OHOTAME · Community reading archive

Section 2

Locations and Contexts

Choose a title to read its preserved abstract. Open the original entry for full-page reading.

Core perspective · 2A

Open original entry ↗

Situating Technology Within and Without Music Education

This chapter addresses two overarching questions, “Where is technology within music education?” and “Who is affected and how?” In considering those questions, I attempt to situate technology within and without music education, that is to say, internal to and external to the paradigmatic constraints of institutionalized learning. In the process, I argue for the development of authentically poietic spaces, or communities of response, within music education contexts. Further, I recommend situating technology within those spaces in such ways as to empower otherwise vulnerable young musicians to explore their own interests, idiosyncratic ways of learning, and the deterritorialized, subjective-social worlds they inhabit. The first section of the chapter addresses the particularized nature of technology within music education contexts. The second section includes examples of technology without music education. The final section lists conclusions that attempt to situate technology in and across those two broad domains.

Core perspective · 2A

Open original entry ↗

Interest-Driven Music Education

This chapter examines how music education can benefit from the use of new electronic tools and materials for music making that allow learners to combine their interests and prior understandings toward deepening their engagement in music. By exploring how rhythmic videogames like Rock Band bridge the large chasm that exists between youths’ music culture and traditional music education; how inexpensive recording hardware and software such as Audacity and Apple Garageband has provided youth with opportunities to compose and perform as only professional musicians could in the past; and how software like Impromptu successfully engages youth in music composition and analysis by enabling users to create and remix tunes using virtual blocks that contain portions of melodies and/or rhythmic patterns, this chapter argues 21st-century music education, with the help of new technology, has the potential for engaging greater numbers of young learners in authentic music making and performance.

Core perspective · 2A

Open original entry ↗

Critical Perspectives from Africa

In Africa technology amounts to audiovisual aids such as books, systems of musical transmission, aural-oral, mental and mnemonic aids, indigenous African stories, language and literature; and aspects of science, the arts and culture. In the West it is different. And, in many parts of United States and Europe, technology is guaranteed of being available. In Africa it is not. And, many African countries have different perspectives regarding technology applied in music education. Zimbabwe is working on consolidating indigenous music in systems of education but, until four years ago there was no music in primary school. Malawi legitimized music in the National Curriculum to be taught through standard 1 to 8, however, there is no mention of technology being integrated with music in education. The Primary Arts Core program of the Namibia’s Ministry of Basic Education and Culture is silent about technological in music education. This section illuminates other perspectives.

Core perspective · 2A

Open original entry ↗

CONTEXT

The Ministry of Education of Brazil (MEC) started a program in 2005 called Open University of Brazil (Universidade Aberta do Brasil - UAB). The government started this program with the initial intention of providing formal education to elementary and secondary school teachers that were already teaching but did not have a university degree. In addition, according to MEC, the program intends to promote the “development of distance education in Brazil“ and aims to expand and interiorize the offering of undergraduate distance education degree programs ([external address omitted] [historical link unavailable]). The UAB program, consequently, has the aim of providing opportunities for students from parts of Brazil in which there are no university campuses and no undergraduate degree programs offered. 105 (one-hundred and five) universities are offering 702 (seven-hundred and two) undergraduate and degree programs through 645 (six-hundred and forty-five) learning centers located in all of the 27 (twenty-seven) Brazilian States with approximately 200.000 students enrolled (see Table 1). The UAB system works in an institutional partnership between CAPES (Ministry of Education Agency), which supports the system financially, the universities that develop, administrate and implement the degree programs, and the counties or states that provide the physical structure of the learning centers.

Participant Universities 105
Undergraduate/ Graduate Degree Programs 702
Learning Centers 645
Students Enrolled Approximately 200.000
Table 1 - The numbers of the UAB system.

Universidade de Brasília (UnB) - the university in which I work as a professor – currently offers online undergraduate degree programs in many areas, including Visual Arts, Biology, Geography, Pedagogy, Portuguese, Drama, Physical Education, and Music. The UnB distance education degree program in music was initiated in 2007 within the scope of the UAB program. Students from 6 (six) Brazilian states (Acre, Bahia, Goiás, Mato Grosso, Tocantins e Roraima) and 12 (twelve) learning centers (see Table 2) have been enrolled in the program. It is important to emphasize that – as aforementioned - due to the fact the UAB program has the intention of interiorizing the offering of degree programs, most of the learning centers are located in small towns.

State - Learning Center
Acre - Acrelândia, Brasileia, Cruzeiro do Sul, Rio Branco, Sena Madureira, Xapuri.
Goiás - Anápolis, Posse.
Mato Grosso - Primavera do Leste.
Minas Gerais - Buritis, Ipatinga.
Roraima - Boa Vista.
Tocantins - Porto Nacional.
Table 2 – States and Learning Centers of the UnB undergraduate degree program in music.

Positive

So far, more than 100 (one-hundred) students have graduated from the referred program, which means that new music teachers are now able to work for the first time in areas of the country where there wasn’t any music teacher before. This can be considered a significant accomplishment, since in 2008 the government enacted a law stating that music is as compulsory subject in the curriculum of elementary schools in Brazil (Brasil, 2008).

One may now ask: What does technology have to do with this? Well, the aforementioned degree program - except for the mandatory face-to-face moments , - is taught online, which means that several examples of digital technology content are employed. Firstly, it is important to mention that online music education became possible only recently, due to the advent of the World Wide Web. Moreover, according to Bowman (2014), online education is a multiple field and provides:

Opportunities to develop creative new approaches and challenges to stretch the boundaries of music instruction to harness the power of new technologies and pedagogical models in the service of the art and craft of online music instruction (Bowman, 2014, p. ix)

Therefore, it can be assumed that the impact of the technology in the communities of the aforementioned small towns in Brazil can be considered as positive as they now have new music teachers with a degree in music and this is only possible due to the facilities provided by the online technologies. It is worth mentioning that before that, any teacher working in an elementary school (even with a degree in chemistry) could teach music. Since, as mentioned, now in Brazil music is a compulsory component due to the absence of music degree programs in these areas of the country, anyone could attempt to teach music in the elementary schools of these areas. Not to mention, this could happen in big cities as well. What exactly does it mean to have a music teacher that is a graduate from a degree program in music instead of a music teacher without a degree in music? Well, the answer for this question is beyond the scope of this article. Many authors, such a Bellochio (2003) Penna (2007), and Sobreira (2008) have discussed the importance of a degree in music education for music teachers. Bellochio (2003) for instance, affirms that in order to teach music, it is essential that the music teacher can understand education in the following aspects: philosophical, psychological, sociological and pedagogical. Her or she could only achieve this by undertaking a degree in music education. It is important to mention this in order to emphasize the positive impacts of technology on those communities.

Negative

In an online program, when we mean technology it is obvious that we don’t mean only the World Wide Web. A lot of digital technologies are employed in the teaching and learning processes. In the UnB program, for instance, there are the so-called author professors. These professors are the ones who design the courses and are also responsible for elaborating the didactic material and consequently for the employment of the technologies in the teaching processes of the courses. Since the aforementioned program is taught at distance, many digital technologies are used in the teaching and learning process such as: audio, graphics, video, online software, MIDI, and others. The author professors then choose the digital technologies they believe are the most appropriate for a given activity. However – as UnB does no offer a proper training for these professors for the elaboration of the multimedia content of the courses – the authors use the technologies randomly and not according to any research conducted in the music technology education field (Costa & Marins, 2015). This can lead sometimes to a limitation or even to an underestimation, or even a bad use of the technology. Costa & Marins (2015) analyzed how the author professors developed a keyboard course for the UnB degree. They found that the professors tend to use the technology that they are more familiar with. Also, one of the 3 (three) professors interviewed in the study conducted by Costa & Marins (2015) affirmed that her or she used mainly audio because he or she thought that this was the most appropriate technology to teach keyboard at distance. This conflicts with what Moore & Kearsley (2007) state, as these authors suggest that online professors need to be creative and use a variety of media in order to teach in online environments.

Another negative impact of the technology can be related to constraints. Internet 2, for instance, is not available in these communities of Brazil. Therefore, the students have access to slow Internet speeds, and so they have to download video content rather than stream. That is similar to the case reported in the study conducted in Kruse, Harlos, Callahan, & Herring (2013) in which the researchers investigated the viability of piano lessons through the videoconference program Skype. Moreover, Bowman (2014) affirms that good quality videoconference is a recent technology and restricted to limited populations. Nonetheless, many researchers such as Braga (2009), Moore & Kearsley (2007), Kruse, Harlos, Callahan, & Herring (2013) (2013) and Waldron (2013) emphasize the benefits of the use of synchronous technologies such as videoconference in online education. Moreover, technologies constraints are not only related to the lack of Internet 2 or bad Internet connections in schools or communities. Videoconference software like the aforementioned Skype was not developed for broadcasting music but rather to convey speech. Thus the frequency range of the videoconference audio content is between 80 to 80.000 Hz - whereas it is known that the frequency range of the human hearing is approximately 20 to 20.000 Hz. Therefore – in an applied music lesson for instance - it might be difficult for the instructor to give feedback to their students, especially in terms of artistic and aesthetic aspects of music (Shepard, Howe, & Snook, 2008). For this reason this type of software can not be considered as ideal for music lessons, although it can be very useful in terms of oral communication between the instructor and the student. Another common issue in synchronous communication is latency. This occurs due to the fact that there is a lot of data conversion involved in the audio stream process (the analog sound is captured by the microphone, converted to digital and then converted into a format that can be transmitted), and in each conversion step can generate a delay effect or the so-called encoding latency.

Mitigating

In order to mitigate the aforementioned negative aspects related to technology, some measures can be taken: 1) Proper training for the author professors. This type of training would necessarily involve not only the use of existing technologies but also the discussion about the research that has been conducted in terms of the employment of digital technologies for online teaching; 2) More research concerning the use of technology for online music education. According to Bowman (2014), little has been conducted in that subject; 3) the use of proper equipment in video lessons, which would include: software developed for transmitting music content without data compression, high-speed Internet connection, and appropriate microphones and loudspeakers for capturing and reproducing the sounds of the instruments; and 4) and in terms of the specificities of the communities of the learning centers cited here, the governments (federal, and state) should invest more in the structure of the learning centers.

FINAL CONSIDERATIONS

This paper discussed the impacts of use of technologies in music education is some communities of Brazil. The main focus here was the undergraduate distance education degree program in music offered by Universidade de Brasília. It was found that through the possibilities of the online technologies a considerable number of new music teachers could now teach in elementary schools in Brazil. Although the literature points that this is positive, the real impact of this situation still deserves further research. It was also mentioned here that due to lack of proper training some instructors still don’t know how to use digital technologies properly in order to perform their teaching. Moreover, it is known that technology constraints can still be barriers for the online music teaching and learning processes. Nonetheless, it can be inferred that some actions, such as i) proper training for the professors, ii) more governmental investment in terms of structure, iii) use of adequate equipment, and iv) the conducting of more specific research in the field could mitigate the negative aspects of the use of technology in the aforementioned degree program. It is hoped that this manuscript will lead to discussions and further research concerning the use of technology in music education and more specifically about the teaching and learning processes of online music education.

REFERENCES

Bellochi, C. R. (2003) A formação profissional do educador musical: algumas apostas. Porto Alegre-RS: Revista da ABEM, n. 8, p. 17-24.

Bowman, J. (2014) Online Learning in Music. Foundations, Frameworks, and Practices. New York: Oxford University Press.
Braga, P.D.A. (2009) Oficina de violão: estrutura de ensino e padrões de interação em um curso coletivo a distância. 2009. 320 f. Tese (Doutorado em Música). Salvador: Universidade Federal da Bahia…

Brasil (2008). Lei 11.769, de 18 de agosto de 2008. Brasília: Presidência da República.

Brasil (2005). Decreto 5622, de 19 de Dezembro. Brasília: Ministério da Educação.

Brasil (2006). Decreto, de 8 de junho de 2006. Brasília: Ministério da Educação.

Moore, M. & Kearsley, G. (2007). Educação a distância: uma visão integrada. Tradução: Roberto Gelman. São Paulo: Cengage Learning.

Costa, H. S. B. & Marins, P. R. A. (2015). A Docência On-line: Um Caso no Ensino de Teclado na Licenciatura em Música a Distância da UnB. EAD em Foco, v. 05, p. 280.

Kruse, N. B., Harlos S.C., Callahan R. M., e Herring M.L. (2013) HERRING, Michelle L. Skype Music Lessons in the Academy: Intersections of Music Education, Applied Music and Technology. In: Journal of Music, Technology & Education, v. 6, n. 1, p. 43-60.

Penna, M. (2007) Não basta tocar? Discutindo a formação do educador musical. Porto Alegre-RS: Revista da ABEM, 16, 49-56.

Sheppard, B.K, Howe, G, & Snook T. (2008) Internet 2 and Musical Applications. Proceedings of the National Association of Schools of Music 84th Annual Meeting, Seattle.

Sobreira, S. (2008) Reflexões sobre a obrigatoriedade da música nas escolas públicas. Porto Alegre-RS: Revista da ABEM, 20, 45-52.

Waldron, J. (2013) YouTube, Fanvids, Forums, Vlogs and Blogs: Informal Music Learning in a Convergent On- and Offline Music Community. In: International Journal of Music Education, v. 31, n. 1, p. 91-105.

Core perspective · 2B

Open original entry ↗

Pedagogical Fundamentalism to Radical Pedagogy in Music Education

Due to the increasing media influence in society, the importance of systematic development of media literacy in music education is a matter of the utmost importance. This chapter engages in an exploration of the role of the school in the face of the social-cultural changes that new media technologies have brought about in the wider culture of music making and learning. It is argued that it is equally unhelpful to adopt the strategy of “pedagogical fundamentalism”, according to which students are passive victims of harmful and damaging media, as that of “pedagogical populism”, which uncritically buys into utopian fantasies about social change autonomously produced by technology. Instead, the chapter argues for the importance of radical pedagogy in music education by suggesting that schools should aim to build balanced approaches to new media that will contribute to the development of the cultural competencies required for students’ growth into digital citizenship.

Core perspective · 2B

Open original entry ↗

Locating Technology Within Music Education

Technology’s place in music education is largely related to how it is socially constituted. Despite how technology enables intersections of and blurred boundaries between ways of being musical, it is often situated in terms of hard boundaries and compartmentalized notions of musical engagement. Furthermore, music education often situates technology as tools without necessarily considering related social, cultural or musical contexts. This chapter addresses how philosophical, pedagogical, and curricular perspectives play a key role in the types and degree of change that occur in relation to technology and music education. I propose that music educators re-conceptualize curriculum and re-situate technology to address social and cultural issues explicitly. I invite music educators to consider the potential of digitally mediated musical engagement within the contexts of curriculum as experience and as social reconstruction. I consider how such change might occur and conceptual frameworks that might help in forwarding such work.

Core perspective · 2B

Open original entry ↗

Society, Schools, and Music Learning

This chapter examines how music education can benefit from the use of new electronic tools and materials for music making that allow learners to combine their interests and prior understandings toward deepening their engagement in music. By exploring how rhythmic videogames like Rock Band bridge the large chasm that exists between youths’ music culture and traditional music education; how inexpensive recording hardware and software such as Audacity and Apple Garageband has provided youth with opportunities to compose and perform as only professional musicians could in the past; and how software like Impromptu successfully engages youth in music composition and analysis by enabling users to create and remix tunes using virtual blocks that contain portions of melodies and/or rhythmic patterns, this chapter argues 21st-century music education, with the help of new technology, has the potential for engaging greater numbers of young learners in authentic music making and performance.

Further perspective · 2A

Open original entry ↗

Exploring Intersections of Technology and Music Education

In revisiting the music technology practices in the three contexts described by Pignato, Peppler, and Kigozi, this chapter foregrounds the playfulness and informality that frequently interlinks technologies and innovation. It outlines the ways that human-technology outputs are frequently generated through experimental and exploratory approaches to learning, rather than those that tend toward the sequential, linear and pre-determined. Context plays a key role, as different settings afford access to different technologies. Regardless of how advanced our technological capabilities become, innovation and the creation of new musical expressions remain products of humans interacting and exploring within a specific context and its available technologies and resources.

Further perspective · 2A

Open original entry ↗

Human Potential, Technology and Music Education

Technology, music and education, the interrelations and interactions between them as well their impact on music education and young people’s lives, are explored in the core perspectives of this section. Writers describe how technology enables boundaries’ transcendence between formal and informal learning and school life and personal life, potentially providing the necessary bridge that would transform music learning. At the same time, a number of threats from the use of technology in education and music education are recognized. Further discourse and caution, as well as further research is important in order to explore and clarify potential opportunities for a more humane education and future.

Further perspective · 2A

Open original entry ↗

The Promise and Pitfalls of the Digital Studio

Whether or not we make the best use of technology in the music classroom, young people will continue to find unexpected uses for it elsewhere. There is no historical precedent for the informal learning possibilities afforded by inexpensive and ubiquitous computers. Are young music learners best left to their own devices, literally and figuratively? Or can we structure a classroom around these devices, combining independent play with guided group activity? Will formal educational settings will always compromise or even negate young people’s autonomy and independence? Perhaps if we think of the music room as a maker space rather than a classroom, we can admit some of the imaginative play and authentic expressiveness that students find outside of school. Music education will happen wherever people gather together, using whatever materials are at hand. A school is necessarily an ad-hoc society; ideally, it can be a genuine artistic community as well.

Further perspective · 2A

Open original entry ↗

Musicking and Technology in Sweden

Computers and digital instruments change the way we think about ourselves and other people, demonstrated by an example with a girl who imagined that she had a computer in her brain where she could click on “Music” in the menu to hear music. This chapter argues that good music technology should allow play and unpredictable events and support a balance between challenge and ability. Digital instruments should also make it possible to revise and develop musical compositions.

Musicking and music creation with digital tools may be vital for children and young people in need of special support, although many children would use any tool available, including their own imagination and fantasy. Musical activities are closely related to play and flow and have measurable biological effects, which makes musicking not only a matter of aesthetics and learning, but also of health and well-being.

Further perspective · 2A

Open original entry ↗

‘Placing’ technology within music education communities

The perspective in this chapter focuses on the themes of context and community in ‘situating’ technology within music education in this section. Here, the centrality of both musical and social interactions within technological developments is explored. Opportunities are discussed in light of the core perspectives provided to examine how we might develop further ways to engage learners in technology-mediated musical experiences that espouse collaborative knowledge building and learning through participation. As music educators, learners, researchers and/or policymakers we are prompted to challenge our assumptions about what technology within music education actually means to different contexts, places and peoples. An argument for fostering “communities of musical practice” within technology and music education is thus put forward.

Further perspective · 2B

Open original entry ↗

On Becoming Musical: Technology, Possibilities, and Transformation

This further perspective examines the role of both high and low-tech solutions, when using music technology as a form of reflective practice in working with special needs populations. Music teachers are often given little coursework in working with at-risk and special needs students. It is little wonder that music teacher attitudes are often negative regarding the inclusion of these students in music activities, whether it’s in a general music class or ensembles. Rather than marginalizing these students, music technology can be adapted to allow even the most severely impacted student a means to music participation in school settings. Providing music education students with context specific field experiences working with a variety of special needs populations can help students realize the musical potential of all students.

Further perspective · 2B

Open original entry ↗

Thinking and Talking about Change in Music Education

Employing the concepts of linguistic relativity and metaphor (after Lakoff and Johnson), the author considers in this further perspective how our thinking about technology and music education is conceptually driven. So long as terms such as “literacy” or “musicianship” and metaphors of virtuosity, talent, and expressiveness continue to drive our thinking, technology will continue to exist outside the human endeavor of music learning in our thinking. Change will only occur when we generate new ways of thinking and talking about what we do. Concepts such as technogenesis, pedagogical fundamentalism, mediatization, and passeur culturel offer intriguing possibilities for helping us to transcend received ways of thinking and talking about practices in music education.

Further perspective · 2B

Open original entry ↗

Technology in Perspective: Who is in Control?

It is commonly known that the assimilation and use of technology that is vertically mandated, without a critical consideration of final users, presents various risks such as an inadequate and unreflective use of technology. For instance, new technological tools tend to be used only to facilitate aspects of traditional teaching practices, without changing previous pedagogical paradigms. One of the main causes is that many teachers have not acquired the expertise to take full advantage of innovative teaching/learning technologies. For an adequate music education provision, music educators must respond distinctively and effectively by considering the socio-cultural and educational context. In this chapter, it is argued that music teacher education and professional initiatives must be focused on empowering music teachers to critically decide the degree of technological assimilation and distinction in order to meet the standards of quality education.

Further perspective · 2B

Open original entry ↗

The Curious Musician

Music technologies have lead us to a transformation of perceptions and the reinvention and refinement of our creative music making. They have also transformed our language and are providing access to musical and sonic possibilities that transcend the facilities of traditional music notation and analysis. They can facilitate new ways of collaborating and sharing and have become intertwined with almost all commercial and contemporary arts practices in the 21st century. Within this contemporary digital cultural landscape, a fluent and adaptable working knowledge of music technology should be foundational to any taught music curriculum. This chapter looks at examples from contemporary practice to inform a strategy for developing effective curricula for higher music education where fluency in digital literacies is promoted through practice-led enquiry and adopting the mindset of the ‘curious musician’.

Further perspective · 2B

Open original entry ↗

A Sociological Perspective on Technology in Music Education

This writing will consider the questions’ Where is technology within music education? Who is affected and how?’ from a perspective drawn from sociology and in particular the sociology of music education. I will discuss the emergence of a Totally Technologized Society, akin to the Totally Pedagogised Society identified by Bernstein (2000) and consider its implications for music technology and music education. I will suggest that many students exist in an educational technotopia that offers great potential within models such as informal music learning for more equitable models of music education.

Further perspective · 2B

Open original entry ↗

The Role of Music in Public Health Education

This essay analyses the Ebola-themed songs produced during the Ebola outbreak of 2014 in West Africa and discusses what role music can play in improving the effectiveness of public health communication. The essay also questions the role of western music celebrities in advocating for international development challenges in the context of global public health crises.