OHOTAME · Community reading archive

The companion community, preserved

Technology and music education

Explore the handbook’s abstracts, provocation questions and companion community posts, organized in their original sections.

92 topics · 92 preserved posts · 4 section readers

Start with a question

Choose a section, then explore its perspectives.

Section 1: Emergence and Evolution

Provocation questions 1B

  • How have music educators negotiated the role of technology within the broader terrain of educational policy and practice?
  • What is the role and what are the effects of commerce and industry upon music learning, teaching and technology within schools?

Section 2: Locations and Contexts

Provocation questions 2A

  • What are the impacts of technology (positive and negative) on different communities (rural, urban, suburban), different socio-economic areas, and different parts of the world?
  • What can be done to mitigate the negative effects of technology while accentuating the positive?

Section 3: Experiencing, Expressing, Learning, and Teaching

Provocation questions 3A

  • What are the ramifications of technology and technological change on music teaching and learning in the classroom? What can technology do for music education?
  • In what ways has technology forced us to re-evaluate definitions of musicality? Of musicianship? Of who is and is not a musician?
  • In what ways has technology transformed our understandings of creativity? What are some of the untapped potentials in this area?

Provocation questions 3B

  • What are examples of effective uses of technology? Under what conditions might technology be inappropriate or ineffective?
  • What are familiar challenges to implementation and what strategies have thus far proven effective?
  • Are there limits to what technology affords and constraints?

Section 4: Competence, Credentialing, and Professional Development

Provocation questions 4A

  • Should music technology be taught as an independent subject, or should it serve existing curriculum and instruction? If the latter, how might technology best serve the needs of students and teachers?
  • How can music educators develop and maintain skills beyond their teacher education programs?
  • What sorts of canonized practices have emerged, and how might these impact on teacher training/education?

Provocation questions 4B

  • What are the ramifications of technology and technological change on teacher training/education programs?
  • What possible tensions exist in terms of credentialing and accreditation? Whose responsibility is it for professional development and certification?
This read-only archive preserves material from the community’s public areas. Some historical links and media are unavailable.
Search and browse all 92 entries← Return to section overview

About Our Community & Visitor Chat

Introduction

Section 1:

Core Perspectives - 1B

Provocation Questions - Set 2:

How have music educators negotiated the role of technology within the broader terrain of educational policy and practice? What is the role and what are the effects of commerce and industry upon music learning, teaching a…

1 preserved post

Samuel Leong - Hong Kong Academy of Performing Arts

Chapter 8: Globalization and Technology in Twenty-First-Century Education Samuel Leong, Hong Kong Academy for Performing Arts Abstract: Information and communication technology has created a global “network society” and …

1 preserved post

Core Perspectives - 1A

Provocation Questions - Set 1:

What constitutes a technology in music and music education? In what ways has technology been used, and how has technology affected music education in different times and places?

1 preserved post

Roger Mantie - University of Toronto Scarborough

Chapter 1: Thinking About Music and Technology Roger Mantie, Arizona State University Abstract In this chapter the author explores implications of Heidegger’s landmark discussion of technology for , specifically how our …

1 preserved post

Marina Gall - University of Bristol

Chapter 2: Technology in Music Education in Europe Marina Gall, University of Bristol Abstract: In this chapter, adopting an autobiographical perspective, I reflect upon the use of music technology within English school …

1 preserved post

Further Perspectives - 1B

Heidi Partti - Further Perspective

Chapter 10: Building a Broad View of Technology in Music Teacher Education Heidi Partti, Sibelius Academy Abstract In addition to innovative policy schemes, program visions, and curricular changes, the transformation of …

1 preserved post

Joe Pignato - Further Perspective

Pondering an End to Technology in Music Education In their Core Perspective contributions, Samuel Leong and Smaragda Chrysostomou describe international efforts on the part of governments, nongovernmental organizations, …

1 preserved post

Jonathan Savage - Further Perspective

Where Might We Be Going? Paraphrasing the Cat from Lewis Carroll’s Alice in Wonderland, 'if you don’t know where you are going, any way will take you there.’ The history of music education with technology is a difficult …

1 preserved post

John-Morgan Bush - Further Perspective

Loaded Questions for an Emerging World In order to provide the best possible education for our students, it is imperative to consider the all-to-human reactions to ICT as experienced by all stakeholders in the music-lear…

1 preserved post

Emily Akuno - Further Perspective

Technology in the Music Classroom in Kenya: Rethinking creativity and curriculum The Kenyan music classroom is a tapestry of experiences, challenges and revelations that accommodate, support and impact creativity. The cu…

1 preserved post

Joe Berkovitz - Further Perspective

A Software Creators Perspective Other contributors to this volume bring with them experience as educators, and as what one might term “meta-educators”: thinkers about the nature of teaching and learning and technology. T…

1 preserved post

Jason Chen - Further Perspective

MOBLIE LEARNING IN MUSIC EDUCATION To follow up the trends from an Asian perspective in globalization and technology provided by the core perspective, this section further discusses the recent development of mobile learn…

1 preserved post

Further Perspectives - 1A

Chee-Hoo Lum - Further Perspective

Savoring the Artistic Experience in an Age of Commodification The ideas of savoring, commodification and learning within a multi-media, multi-arts environment are brought forth as food for thought for music educators wor…

1 preserved post

David A. Williams - Further Perspective

Chapter 7: Then and Now David A. Williams, University of South Florida Abstract: Fear of change is deeply embedded in the music education profession. It is a fear of the unknown—a fear of losing control over that with wh…

1 preserved post

Janice Waldron - Further Perspective

Chapter 5: The Role of “Place” and Context Janice Waldron, University of Windsor Abstract: In our eagerness to embrace the virtues of the “new,” we sometimes fail to critically examine the a prioris of the thing we are e…

1 preserved post

Rena Upitis - Further Perspective

Chapter 6: Slow Music Rena Upitis, Queens University Abstract: This chapter explores how technologies can be both enabling and crippling. While music technologies—for centuries—have afforded us the means of creating and …

1 preserved post

Gabriel Solis - Further Perspective

Chapter 4: Music Technology in Ethnomusicology Gabriel Solis, University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign Abstract: Ethnomusicology has often had an ambivalent relationship with technology: we owe our discipline to mid-twent…

1 preserved post

Section 2:

Core Perspectives - 2A

Provocation Questions - 2A:

What are the impacts of technology (positive and negative) on different communities (rural, urban, suburban), different socio-economic areas, and different parts of the world? What can be done to mitigate the negative ef…

1 preserved post

Joe Pignato - SUNY Oneonta, USA

Situating Technology Within and Without Music Education This chapter addresses two overarching questions, “Where is technology within music education?” and “Who is affected and how?” In considering those questions, I att…

1 preserved post

Kylie Peppler - Indiana University, USA

Interest-Driven Music Education This chapter examines how music education can benefit from the use of new electronic tools and materials for music making that allow learners to combine their interests and prior understan…

1 preserved post

Benon Kigozi - Makerere University Kampala, Uganda

Critical Perspectives from Africa In Africa technology amounts to audiovisual aids such as books, systems of musical transmission, aural-oral, mental and mnemonic aids, indigenous African stories, language and literature…

1 preserved post

Paulo Marins - University of Brasília - Brazil

CONTEXT The Ministry of Education of Brazil (MEC) started a program in 2005 called Open University of Brazil (Universidade Aberta do Brasil - UAB). The government started this program with the initial intention of provid…

1 preserved post

Further Perspectives - 2A

Gillian Howell - Further Perspective

Exploring Intersections of Technology and Music Education In revisiting the music technology practices in the three contexts described by Pignato, Peppler, and Kigozi, this chapter foregrounds the playfulness and informa…

1 preserved post

Smaragda Chrysostomou - Further Perspective

Human Potential, Technology and Music Education Technology, music and education, the interrelations and interactions between them as well their impact on music education and young people’s lives, are explored in the core…

1 preserved post

Ethan Hein - Further Perspective

The Promise and Pitfalls of the Digital Studio Whether or not we make the best use of technology in the music classroom, young people will continue to find unexpected uses for it elsewhere. There is no historical precede…

1 preserved post

Bo Nilsson - Further Perspective

Musicking and Technology in Sweden Computers and digital instruments change the way we think about ourselves and other people, demonstrated by an example with a girl who imagined that she had a computer in her brain wher…

1 preserved post

Ailbhe Kenny - Further Perspective

‘Placing’ technology within music education communities The perspective in this chapter focuses on the themes of context and community in ‘situating’ technology within music education in this section. Here, the centralit…

1 preserved post

Core Perspectives - 2B

Provocation Questions - 2B:

How are technology and music technology changing us? How are we changing music technology? How are music educators responding to social, cultural, and economic issues? How should they?

1 preserved post

Heidi Partti - Sibelius Academy, Finland

Pedagogical Fundamentalism to Radical Pedagogy in Music Education Due to the increasing media influence in society, the importance of systematic development of media literacy in music education is a matter of the utmost …

1 preserved post

Evan Tobias - Arizona State University, USA

Locating Technology Within Music Education Technology’s place in music education is largely related to how it is socially constituted. Despite how technology enables intersections of and blurred boundaries between ways o…

1 preserved post

Valerie Peters - Université Laval, Canada

Society, Schools, and Music Learning This chapter examines how music education can benefit from the use of new electronic tools and materials for music making that allow learners to combine their interests and prior unde…

1 preserved post

Further Perspectives - 2B

Gena Greher - Further Perspective

On Becoming Musical: Technology, Possibilities, and Transformation This further perspective examines the role of both high and low-tech solutions, when using music technology as a form of reflective practice in working w…

1 preserved post

Roger Mantie - Further Perspective

Thinking and Talking about Change in Music Education Employing the concepts of linguistic relativity and metaphor (after Lakoff and Johnson), the author considers in this further perspective how our thinking about techno…

1 preserved post

Patricia González - Further Perspective

Technology in Perspective: Who is in Control? It is commonly known that the assimilation and use of technology that is vertically mandated, without a critical consideration of final users, presents various risks such as …

1 preserved post

Leah Kardos - Further Perspective

The Curious Musician Music technologies have lead us to a transformation of perceptions and the reinvention and refinement of our creative music making. They have also transformed our language and are providing access to…

1 preserved post

Ruth Wright - Further Perspective

A Sociological Perspective on Technology in Music Education This writing will consider the questions’ Where is technology within music education? Who is affected and how?’ from a perspective drawn from sociology and in p…

1 preserved post

Carlos Chirinos - Further Perspective

The Role of Music in Public Health Education This essay analyses the Ebola-themed songs produced during the Ebola outbreak of 2014 in West Africa and discusses what role music can play in improving the effectiveness of p…

1 preserved post

Section 3:

Donald DeVito: Further Perspective

Donald DeVito Draft **Oxford Handbook Response Questions How has technology impacted the learning and teaching of music? How should it? What are the ramifications? Technology up until the 21st century tended to be in the…

1 preserved post

Core Perspectives - 3A

Provocation Questions - 3A category

What are the ramifications of technology and technological change on music teaching and learning in the classroom? What can technology do for music education? In what ways has technology forced us to re-evaluate definiti…

1 preserved post

Barbara Freedman - Greenwich (Connecticut) High School, USA

Music Fluency for Music Creation and Composition In this chapter the author argues that music teachers should focus less on having students become readers and writers of standard music notation (i.e., literacy) and more …

1 preserved post

Chee Hoo Lum - Nanyang Technological University, Singapore

Power and Choice in the Teaching and Learning of Music This chapter opens a critical dialogue about the relationship between technology and the teaching and learning of music, with key emphasis on notions of power and ch…

1 preserved post

Ethan Hein - NYU and Montclair State University

Playing (in) the Digital Studio When schools address music technology, they tend to focus on the nuts and bolts of the technology itself, rather than its creative applications. But to truly engage new digital tools for c…

1 preserved post

Core Perspectives - 3B

Provocation Questions - 3B

What are examples of effective uses of technology? Under what conditions might technology be inappropriate or ineffective? What are familiar challenges to implementation and what strategies have thus far proven effective…

1 preserved post

Michael Medvinsky - University Ligget School (Michigan), USA

Meaningful and Relevant Technology Integration Music technology is pervasive in today’s music classrooms but, in many settings, it is the teacher who designs the integration, often with standardized learning outcomes in …

1 preserved post

Janice Waldron - University of Windsor, Canada

The Convergence of Networked Technologies in Music Teaching and Learning The convergence of the Internet and mobile phones with social networks – “networked technologies” – has been the subject of much recent debate. In …

1 preserved post

Gillian Howell - Griffith University, Australia

Limitations of Technology in Community Music New music technologies are often promoted as tools that can enrich music learning experiences, in and out of the classroom. However, their success is context dependent rather …

1 preserved post

Further Perspectives - 3A

Samuel Leong - Further Perspective

Prosumer Learners and Digital Arts Pedagogy Learners are the subject of the educational endeavor, and include the “teachers” and everyone from the very young to seniors. With instant and 24/7 connections to the world via…

1 preserved post

Evan Tobias - Further Perspective

Augmenting Music Teaching and Learning with Technology and Digital Media In this chapter, address how technology enables people to augment aspects of, blur boundaries between, and connect across musical experiences in wa…

1 preserved post

Jay Dorfman - Further Perspective

In this chapter I discuss my views on how music literacy might be reimagined or interpreted within the context of music technology. While a multitude of entry points for music exist, the music literacy that people develo…

1 preserved post

Deborah VanderLinde - Further Perspective

Possibilities for Inclusion with Music Technologies Universal design for learning is a commitment to differentiation on every level, presenting and engaging with content in varied and flexible ways. That is, teachers mig…

1 preserved post

Don Devito - Further Perspective

Technology and Collaboration for People with Significant Disabilities Further Perspectives discussed in this section center on the existence of technology to greatly transform how people with disabilities experience and …

1 preserved post

James Humberstone - Further Perspective

A Pluralist Approach to Music Education This chapter engages with the core perspectives and provocations by proposing that it is possible to revolutionise music education by engaging with the kind of music made with tech…

1 preserved post

Further Perspectives - 3B

Sandy Stauffer, Arizona State University, USA

Technology, Sound, and the Tuning of Place Sound is fundamental to sense of place and the sense of who, where, and how one is in the world. From birth, humans tune in to sounds, tune out some sounds in favor of others, a…

1 preserved post

Kylie Peppler - Further Perspective

Equity and Access in Out-of-School Music Making This chapter focuses on the importance of community to both music education and the ways that youth shape their ideas, interests, and identities in music. Musical learning …

1 preserved post

Evangelos Himonides - Further Perspective

Narcissism, Romanticism, and Technology In this further perspective the author rehearses the possibility of drawing parallels between trends in music education globally and known behaviors (or even conditions) such as ro…

1 preserved post

Ryan Bledsoe - Further Perspective

Pedagogical Decision Making The implementation of technology may present challenges to music educators. These challenges include varying levels of teacher confidence with technology and aspects of creative processes such…

1 preserved post

Section 4:

Core Perspectives - 4A

About the Provocation Questions - 4A category

Should music technology be taught as an independent subject, or should it serve existing curriculum and instruction? If the latter, how might technology best serve the needs of students and teachers? How can music educat…

1 preserved post

Jay Dorfman - Kent State University, USA

Traditions and Ways Forward in the United States In this chapter I focus on structure of music teacher preparation programs, how they currently accommodate technology studies, and how they might do so in the future. I di…

1 preserved post

Jonathan Savage - Manchester Metropolitan University, UK

Authentic Approaches to Music Education with Technology This chapter argues that approaches to music education with or without technology have been unhelpfully categorized in binary opposition. An example of this from qu…

1 preserved post

Gena Greher - UMass Lowell, USA

Technology and Invisibility in Music Teacher Education The purpose of technology in the music teacher education curriculum is examined in this chapter. While it is easy to view technology as an efficient content delivery…

1 preserved post

Core Perspectives - 4B

About the Provocation Questions - 4B category

What are the ramifications of technology and technological change on teacher training/education programs? What possible tensions exist in terms of credentialing and accreditation? Whose responsibility is it for professio…

1 preserved post

David A. Williams - University of South Florida, USA

Music Technology Pedagogy and Curricula Equipping in-service and pre-service teachers with music technology skills is a matter for concern within the music education profession. There is, however, an even more important …

1 preserved post

Further Perspectives - 4A

Benon Kigozi - Further Perspective

Applications of Technology in Music Education from Selected Countries Culturally, many Africans feel that African music must be taught in context and through methods that are specific to Africa. Thus far, “African cultur…

1 preserved post

Marina Gall - Further Perspective

Technology in Music Initial Teacher Education In this chapter I draw upon the work of Gena Greher and Jay Dorfman, teacher educators working in Massachusetts, to compare and contrast music initial teacher education (ITE)…

1 preserved post

Michael Medvinsky - Further Perspective

Learner Engagement and Technology Integration If music educators use technology to do old things in new ways, they are still doing old things. Music is constantly evolving with technological advancements. Technology can …

1 preserved post

Julie Ballantyne - Further Perspective

Using Mobile Technologies and Problem-Seeking Pedagogies to Bridge Universities and Workplaces The task of providing future music teachers with the capacity to respond effectively in changing teaching environments and th…

1 preserved post

Lauri Väkevä - Further Perspective

Defining and Acknowledging Music Education Technology in Music Teacher Training In this further perspective, I discuss music education technology from the standpoint of Finnish music teacher education. After narrating sh…

1 preserved post

Further Perspectives - 4B

Valerie Peters - Further Perspective

Preparing for Change and Uncertainty This reaction paper discusses how university faculty members in higher education respond to change, especially change that embraces technology. The resistance to change, situated in t…

1 preserved post

Barbara Freedman - Further Perspective

Why Isn’t Music Education in the US more 21st Century PC? In this further perspective, the author addresses three themes in the core perspectives. First, she argues that pre-service teachers should be trained in technolo…

1 preserved post

Matt Hitchcock - Further Perspective

Generating Intersections between Music and Technology Drawing on his background as a professional performing musician, recording studio owner, record producer, recording engineer, software programmer, and music teacher i…

1 preserved post

Advancing Our Conversations

Advancing Our Conversations:

[Replace this first paragraph with a short description of your new category. This guidance will appear in the category selection area, so try to keep it below 200 characters. Until you edit this text or create topics, th…

1 preserved post

OHOTAME Privacy Policy

What information do we collect? [historical link unavailable] We collect information from you when you register on our site and gather data when you participate in the forum by reading, writing, and evaluating the content shared here.…

1 preserved post

OHOTAME FAQ/Guidelines

This is a Civilized Place for Public Discussion [historical link unavailable] Please treat this discussion forum with the same respect you would a public park. We, too, are a shared community resource — a place to share skills, knowle…

1 preserved post
← Return to section overview