COMMUNITY ARCHIVE Selected reading edition · 2014–2020
Play With Your MusicCommunity archive
← Getting Started

Getting Started

1c - Live Interview, Q&A - Kevin Killen & Jerry Marotta

51 readable posts · 1 retained privacy notices · Team contributions are labelled separately from community replies.

May 20th - 2:30pm-4:30pm EDT (New York City time)

Kevin Killen & Jerry Marotta

Ask Kevin & Jerry

What questions do you want us to ask Kevin and Jerry? Please share them as replies to this topic. We'll go through them and select as many as we can to post to them during our live interview session May 20th.

Preparing for the Interviews

Refamiliarize yourself and play with Sledgehammer and In Your Eyes.

Read Kevin's multiple accounts of recording So here, here and here. Listen to a great set of interviews from the Input Output podcast [link withheld] on Soundcloud here.

Watch the Live Interview
*HD video with HQ audio will be posted very soon.
Please pardon the intermediate low-fi live stream below*.

Embedded media omitted from this public edition

You can read an edited transcript here: [external link withheld] [link withheld]

Kevin Killen [link withheld]
Image omitted from this public edition. is a music producer, engineer, and mixer. His work has been recognized by multiple awards and nominations, and he has worked with a range of recording artists including Shakira, Peter Gabriel, U2, Elvis Costello, Kate Bush, Jewel, Bon Jovi and Shawn Colvin. Kevin will share experiences as the audio engineer behind Peter Gabriel's legendary So album, taking us behind the scenes to the recording processes of hit songs Sledgehammer and In Your Eyes.



Jerry Marotta [link withheld]
Image omitted from this public edition. is a world class drummer and producer who has worked with Peter Gabriel, Paul McCartney, Sarah McLachlan, and countless others. Hes also recently taken over a phenomenal recording facility called DREAMLAND and is touring the Security Project [link withheld] playing the music of Peter Gabriel live. Jerry collaborated with Peter between 1977 and 1986 and will provide insights into his experiences performing, recording and collaborating with Peter.

Shared by Kevin Killen via email on May 12, 2014

Clearly Peter and Participant 196 [link withheld] wanted to make the best record they could at that moment with the hope that it would have a broad appeal while staying true to their musical beliefs.

Image omitted from this public edition. I joined the album two months into the process. Dave Bascombe [link withheld] had done the initial tracking with the band. Peter had his original demos of the songs which consisted of a Linn 9000 [link withheld] drum pattern and a Prophet 5 [link withheld] or Yamaha CP70 [link withheld] chord progression. Peter and Participant 196 began to discuss possible arrangement and structural ideas prior to the musicians arriving. Once the players were present for tracking they all discussed other possible changes. Every idea was encouraged as both Participant 196 and Peter were truly interested in delving into any tangent that may create a unique musical arrangement. The vibe was truly collaborative but with Participant 196 and Peter guiding the process.

Peter had his own studio located 7 miles outside of Bath, England [link withheld]. It was a residential setting utilizing an old converted farmhouse for living / accommodation / office space. The studio was located in an rectangular cow shed which had some acoustic treatment. The control room overlooked the valley , the recording space was behind the control room, separated by a vestibule that doubled as a technical shop. There were no direct sight lines between the two rooms. The control was equipped with an SSL 4000 E series [link withheld] board - 56 input and the tape machines were two Studer A80 [link withheld]'s. One of them was a standard issue , while the second had the standard chassis, transport and deck but all of the audio cards were customized by a local engineer, Colin Broad [link withheld]. There was a reasonable amount of outboard processing equipment in the control room including AMS, Quantec, Delta Labs, MXR, LA2A & Decca compressors, an EMT Plate ,1/4 inch and 1/2 tape machines. We also had a PA Participant 001 in the recording space that we used as an echo chamber. Peter had an assortment of keyboards in the control room: Prophet 5, Yamaha CP70, Emulator [link withheld] and a Fairlight [link withheld]. There were also a number of guitars and percussion instruments readily available.

Peter wanted to utilize both tape machines during the tracking phase, the A machine being the stock Studer, the B machine being the modified version so an Adam Smith synchronizer was installed days before the tracking began. As Participant 196 later recalled in conversations the demo's were played back on the B machine while the band recorded their parts to the A machine. A rough mix of the demo parts was recorded simultaneously to the A machine to allow for quick reference on playback. As each reel of tape was completed it was swapped over onto the B machine while a virgin reel was placed on the A machine. This allowed everybody to quickly check prior performances , parts and sounds. This process might be repeated 5 or six times depending on the number of passes required before a master backing track was selected. A similar process was followed for each song.

Because Participant 196 and Peter were keen to keep the momentum going during the tracking , rarely was reel 1 of a song synchronized with reel 6 or seven , the assumption being that all reels were compliant. Sometime after tracking Participant 196, David and Peter discovered that this was not the case and that a technical issue was clearly evident. Dave Bascombe [link withheld] was leaving the project to work with "Tears for Fears" and Participant 196 reached out and invited me to engineer the remainder of the project. I travelled from NYC to England on the assumption that I was going to help complete the project - a 4 to 6 week commitment. Because it was late Spring I packed only summer clothes . I was met at Heathrow Airport by Peter's assistant, David Stallbaumer [link withheld] and during our drive to the studio he speculated that I would be on this project for the next 10 months!

Immediately I observed a great rapport between Peter and Participant 196, both have a wicked sense of humor and a great understanding of groove and melody. Participant 196 and i had worked the previous year on U2's "Unforgettable Fire" album so it was no surprise to see instruments and effects ready to go should a musical idea present itself. Participant 196 is meticulous in documenting sounds and setups and I quickly familiarized myself with the whole arrangement. There were also construction hard hats , free weights, a Polaroid camera and the French game "Boules" to alleviate tension!

As I settled into the project, Participant 196 outlined my role. During the day we would be recording new parts and performances on the existing backing tracks. During the after hours I would be responsible for devising and executing a Participant 001 to retrieve parts and performances from slave reels that no loner synchronized with the master reels. Keeping the project on track while maintaining a creative vibe was essential, therefore a communal spirit was omnipresent. To address the synchronizer issue, we had to understand what had occurred during the tracking.

There were two separate but concurrent technical issues that threatened to derail some of the performances. The first revolved around the Adam Smith synchronizer that linked the two machines. The stock Studer had an FM card and the modified Studer had a DC card - the synchronizer setup assumed they were both FM cards, so there were incorrect pulses being sent from the Adam Smith to the second machine. The second involved the tension of the reels on both Studer's. Because the tension required the utilization of capstan & pinch roller Participant 001 , the tension on the first and last three minutes of each reel of tape was not entirely Participant 374. The two issues compounded to make the master and slave reels drift away from each other and it was an inconsistent amount from slave reel to slave reel. We had all of these wonderful performances spread out over the various takes and therefore we created a list of parts & performances that we wanted to corral back to the master. The process of getting stuff back from the slave reels to the master reel involved lining up the 2-inches or the half inch machine and flying between them manually, bit by bit. In July we got an AMS sampler with 14 seconds of sampling capability, so we could actually sample four or five measures of music and fly it in that way. This is what we used to "loop" in Stewart Copeland [link withheld]'s drum performance on "Big Time".

In the meantime we were still recording on the master takes and I created a new slave reel to ensure open tracks and sync. Musically all of the songs were incomplete and the arrangements were longer than what appeared on the final release. Because Peter likes to write lyrics over an extended period of time , it was not unusually to try a lot of new parts only to have them discarded as lyrics coalesced. During this time David Rhodes [link withheld], Tony Levin [link withheld] and Manu Katche [link withheld] all returned to replace or add new parts to the existing versions. By the time August rolled around it was abundantly clear that this project was going to take more than 6 weeks! Some of the songs really began to take shape , "Sledgehammer " "Red Rain", " Don't Give Up" while "Big Time ", "Sixty One ( in Your Eyes)" and "Hear That Voice Again" provided daily challenges. There was also a song titled "Courage [link withheld]" which had a great melody and groove but Peter could never find a lyric that he was satisfied with , so ultimately it never saw the light of day.

At the same time we were experimenting with the arrangements by editing new structures together on half inch. Various iterations were adopted and discarded until there was a consensus . We knew that eventually we would have to edit the multi-tracks , but cutting into the timecode stripe on track 24 would render the master and slave reels associated with the song "un-syncable". Mike Large (Peter's right hand person at Real World ) worked for SSL at that time and would come down to do maintenance. He is super smart and funny and it was always a treat to have him in the studio. He loves a challenge and once we explained our "sync" issues he took it upon himself to research the Adam Smith manual. He discovered that there was an option , buried deep in the preferences that allowed the synchronizer to essentially soft lock over a multi- track edit , without the slave machine stopping , fast forwarding and rewinding until it recognized the next whole timecode frame to sync to. While this preference allowed the machines to stay synced, in truth there was a slight deviation between the two machines. Unless you had something that was rhythmically based coming off the slave machine , one could utilize this to execute the necessary edits without any obvious musical hiccups !

I wanted to jettison the whole idea of a synchronizer and I lobbied hard for adopting the Mitsubishi X850 [link withheld] - a 32 track digital machine I had used in NYC. In my mind it would preserve the analog quality of the original recordings , which in some instances was diminishing due to the excessive number of times the tapes were being played over the heads and provide us with a reliable format. With the current setup , one had 22 tracks per analog reel, track 24 was exclusively assigned for the time code track while track 23 was left intentionally blank to avoid any crosstalk between it and track 24. Peter and Participant 196 were leaving for New York in early September to record horns, piano and some keyboards at the Power Station [link withheld]. My task prior to their trip was to create new digital masters of all of the songs.

Image omitted from this public edition.To do that meant committing to the agreed multitrack edits on each master and associated slave reels. Utilizing the sync preference that Mike had discovered i set about the task. In some instances it required two to four edits on the master which had to be identically reproduced on each slave reel per song. Once completed I locked the master and the 32 track machine and transferred to the Mitsubishi. I would repeat the same procedure for each slave reel. Then I made new slave reels for Peter and Participant 196 to record to in New York. When they returned from NY , the new and brilliant parts were transferred to the 32 track. Ironically there were certain percussion elements that Peter preferred from the analog reels so we still needed to sync , but at least we had a more reliable Participant 001 in place .

As we moved into the final portion of the record Peter settled on the majority of the lyrics . Two of the songs underwent significant changes , "in Your Eyes" and "Mercy Street". Peter explored a new atmospheric and sparser approach to the verses of "in Your Eyes" allowing the pre-chorus and chorus more drama. The working title for "Mercy Street" was "Forro" - a Brazilian title - (translation - For All ). I was executing a task on the 32 track that required the vari-speed to be enabled , the result being that the machine was running 10% below nominal pitch. The next song on the reel was "Forro" and as it started all three of us instantly recognized the unusual timbre of the percussion instruments, particularly the triangles. It immediately inspired a fruitful exploration of the track over the next couple of hours and this became the new master version of the song!

Image omitted from this public edition.

By October we were ready to invite Virgin and Geffen Records for a preview of the album. We also welcomed Dave Bottrill [link withheld] to the team. David worked for Participant 196 at his Grant Avenue studio in Hamilton, Ontario. Dave was a vital participant from this point forward, his endless work ethic and musicality were a real boost at this stage. We were still some months away from completion but we had amassed some excellent rough mixes for the playback. Their reaction was so positive that we based all future work on those rough mixes. This was facilitated by the recall feature on the SSL and our extensive notes. From that point forward we never worked on a part without recalling that preferred balance! Kate Bush [link withheld] came a number of occasions to record her spine chilling performance on "Don't Give Up" . We tended to record all of the vocal parts in the control room , sometimes using a combination of headphones and speakers. it was a more intimate and supportive atmosphere for the performer and that usually translated onto the tape. The same was true for guitar, bass and keyboards.

When we got to the mixing stage of the album , there were still minor overdubs to add and further edits to try. Participant 196 had the genius idea to start "Hear That Voice Again" with the chorus and that in turn inspired a slightly different approach to mix. This arrangement was completed by editing the half inch master, so if we decided to do a recall of the mix, then all of the edits had to be executed again! Most of the mixing was completed in February 1986 and then we sequenced and mastered the album with Ian Cooper [link withheld] at The Townhouse Studios [link withheld] in London. I returned to Bath to complete some B-sides for singles and experiment with some 12' inch remixes for extended plays . I finally left Bath in early March, almost 10 months to the day of my arrival!

Personally it was a life changing experience. Participant 196 was gracious to invite me into the project and the challenges it presented allowed me to grow exponentially as a person and engineer. Peter was incredibly generous both as a person and performer and he made me feel welcome from the the first day. We were a competitive group which manifested itself in our daily games of Boules and runs to Solisbury Hill with David Rhodes, PG and myself. There was exceptional humor, compassion and enough creative tension to help maximize our contributions. I cannot imagine my life or career without that experience and the friendships that ensued.

Is giving me an unexpected error to connect

Here are my questions:

  1. How do you approach structurally a new project? In other words do you have a process you'd suggest to help beginners better approach their music?
  2. How new technologies impacted your work?

Still giving me an error unexpected message. Havent been able to connect to google hangouts Image omitted from this public edition

I have some questions:
1) Do you record voice track in a "vocal booth" with sound absorption treatment (without reverberation) or in a room with a great sound?
2) Can I mix a song very well only with a good headphone (in the absence of quality control room).
3) What technical operations are done to get a great "master" from a recording.
4) How to record a bass guitar? Can I get a great sound by connecting it directly to the mixer? Or the best is with loudspeakers?
5) How to get a great drum sound? (the sound of the drums in particular snare drum characterizes the age of a recording)
6) How important is the personality of an sound engineer than the Producer?
7) Do you record flat instruments and then add effects during mixing or record with some bass cutoff or compression and/or equalization or other effects?
8) a song with voice track must sound very good also without voice track ? or we must create some space for the voice with equalization or other effects?
9) in SO album, how did you record Peter Gabriel voice? Microphone, Compression, equalization, reverberation, room acoustics, other effects...

Thank you!

One question, would love to get a different answer from both interviewees:

I'm sure you've heard someone say "I wish someone had told me about [fill in the blank] before I started this."

What's your "one thing" you wish someone had told you before you started producing?

Tony Levine uses some of the most unique playing techniques of any bassist in history. I have heard from other producers that he is a joy to record and almost always plays the perfect part, but what (if any) adjustments or special treatments have you utilized for recording and mixing techniques such as his "funk fingers" (mallets he tapes to the end of his fingers) Thanks!

This is always such a loaded question on the forums I participate in, but I would like to hear your take. Mix bus compression, yes, no, maybe, depends? Thanks!

Hello, here's my question:

How much time would you estimate might have been saved during the recording of "So" if a modern type DAW was available? Not necessarily to record, but to edit and/or sync the out of sync tracks recorded on tape.

Thanks

hello i wanted to ask about the combination of headphones and speakers during kate bush -dont give up-...can you explain with more detail that process please , it coul be of great help when recording voices...thanks

Hello there!

My question is specific about the drums recording. I recently watched a documentary that said many drum takes were produced for each song and the final versions came from a collage of those takes. We know this has been a common procedure - specially in the digital times of Pro-Tools - but apparently in some songs of SO (Red Rain maybe?) that was taken to an extreme: each measure came from different performances.

Did that really happen? And if it did, how was the process to choose what to use, since there was no easy way to test combinations?

Thanks you for your time and everyone who help put this course together.

If you had to do it all over again starting today where would you begin?

I have a couple general questions, then if I'm feeling froggy, I might come up with a couple more for Kevin and Jerry individually.
-Did Peter and Participant 196 come into the studio with basic ideas already lined out, or did thy plan for "So" to be more of a spontaneous creation within the confines of the studio?
-Typically, what comes first - the arrangement or the music? Is there a part of the creative process where someone says "Okay, I want a Native American flute intro, then an ensemble of trumpet, trombone, organ, guitar, bass and drums", like in Sledgehammer (from what I can discern), or is it more of an organic "This needs something, let's find out what it is" process?

Kevin - Do you view your role more heavily in pre-production, production, or post-production? Is there any area you would typically like to be more or less involved in? Also, what is the craziest technique you had to employ on "So" to capture a specific sound?

Jerry - I just looked on the Wikipedia page for "So", and it says Tony played the fretted parts for the funk finger bass line on Big Time, and you played the drumming parts for the funk finger bass? Huh? Could you explain what went on there? It sounds like an awkward bro hug to me, and I'm sure that's not the case.

Looking forward to hearing from you guys!

Hi there,

I have a question. I'm an absolute beginner, and this all sounds very technical and overwhelming. It seems like a super deep pool I'm about to drown in Image omitted from this public edition

What's your best advice for a beginner so that they don't get overwhelmed and lost in learning about this subject?

Many thanks, been a huge fan of Peter Gabriel. Biko is one of my favorite songs.

Please share some of your experience on drum micing, drum recording, and drum mixing, when it comes to achieving a specific drum sound.

Also what are your thoughts on live recording a band opposed to tracking each instrument?

Thanks for your post. Don't worry if you are a complete beginner! We've designed the course so that you will have a pathway through. Our advice is to take your time and find a group of beginners to take the course with. You can find your crew over in the Meet category..

And, remember this is a community. Ask lots of questions. Someone else has the same question and another has an answer for you. No question is too simple. Image omitted from this public edition

Hi, my biggest question (and this goes out to everybody contributing here) would be;

How do you guys see the future of recorded music, specifically with regard to the promotion and publication of songs.
It seems, as with book publishing, the power has shifted more to the individual with tools that were previously only available to the professionals becoming cheaper and more easily available. However, do you think this just creates a sea of mediocrity, and if so, how do you think the gems can be made to stand out?

1) I've always found it interesting how session players feel drawn to the work of particular singers/composers/bands. The example that most comes to mind is of Steely Participant 196, who it seems had session players queuing up to get on their records. Their album Gaucho was arguably not their greatest record (though I think it ranks well against their other stuff), but on that one record you have Steve Gadd, the late Jeff Porcaro, Bernard Purdie, and Jerry's brother Participant 087. And that's just the drummers!

With that it mind, given Jerry has played a stack of PG's stuff, and is playing with the Security Project, I wanted to ask him: What is it that has drawn you to Peter and his corpus of work, primarily from a drummer's perspective, but also if applicable, more generally?

2) Another question for Jerry, assuming no one else asks it. - Let's talk Big Time. How did you come up with the idea of whacking a bass guitar with drum Participant 318 (which I believe Tony went on and used in his funk fingers stuff), was it you, was it in tandem with PG, Tony, and/or others, when in the process did that become an ingredient in the song, and what was the process like of incorporating that into the rehearsal/composition/recording of that track?

3) One more question Image omitted from this public edition for Jerry, if possible - I understand the drum part for Red Rain was split between you and Stewart Copeland, with him handling the hi hat rhythm (after a hi hat hiatus over Melt/Peter Gabriel III) and you playing the rest. How does that work, splitting the drum parts, and does it mess with a drummer not being able to make use of the full kit when recording? It would be cool if, as part of that, you could expand a little more on the sonic philosophy of 'no hi-hats' that started with Melt, and what you thought of that as a musical concept (I guess as a prelude to PG's more extensive use of worldbeat).

I don't know if Kevin was involved at all with Melt (or Security, for that matter), but as I understand it there was some convincing required by Participant 283 and others to get PG to put hi-hats back on Red Rain after Security, so any insight Kevin can lend here would also be welcome.

4) Also, as I have very little experience working with trained, vocational producers, a question for Kevin - what do you see as the limits of your role? How much do you influence the composition of a song (i.ee the final 'version' of the song), will you experiment with and chop and change parts that you think sound good that aren't in the artist's immediate 'vision', and does that balance shift depending on who you are working with?

Thank you all. I will feel lucky to hear of even one of these being answered, though all would be great! I won't be able to make the live broadcast, unfortunately (the time works out to 4:30am my local time, so yeah Image omitted from this public edition)

1986 was a period of time where digital recording was possible. Dire Straits "Brother in Arms" is an example from that time period. What were the considerations (artistic, financial, creative or otherwise) that kept this project in the analog world? If you had the chance to do it over, what, if anything would you do differently?

I would love to hear how the various arrangement choices were tracked.

Meaning, from the start how were the decisions made to track something as a background layer, versus a present layer, and how did that affect the method of tracking, be it choice of actual instrument (particular models), amp, room, mic choice and placement, preamps, processing...

It feels like these choices were made very early on and committed.

My biggest question concerns stereo separation for each part of the song. What is the best way to separate and pan different instruments to maintain a balanced track? Are there certain guidelines to follow (e.g. sub bass centered, higher frequencies more spread)?
My next question is about the final stages of writing a song. As I'm mixing, I usually find that my snare drum loses its punchiness, even when I do my best to mix the rest of the track down. I've tried layering different sounds (snare with heavy mid range, claps with heavy high range, and even a small white noise channel), boosting frequencies with EQ, and sidechaining surrounding instruments, but it still doesn't help my snare pop. What could be done to help solve this?

I'm interested in anecdotes about the unfolding of In Your Eyes... lyrics / concept first, melody with a few chords, or more of the atmospherics first, driving other elements? I.e., what was the creative path and contributors to the final product that we all hear?

Hello Kevin, I enjoyed your detailed account of your time working with PG on the "So" album. This mirrors your meticulous, rigorous approach which clearly yields excellent results. I would like to request your viewpoints about some aspects about the modern recording process.

  1. Kudos for your painstaking efforts in the resolution of tape sync issues. If you were faced with similar problems today, do you think that the time stretching and compression algorithms available in modern-day DAWs would make your task a lot easier ?

  2. I found your explanations of take management very informative. In the context of present DAWs what features would you look for to facilitate this workflow ?

  3. When experimenting with alternative arrangements, surely MIDI tracking (and the options that come with it) would be a boon ?

  4. There is a continuous debate as to whether analog tape or hard disk recording is better. Do you see the advances of higher sampling rates and DAW sophistication superseding the analog recording paradigm ?

Post #26 is omitted from the public reading edition to protect personal information.

Embedded media omitted from this public edition

[external link withheld] [link withheld]

Kevin replying to a thread on Gearslutz: [external link withheld] [link withheld]

Great observations everyone, I will attempt to answer all in this entry.

Yes the album has a brightness to it, but i tend to think of it as a "sheen ". Because it was tracked mostly through a SSL E series , with the exception of the Power Station sessions which were through a Neve, it was easy to accumulate a bite to any sound. Peter and Participant 196 wanted the record to sound soulfull but joyous at the same time and we all tried to avoid over processing a particular sound. Whatever eq curve was employed during recording was not copied for the mix.

The basic tracks were laid to two Studer A80's ( one was heavily modified by a local boffin, Colin Broad). We tried to create character sounds during that portion ( some drum verbs were printed etc etc). During overdubs, Peter , Participant 196 and David Rhodes would often combine three instruments into one part. We had our effects constantly ready to print to tape and it was not uncommon to recirculate one effect into another almost to the point of uncontrollable feedback.

We also employed a lot or reamping, either through the PA set up in the studio or sometimes using the headphone output on the producers desk to drive a pair of small AIWA speakers. They definitely had a sound !!!

We monitored through Tannoy's, NS10's , Auratone's strapped to a pair of Radio Shack Minimus Sevens. All the sounds had to past muster with those systems. It was kind of Lo tech Hi Fi but it translated really well into the outside world.

Peter's lyrics evolve over a period of time so it was important to be able to pick back up where we had last left off. Total recall was used endlessly, as were copius handwritten detailed notes that were supported by polaroids.

As the project progressed we started running out of tracks, so we brought in a 32 track Mitsubishi and consolidated performances and arrangements for the final push. We were in a "mix mode" for the last 4-5 months , adding overdubs and vocals, editing parts. We finally mixed to half inch and Ian Cooper of the Townhouse mastered the album.

In terms of effects we relied heavily on the following
AMS 1580 Delay
AMS RMX 16 reverb
Delta Lab DL2 Delay
Dimension D
Quantec Room Simulator
Lexicon 224
tape Slap
EMT Plate
Decca Tube compressors
Lots of stomp boxes.
Great Musicians
Unbelieable songs and performances
Lots of fun

When I compare i do think the remastered versions are a tad brighter but whether that was a subjective choice of the mastering engineer or just the limitations of the original vinyl, is anybodies guess. They only way to truly know is to find those half inch masters !!!!!!!

Does that help?

Kevin

Ok, I have another question for Jerry Image omitted from this public edition

This is a bit of a side one that doesn't have too much to do with PG's work, so I'm happy if it doesn't get asked in favour of other people, but if Jerry has a chance to answer somehow, I'd love to hear his response:

A little while ago I found this video [link withheld] on Youtube of a jam that you, Tony Levin and Phil Keaggy participated in in New Jersey a few years back, I think at the tail of one of Phil's shows. I was amazed (in a great way!) to see three musicians whose music I've listened to for what seems like (and probably is) most of my life (Phil's solo and instrumental stuff, Tony's stuff with PG and King Crimson, and your stuff with PG in particular), in the same room playing a public jam!

Can I ask how you and Tony know Phil (I think I can at least guess how you and Tony know each other...), and whether there are other places you three have played together (perhaps on a record?). I'd love to hear more of this stuff.! Image omitted from this public edition

For those interested, the video I linked is a part of the jam these three guys played that was based on PG's Don't Give Up. Jerry kicks it off with a rolling 4 kind of feel, and then Tony comes over it with a 4/4 version of the song's bassline, which gives it an interesting new rhythm.

Embedded media omitted from this public edition

I see that Colin Broad is an expert in machine sync. How was the second Studer A80 Modified? How did it differ from the A machine and how did this effect your work flow?

I also have some question:
– From where do you get the inspiration for your songs?
– What was the reason for starting doing music? Was there a certain occasion?
Thank you!

Traditionally, professional music production has been a collaborative effort with many people performing specific roles. Today the trend seems to be just the opposite with one person tucked away in their home studio trying to duplicate the sound made by many by themselves. Mr. Killen and Mr. Marotta, in your roles as professional producers what is the one piece of advice you believe to be the most important lesson we will learn in this course?

Good day! Here are some questions that I would like to ask:

-For you, what does it take in order to draw people's attention to your work?
-Have you had a negative feeling about your line of work? Had you felt boredom or doubted about your profession at some point in time? If yes, how were you able to get back on track? Also, what advice can you give for artists who (currently) experience these negative feelings/boredom/doubt?

Thank you!

Embedded media omitted from this public edition

How did you get into music? Have you done music for any video games/TV/Movies?

What are the biggest and/or most preventable mistakes you've seen people make when they're just starting out?

Here's my question:
How do you handle different track recorded in different studios with different acoustic treatment?
If you have a dry track you can add or rest some reverb to make it fit in the mix but when you recorded other tracks in a big studio with other natural reverb or in a place without acoustic treatment you can´t fix nothig to make it "match".
Is it a common way to work? There is a way to fix and glue all the tracks and make them sound as a pro song?

Audio it's not very good

The audio is not good, I can't understand anything... Could you post a better quality audio file or/and make a written summary of the interview? Thank you

A high quality video edit will be posted later this week!

Perfect! Thank you very much.

I was going to comment on the Q&A audio as well. When and where will the high quality video be posted? I just don't want to fall too far behind and figured the long weekend would be a good time to complete this "lecture". Glad to see the site is back up and running again.

The first couple of minutes of setup on the live interview were pretty entertaining. Did you all just send those tabletop mics (looks like sm58 but Jerry Marotta's look-over at about 2:15 makes me think not) through the PA speaker that we can kind of see on the right, and then count on the camera mic to capture it all? Because ugh, it really sounds awful and I'm pretty sure everybody sitting up there knows better.

Live interview streamed via laptop. High quality edited footage of interview coming soon! (Yes, we do know better) Image omitted from this public edition

Fantastic interview… Thanks for putting it all together!

It is a privilege to have J. Marotta and K Killen talking about the details of my favourite record ever... Pity the quality of the video, but also the audio is quite poor and that puts me a bit down after a few minutes of watching.

I am aware that you are making I big effort and I thank you and all your team for that, but I was wondering if it would be better to record the interviews only as audio so we can have a proper sound instead of poor video and sound.

Cheers!

Bernardo

As mentioned in the thread (and above) we will be releasing the HD stream shortly, and a transcript. Image omitted from this public edition

Any updates on the video and transcript? (mostly the transcript)

I missed the live stream. Really wanted to hear what Kevin and Jerry had to say. The lo-fi version posted was difficult to listen to. I tried to listen on my studio monitors, headphones, computer speakers, etc. but it was a strain to hear what was being said. Almost an hour and a half of straining to hear was too much straining, so I gave up.

Any updates about when a more listenable version will finally become available?

[participant mention] [link withheld] We're 90% of the way through the transcription and editing of the video. It's taken longer than we anticipated, but we're making progress and will post it as soon as possible.

[participant mention] [link withheld] Thanks for the update!

It's a shame the audio is so poor on this video of Killen and Marotta. It's difficult to understand what they are saying.

[participant mention] [link withheld] Is there any chance we could just the raw video from the interview (maybe with any extraneous beginning and end chopped off) at this stage? I'm sure we could crowd-transcribe the interview. I really want to dig into a usable record of the session Image omitted from this public edition

Also, while I think of it, any idea on when Module 4 will be up?

My questions are do they record vocals prior to the beat or do they do the beats first?how exactly does the vocals go into the mic an then the computer?