OHOTAME · Community reading archive

Section 3

Experiencing, Expressing, Learning, and Teaching

Choose a title to read its preserved abstract. Open the original entry for full-page reading.

Core perspective · 3A

Open original entry ↗

Music Fluency for Music Creation and Composition

In this chapter the author argues that music teachers should focus less on having students become readers and writers of standard music notation (i.e., literacy) and more on teaching whatever music “language skills” will allow students to freely communicate their ideas in music – i.e., to have them become fluent in the language of music. The author also demonstrates how, when using software to facilitate music creation teaching, the piano keyboard and various graphical visualizations of sound helps to teach and understand chord progressions, accompaniment patterns, bass lines from chords, melody writing, and music theory in ways more meaningful than traditional instruction. Through the intelligent use of technology, students who have never played piano or studied another instrument suddenly create, of their own volition, music of increasing sophistication.

Core perspective · 3A

Open original entry ↗

Power and Choice in the Teaching and Learning of Music

This chapter opens a critical dialogue about the relationship between technology and the teaching and learning of music, with key emphasis on notions of power and choice. Discussions revolve around technology as provisions for: i) access to the musical world as sound through digital forms/formats, ii) greater opportunities for the most basic beginner in music to explore and experiment with sound, iii) wide/r choice and variety in listening, performing and creating for both the ‘trained’ and ‘untrained’ musician, iv) compressed time and space in musical experiences and environments, and v) questioning what constitutes musicality, a musician and skill acquisition. Music educators need to draw closer links between the widening gap of school music with learners’ daily musical-technological experiences and become more cognizant of the multi-media and multidisciplinary space which the digital native learner is engulfed in to further notions of creative work within the music classroom that might include these experiences.

Core perspective · 3A

Open original entry ↗

Playing (in) the Digital Studio

When schools address music technology, they tend to focus on the nuts and bolts of the technology itself, rather than its creative applications. But to truly engage new digital tools for creative music-making, we must address their most culturally significant context: electronic dance music and hip-hop. This music falls well outside the canon of what is widely considered suitable music for the classroom. Nevertheless, such music should be included, and not (only) because young people enjoy it. Rather than ‘dumbing down’ music education, the inclusion of popular dance music would significantly enrich the curriculum, particularly in areas traditionally neglected: groove, timbre, and space.

Core perspective · 3B

Open original entry ↗

Meaningful and Relevant Technology Integration

Music technology is pervasive in today’s music classrooms but, in many settings, it is the teacher who designs the integration, often with standardized learning outcomes in mind. As learners and teachers navigate these new experiences, teachers must develop environments in which learner/musicians have voice in the design process and agency in their own learning. New genres and digital instruments have played integral roles in extending the definition of what it is to be a musician. In the context of listening, performing and creating experiences, providing opportunities for learners to create music using emerging technologies produces a classroom culture where musicians become autonomous in their approach to showing their musical understanding. The technology and the learning become ubiquitous, transparent, and constantly evolve.

Core perspective · 3B

Open original entry ↗

The Convergence of Networked Technologies in Music Teaching and Learning

The convergence of the Internet and mobile phones with social networks – “networked technologies” – has been the subject of much recent debate. In this chapter, I consider what new media researchers have already discerned regarding networked technologies; most importantly, that more significant than any given technology is how we use it, the effect(s) its use has on us, and the relationships we form through it and with the technology. Music education researchers and practitioners have tended to focus on technology as a knowable “thing” – i.e. hardware and/or software with its “practical classroom applications” – and not the greater epistemological issues underlying its use. How will we engage musically in a meaningful way with a generation of students – “digital natives” – who have grown up technologically “tethered?” How will these different “ways of knowing” change music learning and teaching now and in the not-so-distant future?

Core perspective · 3B

Open original entry ↗

Limitations of Technology in Community Music

New music technologies are often promoted as tools that can enrich music learning experiences, in and out of the classroom. However, their success is context dependent rather than universally certain. This chapter examines some of the limitations that occur in facilitator-led community music activities, where project goals frequently encompass social and health-related dimensions as well as musical, and where sustainability of activities and outcomes is often a priority.

Descriptions of music composition projects in three diverse settings – from a remote village in post-war East Timor (Timor-Leste), to a school-based residency in suburban Australia – illustrate some of the limitations of new music technologies. Issues discussed include environmental capacities, workshop flow, and facilitator knowledge. While new music technologies in community music workshops are not inherently problematic, this chapter argues that their effective use requires thorough consideration of the complete environmental and social context.

Further perspective · 3A

Open original entry ↗

Prosumer Learners and Digital Arts Pedagogy

Learners are the subject of the educational endeavor, and include the “teachers” and everyone from the very young to seniors. With instant and 24/7 connections to the world via technologies, the transformed educational eco-system has given rise to prosumer learners who are both producers and consumers. Technology has expanded the diversity and range of possible learning contexts, enabled the provision of life-long learning opportunities, assisted in catering for learners with different academic abilities and behavioral needs, while resetting the traditional classroom-based schooling and herd-driven consumer culture with a life-wide participatory culture. Today’s digital arts pedagogy and technology-enhanced curriculum should be more prosumer friendly – liberating teachers and learners from the constraints of school practices (e.g., rigid timetables, fixed rows of desks and chairs) while facilitating learners to become more adaptable and flexible, able to negotiate, navigate and manipulate the oceans of knowledge that is fluid, multi-faceted and open to interpretation.

Further perspective · 3A

Open original entry ↗

Augmenting Music Teaching and Learning with Technology and Digital Media

In this chapter, address how technology enables people to augment aspects of, blur boundaries between, and connect across musical experiences in ways that might expand conceptions of musicality, musicianship, and who might be considered a musician. I propose three such approaches to leveraging technology: augmenting music and musical engagement, augmenting musical sharing and concert experiences, and augmenting performing and ensembles. These three approaches to augmenting music teaching and learning through technology and digital media have potential to expand how music educators and their students conceptualize and enact musicianship. The chapter forwards a perspective that leveraging technology and digital media to augment music and musical engagement situates the act of connecting and identifying musical relationships as a form of musicianship and way of being a musician.

Further perspective · 3A

Open original entry ↗

In this chapter I discuss my views on how music literacy might be reimagined or interpreted within the context of music technology. While a multitude of entry points for music exist, the music literacy that people develop can be equally legitimate regardless of the point they choose. I also discuss teachers’ roles as facilitators of literacy development.

Further perspective · 3A

Open original entry ↗

Possibilities for Inclusion with Music Technologies

Universal design for learning is a commitment to differentiation on every level, presenting and engaging with content in varied and flexible ways. That is, teachers might provide multiple ways for students to engage with content and to express what they know with multiple avenues for applying and assessing understanding (aural, oral, singing, verbally, visually, enactively and kinesthetically, with iconic representation, with manipulatives and assistive technologies). These principles are best practices for all teaching, but essential for learners with exceptionalities.

Mobile technologies have much to offer as a form of assistive technology for learners with exceptionalities. The content in this “further perspective” explores these possibilities.

Further perspective · 3A

Open original entry ↗

Technology and Collaboration for People with Significant Disabilities

Further Perspectives discussed in this section center on the existence of technology to greatly transform how people with disabilities experience and express themselves through music. The variety of methods for developing the untapped potential of music participants with complex needs in the modern music classroom are discussed. Widely available technology such as: Skype, Google Hangout, and simple online communication technology create real and enduring international connections and interactions in music education for all learners. The definition of music and musicianship are discussed through 21st Century issues and trends in the inclusive classroom. How we define who is a musician and who is considered to have the prerequisite music skills and expertise to be referred to as a performer will increasingly change or in fact become irrelevant with the advent of personal music technology. The result will be music opportunities for all special needs populations around the world.

Further perspective · 3A

Open original entry ↗

A Pluralist Approach to Music Education

This chapter engages with the core perspectives and provocations by proposing that it is possible to revolutionise music education by engaging with the kind of music made with technology that Hein advocated for in his chapter; but at the same time, not to abandon what we know about tried and tested music pedagogies. It proposes the way to do this is to take a truly pluralist approach to music, one that embraces all genres, especially popular music genres, by taking the time to learn about them and legitimise them in the music classroom. Recent research on the creative processes of traditional composers and DJs reveals technology directly affects both, and this understanding, alongside Freedman’s approach that allows students to lead with technology, breaks down the borders preventing such a pluralist approach from being taken. It is concluded that such barriers have already been broken in the professional, metamodern musical world.

Further perspective · 3B

Open original entry ↗

Technology, Sound, and the Tuning of Place

Sound is fundamental to sense of place and the sense of who, where, and how one is in the world. From birth, humans tune in to sounds, tune out some sounds in favor of others, and, over time, consciously or unconsciously, use sound to tune place. Conversely, the sonic qualities of places, including music, tune human actions and interactions. Technologies of all kinds allow us to create, separate, reproduce, intensify, or cancel sound. These ways of manipulating sound are also a means of curating of space and therefore place-making gestures. What should that matter in music education?

Further perspective · 3B

Open original entry ↗

Equity and Access in Out-of-School Music Making

This chapter focuses on the importance of community to both music education and the ways that youth shape their ideas, interests, and identities in music. Musical learning is rarely, if ever, about a learner operating a new musical technology-based tool in isolation. Music is inherently social and these influences have a great impact upon the development of musical identities. This chapter explores the ways that out-of-school spaces like those in the Computer Clubhouse Network, YOUmedia, and Musical Futures support social music learning by providing private recording studios that allow youth to assume increasingly public roles as musicians, performers, and producers; and describe how mixing formal, non-formal, and informal learning spaces helps to develop a youth’s musical maturity through what is known as the “progression pathways model.”

Further perspective · 3B

Open original entry ↗

Narcissism, Romanticism, and Technology

In this further perspective the author rehearses the possibility of drawing parallels between trends in music education globally and known behaviors (or even conditions) such as romanticism and narcissism. We attempts to view technology’s role under this novel ‘lens.’ Finally, the author argues that technology is often viewed as a tool, or as sets of tools, that are being used not particularly creatively in order to “enable,” “facilitate,” or “enhance” curricular aims and objectives that might have remained unchanged for over a century, which is something that might be counterproductive. The author suggests that it is through technology that a new “music education” can be envisaged, celebrated, and experienced.

Further perspective · 3B

Open original entry ↗

Pedagogical Decision Making

The implementation of technology may present challenges to music educators. These challenges include varying levels of teacher confidence with technology and aspects of creative processes such as student exploration; teacher conceptions of when music happens, risk, and failure; and school curricula. I provide examples of these challenges from a music teacher’s perspective. One of the questions from my own practice is in what ways could students be makers, tinkerers, or engineers in the music classroom? I identify three principles that guide my own implementation of technology in a creativity-driven music classroom. These principles are not unique to teaching music with technology, and could underlie all music-making experiences for children.

Further perspective · Additional section 3 perspective

Open original entry ↗

Donald DeVito
Draft

**Oxford Handbook Response Questions

How has technology impacted the learning and teaching of music? How should it? What are the ramifications?

Technology up until the 21st century tended to be in the form of equipment utilized in the classroom to play and watch examples of music performance. Examples are the CD player for listening and the VCR or DVD player for watching recorded performances of local ensembles, classical orchestras and movies about famous musicians. While these were utilized to enhance the curriculum by viewing and listening to a piece of music from a given style or genre, simple technology exists today to greatly transform how interaction with music and musicians takes place in the classroom. The opportunity through Skype, Google Hangout and simple online communication technology to create real and enduring international connections into the classroom curriculum are widely available. The IPad is increasingly becoming considered as a music resource and especially with children with disabilities, an adapted music instrument. The same device can be plugged into a projector and with Skype or other readily available online communication program literally open the world of music to a classroom by engaging with musicians from all areas and professions. The ramification is that technology is no longer just a CD player and music literature in the classroom is no longer Americanized versions of traditional world music offered in state adopted textbooks. The manners in which these engagements take place are wide and varied.

The Sidney Lanier Center School where I teach serves students with moderate to severe disabilities between the ages of 3 and 22. The description of our program below includes each course by grade including supplemental music ensembles. The music program highlights a global music education approach that utilizes Skype to link our music classes with universities and community based programs around the world. The efforts of this music program have been published in peer reviewed journals, book chapters and international music education conferences since 2003. Institutions linked with the Sidney Lanier music program include: The University of Roehampton and the Univ. of London in the U.K., the China Conservatory, the Universidad de Londrina in Brazil, Limerick University in Ireland, Queensland University in Australia, the Special Education Centre music program led by Arthur Gill in Gujrat City, Pakistan, Group Laiengee in Guinea, West Africa, the Notre Maison orphanage led by Gertrude Bien Aime –founder of one of the few programs that serves children with disabilities in Haiti, the University of Minneapolis-Duluth, Pacific University, James Madison University, Jackson State University, the University of South Florida and recently the University of Miami. UM staff members have expressed interest in developing an online special education course that will include the Sidney Lanier Center as a part of the practicum training for the U.M. music education majors. This multi-cultural real time approach to music and special education has opened doors and adapted learning experiences for our students for over a decade.

A current project in development was brought about by an invitation I received to present on this program at the “Listen” Conference held by the Sabreen organization in the West Bank for Palestinian educators looking to develop music education as a course in public schools. A variety of presenters shared the latest approaches in music education development. As a result of teaching in local schools and this session, Skype collaboration will now begin between two special schools of varying populations that cater to children with disabilities, one in Bethlehem the other in Jerusalem, and the Sidney Lanier Center in Florida. The first school in Bethlehem was “Ephpheta Paul VI” Pontifical Institute for the audio-phonetic rehabilitation and the educator who accompanied me in the workshop was Luab Nayef Hammoud, a creative and dedicated music teacher at the school. One current grant project idea with the Jerusalem school was to share music education online and then have the activity culminate with an in person visit by children at the school in Jerusalem who would visit their colleagues in Florida. The inclusion of the developing project being included this Oxford Handbook on Music and Technology is an early and very meaningful distinction for of all the special schools involved.

What can technology do for music education?

Technology can break down barriers between cultures, create previously un-thought of educational and interaction opportunities in the music classroom and enhance the quality of life for underserved populations. Consider the following example. A public school in the united states that serves students with moderate to severe disabilities links with the University of Roehampton and the University of London in the UK through Skype to create facilitation of the newest approach developed there in creating behavioral response frameworks to music called Sounds of Intent which is shared with the Notre Maison orphanage in Port Au Prince, Haiti. This included the Society for Education, Music and Psychology Research (SEMPRE) based at the University of London, who provided a projector for group instruction for the orphanage to enhance the Skype experience to their entire orphanage at one time and Go Talk communication technology for facilitating a nonverbal communication approach for children with severe speech language challenges at the orphanage. This approach has been explored in a number of facets over the years with the Sidney Lanier Center utilizing Skype in the music education classroom. A variety of in person collaborations, trainings and shared music education activities have developed as a result of this approach.

After several Skype activities with the Notre Maison Orphanage in Haiti, I went in person to develop a music and special education program there and followed it up with enhanced Skype interactions with the students at Sidney Lanier upon my return. Documentation of this led to being involved with Projects for Haiti who invited me, and Gertrude the director of Notre Maison who we collaborate with online to travel together to Cap Haitian in the north of the country to train 400 Haitian teachers in the concept of music and special education inclusion developed at Notre Maison. The culminating activity resulted in hundreds of Haitian teachers volunteering in adapted arts activities in their communicates with children with disabilities, and the publication of their feedback to the Projects for Haiti training (which involved 12 other educators from the US) in a book on their approaches to developed inclusion in Haiti, edited by myself and Project for Haiti creators Bertrhude Albert and Priscilla Zelaya. All 400 Haitian educators are to be listed as contributing authors to this book which will be translated in Creole and distributed throughout Haiti. One cumulative effect will be enhancing their status in their communities and the further understanding of the ability of arts education to enhance underserved populations. All from the development of music education and Skype technology triangulated between the efforts of major universities in the U.K., public schools in the U.S. and community based programs in low resource areas such as Haiti. Further communication on this development and shared experiences is being continued with the Haitian teachers using simple technology such as cell phones that allow them to access Facebook to post and share their needs and experiences with this collaborative project.

In what ways has technology forced us to re-evaluate definitions of musicality? Of musicianship?

Musicality has changed with technology as the venue of music making has changed. This has been accounted for in several developments with the advent of technology. Namely, in relation to: a. venue, b. the definition of audience, and c. the manner in which music performance is shared and transmitted. With online technology, music is no longer primarily taking place in a single room or recital hall. It is being shared in greater real time settings with the transmission of music no longer taking place in a theatre or established hall. With this change in venue comes a change in acoustics and in the styles of music being transmitted allowing for real time blending of cultural styles and genres. The definition of audience is also changing with a much more varied integration of participants from school students to professional musicians of greatly varied cultures and backgrounds. The manner in which music performance is shared and transmitted is also changing with the advent of IPADS as a recognized musical instrument. In fact, informal music integration can take place in hand held devices with the differences in time zones becoming less of a factor with friends and colleagues simply adjusting their schedules or sharing spontaneous music activities during free time as opposed to set class scheduling or evening performances.

Of who is and is not a musician? In what ways has technology transformed our understandings of creativity? What are some of the untapped potentials in this area?

There seems to be a common perception that people with disabilities receive music therapy while those without receive music education. With advancements in IPad and other related technology that only require the movement of a finger to generate musical sounds, the ability to participate as an active musician in an ensemble is being redefined in some truly amazing and positive ways. In many cases, students with severe disabilities who are in a traditional public school would often be kept out of higher level performing ensembles because of their special needs (often through auditions, an inability to read written music, no mandate requiring their participation, and oftentimes the lack of consideration by the family that the student has the skills necessary to participate). Thanks to examples such as the global online program at the Sidney Lanier Center, students are having inclusive online experiences with ensembles from around the world and at all levels of accomplishment. Some of this collaboration in the aforementioned Sidney Lanier Center online program will include Gary Day, an expert in IPad music adaptation who is currently affiliated with the University of Roehampton in London, UK. He has already shared traditional Irish music with the students and will begin instructing the students on the utilization of IPads in shared music experiences in 2015.

In what ways has technology transformed our understandings of creativity?

The manner in which technology is utilized can transform our current understandings of creativity by opening the door to a variety of media that previously was not available. Currently, hardware can be developed that is specifically designed to minimize the hand eye coordination needed to create musical sounds while pairing with software that opens up a variety of methods for creating music. Specifically, music that can be enjoyed by the performer alone or adapted to include others in a concert environment. One such example was the development of a personal sound generated device by Mallory Moyer, a University of South Florida student who created a device that looks much like an oil painting with deep grooves and designs but becomes a personalized music instrument at most or a sound generating device at least for people with severe disabilities. The project required a study of music therapy, design, and technology which helped her to create a musical instrument with universal playability. The musical design of this instrument includes fun graphics and a touch sense technology allowing anyone to play and have fun. The goal was for people with disabilities to achieve the therapeutic benefits of playing a musical instrument. Throughout the project she introduced her instrument to a wide variety of people: musicians, doctors, and people with disabilities.

My music program had an incredible role in this project. I provided suggestions for the project, and my students approached the instrument for the first time at the school and had a wide range of reactions that revealed the potentials of this technological approach. It also revealed the potential advantages of having a touch sensitive instrument on hand in the classroom. It also opened up discussions on the possibilities of having instruments that are customizable, tailored to the individual. Choice of sounds, colors, graphics, size, and placement of the touch sensitive graphics could be considered. The most profound realization of this project was its potential for growth.
Mallory intends to continue to develop the project and work with our center school in the future. She will collaborate with creative minds to make new prototypes and instruments based on universal playability and music therapy and hopes to continue to utilize these insightful resources as she and her project grow.

Another example was the use of IPads by Phil Mullen and I at the 1st inclusive music performance held at the China Conservatory in Beijing coordinated by Professor Xie Jiaxing in 2012 and including adults with learning disabilities from the Anhuali Community Center. This concert utilized IPad apps that created a variety of acoustic and modern sounds that fit within a hands on pitched and unpitched percussion ensemble comprised of conservatory students and local adults with learning disabilities from the Anhuali Community Center.

What are some of the untapped potentials in this area?

One of the key untapped potentials in this area is the increasing ability of people to create and design their own apps for computer and personal device technology. I would guess in the near future the ability of people to develop their own music apps without relying on software engineers will become commonplace. What sounds represent music and what constitutes an instrument are being redefined as technology develops in the field of music education and performance. This should continue to change and develop over time. Originally, the format of music reception was through recordings which could be listened to individually or shared at dances and restaurant Jukeboxes. Technology is not only changing the context in which music is shared but the utilization of music performance and interaction by what may no longer be referred to as “non-musicians”. How we define who is a musician and who is considered to have the prerequisite music skills and expertise to be referred to as a performer will increasingly change or in fact become irrelevant with the advent of personal music technology-bringing music opportunities to all populations regardless of special needs around the world.