

A musical structure graph is a diagram showing the different sections of the song and where its component sounds enter and exit. To create a graph, you'll need to listen through your song closely, probably many times. This kind of critical listening is 90% of the day-to-day work of a music producer or audio engineer. Through isolating and describing timbres and positioning them in perceived space, you’ll better be able to work with these concepts in your own tracks.

  • Open up this recording of Sledgehammer in YouTube [link withheld] and a copy of Ethan's Musical Structure Graph [link withheld].
  • Listen through Sledgehammer while viewing Ethan's musical structure graph.
  • Read through Ethan's blog post analyzing and discussing the structure of Sledgehammer [link withheld].
  • Watch the following video of Ethan walking you through the process of creating a musical structure graph:

Embedded media omitted from this public edition

The timestamps in the Sledgehammer structure graph refer to the HD version of the song on YouTube [link withheld], which begins with fourteen seconds of silence. The album version (the one you get from iTunes or from your own CD) skips the silence. If you want to refer to the album version, subtract fourteen seconds from each timestamp. The measures are shown in cut time, so each measure has a snare hit on beat three. You might also logically count through the song half as fast, so each measure has snare hits on beats two and four. If that’s how you prefer to count, just divide each section length by two.

Going Deeper: Songwriting and Musical Content

Embedded media omitted from this public edition

To really dive deep into the musical content of the song, you might find it helpful to create a chord chart or lead sheet of your song. This is an especially valuable exercise for songwriters. Here is a chord chart [link withheld] we created for "Sledgehammer" as a guide.

Sledgehammer DNA - Early Demos

Take a listen into the early demos, scratch tracks, and mixes:

Embedded media omitted from this public edition

You can really hear how the lyrics are often the last part of the tune to be solidified by Peter. They are often in flux even through the final mixes. The beginning starts out with Peter at a piano with a Linn Drum beat pattern in the background. This was the "click track" that persisted through the live tracking of the parts for Sledgehammer. According to Kevin Killen, the Linn Drum was always in the headphones and on one track of the monitor mix most of the time.

Now that you've explored some techniques for analyzing musical structures, check out our archived interview with songwriter Phil Galdston.

I don't know if it's just me but I can't hear any of the sections of sledgehammer being used in the "creating a musical structure graph" which is making it rather hard to follow what's happening :/ Any chance of a copy with the sections under discussion actually audible?

Thanks for the feedback. We're always working on improving our video production process. Stay tuned.

Very subtle yet unique chord changes to this rather simple song…no hint of early Genesis at all.

[participant mention] [link withheld] I just added a YouTube link to some of the early demos/"DNA" for Sledgehammer above in the post. The roots really seem to be in Blues/Funk.

Embedded media omitted from this public edition

I love how Gabriel is just improvising vocally and lyrically. Nice compilation. I'm curious to read the lyrics he didn't use.

Hello, I apologize if this is incorrect, but in the Musical Structure Graph provided for Sledgehammer the Horns seem to be missing from the Chorus 1 section. I'm by no means a musical savant, so perhaps that's just the synth playing tricks on me.

Hey,

Please create all links used in the articles as target=blank, so that all the links are opened in new tabs. That would be a huge improvement for me Image omitted from this public edition

All the best!