OHOTAME · Community reading archive

Section 4

Competence, Credentialing, and Professional Development

Choose a title to read its preserved abstract. Open the original entry for full-page reading.

Core perspective · 4A

Open original entry ↗

Traditions and Ways Forward in the United States

In this chapter I focus on structure of music teacher preparation programs, how they currently accommodate technology studies, and how they might do so in the future. I discuss music technology skill development and the roles of faculty in overseeing skill development under the theoretical model known as TPACK (Technological Pedagogical and Content Knowledge). I conclude with suggestions for researching the complex task of integrating technology into music preparation.

Core perspective · 4A

Open original entry ↗

Authentic Approaches to Music Education with Technology

This chapter argues that approaches to music education with or without technology have been unhelpfully categorized in binary opposition. An example of this from qualification frameworks in the United Kingdom is explored. Notions of what constitutes a ‘digital’ musician as opposed a ‘non-digital’ musician are equally flawed. Rather, the chapter argues that a rich accounts of musical practice and music education should avoid artificial distinctions and focus on what really matters – the music itself. One example of such an approach from the world of electroacoustic music is presented as a potential way forward.

Core perspective · 4A

Open original entry ↗

Technology and Invisibility in Music Teacher Education

The purpose of technology in the music teacher education curriculum is examined in this chapter. While it is easy to view technology as an efficient content delivery system, that perspective does little to support pedagogical transformation or 21st Century Skill acquisition. State teacher certification requirements mired in 20th Century practices have done little to encourage a re-thinking of the music teacher education curriculum to include a more expansive and constructionist view of the role technology can play in music education.

Those creating the curricular guidelines for higher education in music are perhaps conflating the pervasive existence of the technological tools available to our students with the existence of a sound pedagogy for working with these tools. By providing a pedagogical approach based on creating with technology, we can begin to bridge the disconnect between music education practice, and the multiple ways that our students understand music on their own outside of school.

Core perspective · 4B

Open original entry ↗

Faculty Development in and through the Use of ICT

Governmental and institutional policies in many countries currently encourage the use of technology at all educational levels. Post-secondary music education has not escaped from these demands and faculty members are expected to fully embrace the use of technology to improve teaching and their professional practice. In Mexico, while universities have emphasized providing technological infrastructures and faculty development programs in and through the use of ICT, this goal has not been fully met, particularly in music and music education programs. This chapter provides a general overview of the challenges that need to be overcome in order to fully embrace the technological era and the current professional and technological development needs of university professors. It also describes a technology-enhanced professional development program conceived to provide continuous learning opportunities in post-secondary music education that has resulted into an international partnership and the development of communities of practice.

Core perspective · 4B

Open original entry ↗

Educators’ Roles and Professional Development

In this core perspective concerning the ramifications of technology and technological change on teacher training/education programs, the author offers five points as essential for such a discourse, namely, that the role of technology in education is central; that technology can foster the development of teachers’ critical thinking; that teachers cannot be passive recipients of whatever educational reforms and that they need to be in a position to shape their own and their students’ learning; that it is the social facet of technology that will play a leading role in teachers’ competence, credentialing, and professional development; and, finally, that technology is becoming mature enough to allow us to re-rehearse the notion of evidence based education in a completely novel way.

Core perspective · 4B

Open original entry ↗

Music Technology Pedagogy and Curricula

Equipping in-service and pre-service teachers with music technology skills is a matter for concern within the music education profession. There is, however, an even more important issue affecting the use of music technologies in schools.This has to do with the pedagogy we employ in our classrooms. Curricular possibilities employing learner-centered and informal learning pedagogies are explored in this chapter and one particular model that relies heavily on student autonomy is detailed. This pedagogical approach shares much in common with how individuals make music in popular music settings outside of schools.

Further perspective · 4A

Open original entry ↗

Applications of Technology in Music Education from Selected Countries

Culturally, many Africans feel that African music must be taught in context and through methods that are specific to Africa. Thus far, “African culture” and instructional practices in Africa have not succeeded in consistently incorporating computer-based technology for music education into regular classroom instruction, even at those few schools that can afford it. Computer-based technology must therefore prove to have a generic role of preservation and advancement of the culture if it is to be integrated in music education. Through discussion of music teaching in Namibia, Ghana, Malawi, Botswana, Zimbabwe, Nigeria, and Kenya the author illustrates how governmental educational policy reflects and relates to expectations for technology in music education.

Further perspective · 4A

Open original entry ↗

Technology in Music Initial Teacher Education

In this chapter I draw upon the work of Gena Greher and Jay Dorfman, teacher educators working in Massachusetts, to compare and contrast music initial teacher education (ITE) in the USA with the system in England. This includes discussion of the structure of the teacher education programmes, the impact of the differing school curricula on teacher education in each country, novice teachers’ opportunities for using technology when on school placements, and continuing professional development for practising school teachers. I also add to reflections on the English system of ITE for secondary music teachers presented by Jonathan Savage in his earlier chapter, raising issues related to gender, and new forms of ITE that have emerged of late.

Further perspective · 4A

Open original entry ↗

Learner Engagement and Technology Integration

If music educators use technology to do old things in new ways, they are still doing old things. Music is constantly evolving with technological advancements. Technology can be used in many different ways in music classes. Technology best serves music educators when they reimagine musicianship and design opportunities to explore nontraditional ways of being a musician. This should begin with the teacher’s preservice experiences. Music educators need a rich understanding of their content area so that technology becomes a support for authentic musical processes as opposed to being an add-on. The integration of music technology must be contextualized within methods courses in order for music educators to feel comfortable enough with the technology itself that it becomes transparent to the musical experiences. Technology will never replace a great educator, but a great educator who understands the possibilities of supporting learning with technology will replace a great educator who does not.

Further perspective · 4A

Open original entry ↗

Using Mobile Technologies and Problem-Seeking Pedagogies to Bridge Universities and Workplaces

The task of providing future music teachers with the capacity to respond effectively in changing teaching environments and the related issues of retention and job satisfaction of early-career teachers present an on-going challenge to teacher educators. Engagement in a process of systematic problem-solving arguably builds the kind of complex understanding of the real-world workplace which inoculates against praxis shock. In this further perspective, the author addresses the problem by demonstrating how the utilization of simple technologies as learning tools can enhance the quality of the teacher education process. The Engagement in the Mobile Technologies Project (MTP) encapsulates a two-way process of having future teachers become comfortable with new technologies, thereby increasing the likelihood that they will use them effectively in their classrooms. The aim of this pedagogical trial was to increase the relevance of tertiary study to the “real world,” linking the reality of teaching with university training.

Further perspective · 4A

Open original entry ↗

Defining and Acknowledging Music Education Technology in Music Teacher Training

In this further perspective, I discuss music education technology from the standpoint of Finnish music teacher education. After narrating shortly my own history as a digital immigrant, I describe Finnish music education system and the varied functions technology has had in it. While music technology has been studied for decades in the country, there has been a lack of pedagogical concentration on communication technology and the social aspects of music technology. It seems that, at least in Finland, we need a rethinking of how music education technology courses can widen music teachers’ visions. Music teacher training programs would seem to be natural habitats for experimenting with different expressive and creative aspects of digital technology. I conclude by presenting three suggestions on how to organize music education technology studies in Finnish music teacher education.

Further perspective · 4B

Open original entry ↗

Preparing for Change and Uncertainty

This reaction paper discusses how university faculty members in higher education respond to change, especially change that embraces technology. The resistance to change, situated in the “independent entrepreneur” professorial model that continues to exist in most music education doctoral programs and most university faculties, is discussed. A collaborative model with faculty working together to prepare undergraduate students for the complexity of music teaching in the 21st century is proposed. Attitudes and core beliefs about technology integration are discussed as well as the difficulty of coming to a common understanding of how technological changes might orient teacher certification around the world. Finally, preparing future teachers for an uncertain future is proposed as a professional teacher education competency, a way for teachers to take charge of their own continued professional development and a way for them to initiate and sustain changes in their own local contexts.

Further perspective · 4B

Open original entry ↗

Why Isn’t Music Education in the US more 21st Century PC?

In this further perspective, the author addresses three themes in the core perspectives. First, she argues that pre-service teachers should be trained in technology and technology pedagogy as one would train pre-service teachers on brass, woodwinds, percussion, or piano. Second, she suggests that in-service teachers are the expert in their classrooms regardless of their pre-existing competence with any individual sub-domain – brass, percussion, or, in this case, technology. Just as experienced band teachers have no problem asking their advanced trumpet player students to help the beginning trumpet player students, teachers can similarly capitalize on students with technological competence. Third, the author argues that the American music education system, K- University, is implicitly skewed toward middle to upper economic class culture and, by nature, disinherits those that seek to engage in other musical cultures. Technology, she suggests, is an excellent way to better meet the needs of all students.

Further perspective · 4B

Open original entry ↗

Generating Intersections between Music and Technology

Drawing on his background as a professional performing musician, recording studio owner, record producer, recording engineer, software programmer, and music teacher in Australia, the author discusses the dichotomy between the ubiquity of music technology in the music world and its relative paucity in the school curriculum. He goes on to discuss how music educators should remain aware of the marketplace, specifically how the democratization of technology has caused major disruptions to multi-national corporations while simultaneously resulting in the prevalence of copy and paste music making. Ultimately, the author presents a taxonomy (imitation, emulation, inspiration, generation) for understanding how technology can be deployed in musically generative ways.